Poodlestrike
Banned
Can we all make friends and agree Captain Phasma was wasted potential.
She really is the new Boba Fett.
Can we all make friends and agree Captain Phasma was wasted potential.
Can someone tell me the moment Ren's lineage is revealed? My boyfriend swears the speech to Vader's mask included the word grandfather, but I and the rest of the theatre gasped when Snope plainly revealed it in a later scene.
Can someone tell me the moment Ren's lineage is revealed? My boyfriend swears the speech to Vader's mask included the word grandfather, but I and the rest of the theatre gasped when Snope plainly revealed it in a later scene.
The whole series starts off with a series of very unlikely coincidences in ANH.Okay, I'll say this then: The writing is weak, and (as I've mentioned before) the characters get pushed around by the plot rather than the characters doing the work. There are numerous examples of this throughout the movie with the first and second acts basically amount to character A runs into character B before A and B run into character C.
Why? Coincidence. That's right... Finn and Rey (who may or may not be Luke's daughter) just so happen to pick the millennium falcon and just so happen to run into Han Solo (despite him having lost the falcon decades ago) who just so happens to be the father of the bad guy and the estranged spouse of a resistance general who needs the very thing that Poe (who Finn who just happens to run into) was after in the first place.
You want to know my core problems with the movie (as opposed to the stuff built around it), then the above is a good start.
"Will of the Force."
There is a fair amount of backstory to ANH, with Kenobi (who was intentionally watching over Luke) being a big part of that. If that was rewritten to the same standards of TFA then Luke would coincidentally run into Kenobi, one of the few master Jedi in existence.The whole series starts off with a series of very unlikely coincidences in ANH.
Rey says it herself that the ship hasn't been flown in years.yeah, Im guessing the logic is it can only be tracked when its on, or maybe out in space. And I recall that its been parked for a looong time. Hence why he shows up almost immediately.
yeah, Im guessing the logic is it can only be tracked when its on, or maybe out in space. And I recall that its been parked for a looong time. Hence why he shows up almost immediately.
Uh huh.
Rey says it herself that the ship hasn't been flown in years.
yeah, Im guessing the logic is it can only be tracked when its on, or maybe out in space. And I recall that its been parked for a looong time. Hence why he shows up almost immediately.
I agree JJ certainly relies on coincidence a lot in his other films and maybe a bit too much in this. This film follows the template of A New Hope pretty closely (probably to its detriment), but the coincidences are very similar to that films, so i'm a bit more forgiving. Plus the force guiding them and fate and all that which have always been components of the series.Okay, I'll say this then: The writing is weak, and (as I've mentioned before) the characters get pushed around by the plot rather than the characters doing the work. There are numerous examples of this throughout the movie with the first and second acts basically amount to character A runs into character B before A and B run into character C.
Why? Coincidence. That's right... Finn and Rey (who may or may not be Luke's daughter) just so happen to pick the millennium falcon and just so happen to run into Han Solo (despite him having lost the falcon decades ago) who just so happens to be the father of the bad guy and the estranged spouse of a resistance general who needs the very thing that Poe (who Finn just happens to run into) was after in the first place.
You want to know my core problems with the movie (as opposed to the stuff built around it), then the above is a good start.
Finn was easily the worst part of the film which was incredibly frustrating. His actions half the time was because of some reason and you could have almost entierly written his character our and it wouldn't have changed the story.
Finn was easily the worst part of the film which was incredibly frustrating. His actions half the time was because of some reason and you could have almost entierly written his character our and it wouldn't have changed the story.
You could take Indy out of Raiders and the movie unfolds the same way. Doesn't mean him or Finn aren't good characters though.. (also who rescues Poe).Finn was easily the worst part of the film which was incredibly frustrating. His actions half the time was because of some reason and you could have almost entierly written his character our and it wouldn't have changed the story.
If the other droid doesn't break down, Luke's uncle never buys R2 and he never gets involved. That's carefully integrated into the plot?There is a fair amount of backstory to ANH, with Kenobi (who was intentionally watching over Luke) being a big part of that. If that was rewritten to the same standards of TFA then Luke would coincidentally run into Kenobi, one of the few master Jedi in existence.
But coming across Han Solo was the biggest WTF for me. They should have at least tried to more carefully integrate that into the plot.
Finn was easily the worst part of the film which was incredibly frustrating. His actions half the time was because of some reason and you could have almost entierly written his character our and it wouldn't have changed the story.
So you ignore that Han says he tracked the Falcon? He didn't just happen to run into it.
Ending was fine IMO, it's clear he'll train her.If there's one thing I'd change, it'd be the ending:
- Rey and Chewie wouldn't find Luke yet. Instead, end with them still preparing the trip, talking about finding Luke with the other characters.
