A completely original "Mahou Shoujo" or Magical Girls game, in typical PG beat 'em up style. Apply those typical character tropes to a bunch of playable characters, and make a fantastical action game with beautiful, bright anime style graphics. This would definitely be my first choice!
Alternatively, an adventure game. What PG (as Clover) achieved with Okami was fabulous: they successfully:
- applied a Zelda-style gameplay/world structure template
- created sumi-e: the game
- incorporated a new mechanic (brush work, integrated into combat, puzzles and overworld) into an adventure game
- created a game where you play as an animal and interact with animals/the environment
As such, I would love for them to make another adventure game using that "Zelda" template, but in a different setting with different gameplay ideas and themes, but with that wonderful level of polish in all areas of the game that I've come to expect from them.
Some adventure game settings I'd love to play from them would be:
- Underwater! Though not necessarily without humans/humanoids.
- Pre-Columbian Indigenous Central American people x Space Aliens
Captain Falcon: The Game.
This again eh?
Captain Falcon action game.
Never get tired of asking for that.
Hahaha, this would be an absolutely INSANE game. Love the idea.