Raise the flame shield: Your "controversial" gaming opinion.

Metal Gear 2: Solid Snake is the second best game in the series after Metal Gear Solid (with Snake Eater coming in at a close third). Ghost Babel is also close up there with MGS3.

Well modern Metal Gears are pretty much evolved Metal Gear 2s, the mechanics introduced in this game were amazingly new and innovative.


For my own controversial opinion:

Ico is far superior than Shadow Of The Collosus and Shadow of The Collosus is overrated , and had a bad ending. I must say, I played the games for the first time about a year ago.
 
*stares back unrepentantly*

It doesn't need to be chrono trigger, it surpassed it. Superior combat, story, environment, and mythos.

*flicks rubberband sharpky at your forehead*

*puts band-aid on forehead, looks around for something to throw while yelling*

No way man. Different styles of combat, but Chrono Trigger is just perfect in that respect. As for environments (any environment you could think of), story (insane amount of possible endings), and mythos (in-dwelt alien villain within the earth), a perfect tale told in 25-30 hours is far more preferable than the forever long BG II. One last thought - characters create the most lasting impression within a story, and CT's are second to none.

*Nothing to throw, shrugs, and offers you a beer*
 
Uncharted 1 is the only good game in the series

PC gaming is far and away superior/better than console gaming

The biggest problem with some of this gens great games is that they are on consoles (Dragon's Dogma immediately comes to mind)

Paper Mario peaked with The Thousand Year Door and has since died and had its corpse mutilated

Skyward Sword is the absolute worst game in the series BUT it also has the best and most enjoyable controls and combat.

Zelda has absolutely no business, nor any place, being even remotely light hearted. Stop being Disney god damn it!

One of Skyward Sword's bigger problems is that despite the prologue it feels like I'm walking through some rejected Disney Land area(s). This is a world ravaged by war between God and the Devil, why does this place look like it was designed by people even Disney
rejected due to it being far too excessively sugar coated?

Stop forcing light hearted bullcrap into/onto things that have no business being light hearted! This goes to everyone but especially Nintendo.

Wind Waker is far, FAR better than Ocarina of Time and far, FAR darker than Skyward Sword.

The Wii U should have had far better hardware.

The top screen on the original 3DS should have been 4 inches and 16:9, MINIMUM

Super Mario Galaxy 2 is the best 3D Mario game despite it looking like it was designed by toddlers all hopped up on sugar and made for newborns who like watching TV's explode into colorful nonsense

Super Mario Galaxy 1 had a good story

Super Mario Galaxy 2 had a great sound track

Tomb Raider (2013) is not a good or great game by any stretch......
I cannot bring myself to state the other end of the spectrum

The first bioshock is a horrible game

My biggest complaint with Skyward Sword is also my biggest complaint with the first Bioshock (Fetch Quest: The Game)

Half Life 2 is one of the most boring games ever created

Bulletstorm is one of the best shooters ever made

Left 4 Dead is one of the worst zombie games ever created (same goes for 2)

Resident Evil 5 is the worst in series

Resident Evil (Game Cube) is one of the best games to feature zombies, period.

Mass Effect has zero replayability

The Witcher games are the only games where choices actually feel like they matter and the only games that I've played that actually seem to do the whole choice thing properly in the first place

Fallout New Vegas is a proper Fallout game, 3 is a boring pile of dulled out boring boring.

Oblivion is terrible

Skyrim is okay with mods

Obsidian should be in charge of the Fallout series

Gamebryo needs to be destroyed

Bethesda can't write worth a damn.

1080p native should have been the standard for Wii U

Mario Kart DS was the last good Mario Kart game

The 3DS has no games, nor does Vita

Epic Mickey was a great movie

Nintendo needs to stop converting their franchises into bridge games (another issue I had with Skyward)

Intel is overrated and overpriced

Games should be a tad more cinematic if the situation calls for it AND have great, deep gameplay to back it up

Video games can outclass both film and novels when done right (Bioshock Infinite comes to mind)

Delays are annoying but not as incredibly irritating as devs releasing teaser trailers for games that won't come out for another half a decade.