CUT TO:
- Inside secret Jedi temple:
Hooded Luke, back turned to us, moving down a dark corridor. He comes into a room with engraved walls, with a single Holocron sitting on a dusty stone table. Some rustling/whispers are heard. He grabs the Holocron with his bionic hand and removes his hood, slightly turning his head, but enough for the audience to recognize him.
Stuffs the Holocron in his robe and draws his green lightsaber, lighting it up by his side, still with his back to us.
Some more rustling/whispers. Luke fully turns, gets into an attack pose and runs/hastily paces towards the camera, fading into CREDITS.
RIP solo the god
Blah , thought he was gonna be taken as prisoner but then people would complain it's just a rehash
The public killed Han Solo
I give it a solid 8/10
After decades of it being missing. "Tracking the falcon" is a hand wave from the writer.
After decades of it being missing. "Tracking the falcon" is a hand wave from the writer.
After decades of it being missing. "Tracking the falcon" is a hand wave from the writer.
After decades of it being missing. "Tracking the falcon" is a hand wave from the writer.
After decades of it being missing. "Tracking the falcon" is a hand wave from the writer.
do we know if its been missing for decades? Honest question.
Finn was easily the worst part of the film which was incredibly frustrating. His actions half the time was because of some reason and you could have almost entierly written his character our and it wouldn't have changed the story.
I had fun watching it. But I'm kinda disappointed there's no sense of continuity from Eps VI, everything just...happens.
I mean who the hell is Snoke? How the hell do these First Order gets into power?
The fight between Finn and that random Stormtrooper was totally done using the Raid dude as it was the best fight in the movie. The final fight looks the prettiest though.
And Rey is totally Han's daughter right? Alot of scenes seems hinting towards that.
I had fun watching it. But I'm kinda disappointed there's no sense of continuity from Eps VI, everything just...happens.
I mean who the hell is Snoke? How the hell do these First Order gets into power?
The fight between Finn and that random Stormtrooper was totally done using the Raid dude as it was the best fight in the movie. The final fight looks the prettiest though.
And Rey is totally Han's daughter right? Alot of scenes seems hinting towards that.
- kylo ren is a powerful force user (keeping a blaster shot suspended and reading minds), with lessons by snoke but gets thrashed by Rey...the duel was awful (zero tension/pacing and came across like two children swinging sticks); again not sure if this was butchered in editing or highlighting Abram's limitations as a filmmaker.
I had fun watching it. But I'm kinda disappointed there's no sense of continuity from Eps VI, everything just...happens.
I mean who the hell is Snoke? How the hell do these First Order gets into power?
The fight between Finn and that random Stormtrooper was totally done using the Raid dude as it was the best fight in the movie. The final fight looks the prettiest though.
And Rey is totally Han's daughter right? Alot of scenes seems hinting towards that.
Finn was easily the worst part of the film which was incredibly frustrating. His actions half the time was because of some reason and you could have almost entierly written his character our and it wouldn't have changed the story.
Finn was easily the worst part of the film which was incredibly frustrating. His actions half the time was because of some reason and you could have almost entierly written his character our and it wouldn't have changed the story.
Can you really blame him? They only went to great lengths to establish the bowcaster as a very powerful weapon, and only zoomed in Kylo's wound and blood. Easy to miss.I
Kylo Ren got shot with Chewbacca's bowcaster. Did you see how that weapon wrecked shit? He was badly wounded. You must not have been paying attention.
Eh
I liked Finn most in this movie. So much heart. Hell, I didn't enjoy the movie as much as I hoped, yet I loved his character.
Opinions...
Finn wasn't too bad during the opening or at the end; I agree his time spent in the middle is largely spent as the guy who reacts to things, but I could get behind him as the lead.
Of the prominently featured characters, the one with the least impact on the story was Leia. She was my least favorite part of the film (sorry guys). Carrie Fisher was showing some great acting chops, but she didn't really have a character to play anymore. She had a conversation with Han to reiterate what the audience had already inferred (that Han wants to bring Ben back from the dark side), said goodbye, then just kind of faded into the background and watched the monitors as a general. She needed more, and I hope she gets more in the coming films.
Anyone else feel that Finn vs SHOCK CHAINSAW Stormtrooper would've been better if it was Phasma? She was really wasted, and I hope she wasn't actually killed off.
yeah, Im guessing the logic is it can only be tracked when its on, or maybe out in space. And I recall that its been parked for a looong time. Hence why he shows up almost immediately.
I mean who the hell is Snoke? How the hell do these First Order gets into power?
I admit I was disappointed snoke wasn't in fact a giant
That would have been ridiculous in a fun way