-
Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!
Eurogamer: NX = portable w/ carts, detachable controllers, Tegra, TV Out, no BC, Sept
- Thread starter Wollan
- Start date
- Status
Entertaining that hypothetical speculation and getting hyped up like posters i see is making it a plausible scenario. It needs to be held firmly at arms length
If playing a Pokémon game on NX is your idea of "console Pokémon" then you can just go back and get an SNES, Super Gameboy, and Pokémon Red/Blue/Yellow.
Seriously, I don't get why people keep saying this lol
This is such a bullshit statement. Just admit that you were wrong in thinking this was just some kind of talk between Emily and Eurogamer. It's not gonna hurt.
James Scott
Banned
there isn't. No word on power or what the controls do either
Eolz
Member
Edit on topic: going higher than 720p would be madness. If it's just a custom X1, they'll likely go 540p. X2 and it's 720p.
I don't see the point in turning that into some sort of witch hunt from both sides tbh. Most of the other sources have second-hand info and aren't really making that as clear as talking about the eurogamer statement.
I don't see the point in turning that into some sort of witch hunt from both sides tbh. Most of the other sources have second-hand info and aren't really making that as clear as talking about the eurogamer statement.
How do you know what kind of sources do they have?
Edit: what even makes a info second hand? What's first hand? A statement from Kimishima?
Eolz
Member
To reply to your pre-edit reply: did you even read the quotes?
Post-edit: of course not, but that's not giving any hints about how credible that source might be either. It's not like getting the PS4 Neo confidential docs for example.
Bam Chowder
Member
Feeling a lot of mixed emotions on this, very reminiscent of how I felt during the lead up and reveal of the Wii U.
But ultimately, it's going to be the software that sells me on the NX and unified development on one platform has a lot of potential to do that. Bayonetta 2 sold me on the Wii U and its turned out to be one of my favorite systems. The launch line-up and initial marketing is going to be critical in making NX a success imo.
But ultimately, it's going to be the software that sells me on the NX and unified development on one platform has a lot of potential to do that. Bayonetta 2 sold me on the Wii U and its turned out to be one of my favorite systems. The launch line-up and initial marketing is going to be critical in making NX a success imo.
And yet you classify the info as second-hand info without a shadow of doubt. Even if you have no idea how credible it is.
DrROBschiz
Member
How about you read my posts first
And grapple the context as me trying to figure out why a leak this big has so little commentary
Also stop acting like its some sort of personal attack
Also no conspiracy theory was ever posed in any of my posts
Ok, excuse the extremely crude mock up here (my skillz lack) but here is my guess at what this will look like. I think the touchscreen button patent is at play here:
An example, playing Breath of the Wild:
The actions mapped to the D-Pad on Wii U, now have their own custom buttons on the left panel and the traditional ABXY appear on the right.
As an example, New Super Mario Bros Local Multiplayer:
The controller are detached, and both players have A/B on their controller plus navigation
I admit I was wrong (see, it's not that difficult). You didn't start the conspiracy theory, you just piggybacked on it.
And you're still trying to deny the validity of several separate reports about the same info from several very reputable sources.
Shadowlink
Member
Excited to see more in September. I believe Nintendo will surprise all of us.
SinCityAssassin
Member
This is based on the assumption that because they didn't SAY it was there, it does not exist.
Imagine something like a board game being played out with Amiibo figures, and with all stats / attack animations happening on screen. My first thought is something akin to Advance Wars. It might require a printed board to make it more comprehensible.
ShockingAlberto
Member
I wonder if the patent for the button screen was for when the handheld doesn't have any controllers attached.
Potentially, but somehow I doubt it. It seems too good to be true. I fully expect a screen/tablet only mode, but pop up tactile buttons are a pipe dream. Maybe for NX2.
Hell, Phillip K. Dick's estate might have something to say about it.
Thank you. So, really no basis to be saying it at all at this point as I understand it.
Eolz
Member
I classify it like this because that's what it is. Not sure where the problem is with that.
DrROBschiz
Member
Nope never did in fact i went out of my way to point out the the eurogamer leaks were the only source worth discussing
I was already corrected on and updated on the corroboration from other sites
What is interesting is the lack or varied details meaning everyones corroborations must be link to developer dev kits.
