There are plenty of reasons to believe that number two is false. I don't need to recite everything all over again. You should really consider all of that information.
Also for the exact same "who on top of who scenario", two other eye witnesses have said otherwise.
The reasons people have given for number two being false basically amount to conspiracy theories, and "I dont' see any blood in this video taken 30 minutes later, so it can't be true".
I'm not saying the police are 100% credible, but the first cop on the scene said Zimmerman had some blood from his nose, and on the back of his head. Make of that what you will, but it's in the report, and it would be a very random thing for a cop to just create out of thin air and say on a report.
The same goes for the wet grass on the back of his red jacket. That would be a very random thing to just make up and put in your police report.
The "on top" scenario is only questionable because people are trying to put different statements together at different times, and say they're the same. While the scuffle was happening, a 911 caller said "a guy in a white shirt is on top of the other one".
I'm not aware of a single other person who says they saw different while the scuffle was occurring. I am aware of others saying after the shot was heard, they then saw Zimmerman on top of Martin. AFTER the gun shot was heard.
Zimmerman was wearing a white shirt under the coat.
Yes, but the first cop on the scene said he was wearing his red jacket, and it had wet grass on the back of it.
So we have a 911 caller saying they see a guy in a "white shirt" on top of the other.
Then we have a cop who shows up and says Zimmerman is wearing his red coat, and it's got grass on the back.
Did the 911 caller and the cop talk before hand, and make sure they had their stories straight? Of course not. So it seems pretty damn likely Zimmerman's coat was always on him.
I'm not so sure about that. Trayvon's hoodie was dark grey. Zimmerman's shirt was light grey. The witnesses described the man on top as wearing a white shirt.
A dark grey is much harder to mistake for white than alight grey. And they said shirt, not sweater, not hoodie.
If zimmerman removed his jacket, it explains why the jacket was wet with stains, why zimmerman was the person the witnesses saw on top, and why they saw him wearing a white shirt (because he removed his jacket).
The question then is, why did he remove his jacket, and what of the alleged bleeding and broken nose?
That is an interesting thought there.
It's just a little weird to imagine him taking off his coat in the heat of the moment.