I was just curious that the news didnt snowball and we were getting new details that werent already delivered by eurogamer
Meaning Eurogamer was thorough as fuck covering every angle that could be infered from the dev kits or there really is nothing else Nintendo is putting out there to leak
James Scott
Banned
While that tech might be good for something in the future, I imagine it'll be a bit too expensive for right now. I imagine that after the industry rejected the Wii U they probably decided against high cost, controller based gimmicks.
Benjamin1981
Member
Hopefully the handheld can be docked without detaching the controls every time i want to play on the TV. This seems so unecessary and Kids will break those things easily. Just bundle a bluetooth controller.
It's second hand info because the source doesn't write the article him or herself? How does this work? What has this to do with the credibility of the source?
I've been busy at work so I didn't read all the info and the thread yet, but I'd like to write down my 2cents. Sorry if some is incorrect because I don't have all the "facts" yet... Feel free to correct me if I got something wrong!
-I know several media sites and insiders are reporting this so that could mean it's the real deal, but I want to think this is just another rumor. I know it's not the same but some journalists also said that infamous controller mock up was real, too...
-I had the impression that many developers hinted heavily about NX being a console not a handheld... Even if this kinda "transforms" into a console, something doesn't feel right...
Things I like:
-Unified library (could be achievable with two or more different SKU as many speculated)
-Game Cards (I hope the standard is 32/64GB with smaller capacities as an option)
-A new Mario Maker will be possible with this set up
Things I don't like:
-I don't commute so I play always at home. I prefer my monitor or TV to play games. I know there would be a "base" to connect this to my TV but... It's still a handheld... With all its limitations... If I'm going to use it always like a console I'd want a proper stationary console...
-Or the screen will be too small to play games like BotW (it's already difficult to play XCX on the Game Pad so...), or too big for people that want to put it on their pockets.
-Probable battery issues if the thing is too small and still more powerful than a Wii U.
-The power of the system. I'm 35 and to think I'll need to wait another 5+ years to see some Nintendo franchises evolved graphically it's depressing... I'm not a graphics whore, but damn...
Now some questions for some kind soul...
-What are the main differences between X1 and X2 chips?
-There's any info about if the "base" would improve the power of this thing when connected (SCD) or only a dummy charger with HDMI input?
Thank you!
-I know several media sites and insiders are reporting this so that could mean it's the real deal, but I want to think this is just another rumor. I know it's not the same but some journalists also said that infamous controller mock up was real, too...
-I had the impression that many developers hinted heavily about NX being a console not a handheld... Even if this kinda "transforms" into a console, something doesn't feel right...
Things I like:
-Unified library (could be achievable with two or more different SKU as many speculated)
-Game Cards (I hope the standard is 32/64GB with smaller capacities as an option)
-A new Mario Maker will be possible with this set up
Things I don't like:
-I don't commute so I play always at home. I prefer my monitor or TV to play games. I know there would be a "base" to connect this to my TV but... It's still a handheld... With all its limitations... If I'm going to use it always like a console I'd want a proper stationary console...
-Or the screen will be too small to play games like BotW (it's already difficult to play XCX on the Game Pad so...), or too big for people that want to put it on their pockets.
-Probable battery issues if the thing is too small and still more powerful than a Wii U.
-The power of the system. I'm 35 and to think I'll need to wait another 5+ years to see some Nintendo franchises evolved graphically it's depressing... I'm not a graphics whore, but damn...
Now some questions for some kind soul...
-What are the main differences between X1 and X2 chips?
-There's any info about if the "base" would improve the power of this thing when connected (SCD) or only a dummy charger with HDMI input?
Thank you!
SporeCrawler
Member
so using cartridges makes it clear for me that its meant to be a handheld with TV out and not a console with handheld functionality.
There's a whole separate thread about that, fyi.
evilromero
Member
I like the idea of having one Nintendo device that is both a home platform and mobile if I choose. But I'll mostly leave it docked for play on my TV so I'm curious about what the control method is in that case.
Important note: The Tegra K1 Shield Tablet from 2014 launched at $300, but that's with an 8-inch 1080p screen. I'd say that $200 isn't a problem. However, I think they'll stick with the X1 just because Nintendo literally prefers using older, proven tech. The next-gen Tegra really should be available to partners already, and I'd think that Nintendo would have told devs that X1 wouldn't be the basis for the final chip.
$150 is impossible. $200 is the minimum, even if it uses the X1.
SporeCrawler
Member
I hope its compatible to the Wiimote and the WiiU Pro Pad
my guess is 250 with a packed in game (possibly Pokemon Go Plus).
Mithos
Member
They are just talking about what the X2 is in that section, not actually saying the NX is using an X2.
My take on the power situation. Nintendo need to be able to run most modern 3rd party engines on the NX for it to work. Specifically Frostbyte. Currently Frostbyte runs at 720/60 on the Xbox one (1.2 AMD Tflps) if the NX is a handheld that is around .5 Nvidia Tflps @1GHz (possible with the X2) then that would put it at 2/3 of an Xbox Ones power in a 5-10W window and it should be able to run Frostbyte at 540/60 something that's more then acceptable for a handheld. Battery life might be a little low, but if the battery is removeable or has modern quick charge tech that's hardly a dealbreaker. Especially with a NX XL probably due holiday 2017
The real question becomes the dock. If it's just a turbo boost it couldn't be more then 3GHz which would make a .5Tflp NX @1GHz Roughly equivalent to 2.3 AMD Tflps which is near PS4 Power levels. If the dock has some form of discrete GPU say another X2 it could hit That performance level at a lower power window.
However some have speculated on GAF that it could even be a discrete 1050 which would give the NX when docked Neo/Scorpio level power
Pricing will probably start a little high 299USD for a device with the X2 seems possible. But if Nintendo bundles its key Wii U ports (Mario Maker, Splatoon and Smash Bros) they can essentially break even while convincing the public the NX is a 250USD device.
The real question becomes the dock. If it's just a turbo boost it couldn't be more then 3GHz which would make a .5Tflp NX @1GHz Roughly equivalent to 2.3 AMD Tflps which is near PS4 Power levels. If the dock has some form of discrete GPU say another X2 it could hit That performance level at a lower power window.
However some have speculated on GAF that it could even be a discrete 1050 which would give the NX when docked Neo/Scorpio level power
Pricing will probably start a little high 299USD for a device with the X2 seems possible. But if Nintendo bundles its key Wii U ports (Mario Maker, Splatoon and Smash Bros) they can essentially break even while convincing the public the NX is a 250USD device.
Joelstinton14
Member
I think we can safely say that this Eurogamer article is the real deal or based on proper information and sources. They're a reputable gaming website and would not publish this without sources they have verified. It read as a proper report with clear information. I think it is fair to say that the information is out there. I wouldn't be surprised if Nintendo themselves allowed the information to be published to give people a rough idea of what to expect, and set expectations lower when it comes to out right power (basically internet gaming fans).
As for the controller mock up, i don't think any website published an article saying This is the NX controller, rather they published articles asking Is this the NX controller?
SporeCrawler
Member
I still will not believe it 100% unless nintendo announces it.
Chezzymann
Member
So is it realistic for it to be $250 with the X2?
DrROBschiz
Member
Yeah im leaning on this idea
250 seems like a target with those specs though i wouldnt be surprised if they pushed 300
ultrazilla
Gold Member
It'd be interesting if Nintendo made the tablet similar to the patent they had for that oval shaped screen. There could be one attachment that allows you to insert it into a more classic controller design with handles, D-pad, stick and buttons. The other attachment could be a clamshell design where the Oval screen functions as the top of the clamshell and the bottom half has the buttons, sticks, and D-pad. Have the Oval tablet be about 7" long and be able to play some games without either attachment. Here is the design/Mockup I'm referring to:
This excellent fan made video here is basically showing what I'm talking about. It's using the Sharp Free Form display tech. I believe he's a fellow Gaffer!
Also interesting is that he named the system/controller the "Nintendo Go" and this was back in January when he posted the video. I'm of the opinion that Nintendo
will end up naming the console the "Nintendo GO".
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=udkU101fFOk
My mock-up would be two controllers attaching together for either a single screen held horizontally or held vertically to mimic a DS/3DS with touchscreen on the bottom.
No mention of screens on the controllers in the Eurogamer "leak/story" because the controller *IS* the screen ie: video above.
- Status