That's all that's on my mind right now
 
As much as I love their games, I secretly think Obsidian is kind of bad at making RPGs on their own and should perhaps try their hand at making adventure games that will let them go crazy with their strengths (writing, world building) and not have to worry about their weaknesses.
 
Here's something controversial:

Both Super Metroid and SotN are unique and amazing games that don't need to be directly compared to each other each time one of them is mentioned.
 
Rumble is pointless and stupid. The only time Rumble actually enhanced a game was in Wii Sports when you hit a ball with a tennis racket.
 
I got bored. The story did nothing for me whatsoever and I didn't care for the characters. The entire time I was thinking "I'd rather be playing Devil May Cry"

eh, there was never meant to be a good story in it I think, kind of a shame cause up until a certain point it could've been good.
 
*puts band-aid on forehead, looks around for something to throw while yelling*

No way man. Different styles of combat, but Chrono Trigger is just perfect in that respect. As for environments (any environment you could think of), story (insane amount of possible endings), and mythos (in-dwelt alien villain within the earth), a perfect tale told in 25-30 hours is far more preferable than the forever long BG II. One last thought - characters create the most lasting impression within a story, and CT's are second to none.

*Nothing to throw, shrugs, and offers you a beer*

I feel as though I entered a terrible RP session :lol

I can appreciate CT, but to me all the things that BG2 offered culminated into one of the best rpg experiences I have had. To me it is the yardstick by which I compare other rpg's. The game was as long as you wanted it to be, depending on how many side quests you wished to do. I thought the characters in bg2 were fantastic. Irenicus is a goddamn badass, and all the guys you encounter along the way just added in their own wsy to the experience. To me it is the most compelete rpg in what it offers.
 
Tuck said:
Rumble is pointless and stupid. The only time Rumble actually enhanced a game was in Wii Sports when you hit a ball with a tennis racket.

Are you a scholar? That sounds so prolific. I mean that makes total sense. [/not sarcasm]

** you know what while we are still doing this:

I don't understand or like games like Fallout. I played the game for I don't know how many hours and could not get anywhere, and ended up dying because I went to some far off place where some mutant dude kills me. I just don't get the fascination, same with elder scrolls dat combat.

I really don't like the DC fighting games. I really hate them. No style or substance imo. I cringe at the very thought of them.

I have been gaming for a long time (over 20 years) and I don't understand the shin megami tensei series at all. I tried one a long long time ago, just don't understand the fascination.

That's it for now. I think I will come back to this thread periodically.
 
Bioshock Infinite is a bad game. I would give it a 0/5. The gameplay is boring and the story is racist and full of holes.

Yoshi's Island is the best 2d Mario game.
 
I love Resident Evil 6, DmC, and Dead Space 3.

I like Final Fantasy XIII and XIII-2.

I believe Final Fantasy 7 gets way more love than it deserves these days.

Chews.+I+made+this+earlier+hope+you+enjoy_c845e5_4577171.png
 
Most gamers and game journalists don't actually care about gameplay mechanics and would rather talk about the story

Bioshock Infinite is insanely overrated, the gameplay is mediocre at best and the story and twist sucks

Tomb Raider is one of the most insultingly easy games I've played since PoP 2008
 
Hey this is fun

WoW sucks. It's just a bad game designed to be a treadmill. The Blizzard 'art direction' is also massively overrated, the game looks like crap

There has never been and never will be a good console multiplayer FPS game because playing a multiplayer FPS game with a controller is awful
 
I agree (except I paid full price and really regret it), and I also feel this way about Sony's western first party efforts in general. Games like inFamous, Killzone, God of War and Resistance are downright unpleasant to play. I really hope they are focusing on other things for the PS4.

I couldn't have said it better.


Rumble is pointless and stupid. The only time Rumble actually enhanced a game was in Wii Sports when you hit a ball with a tennis racket.

Starfox 64

wtf why would you enjoy video games???? BURN HIM!!!!!!!!!!!

I'm on it.
 
This...is probably the most insane one out of that big list above

edit: oh jebus

how dare you good sir!

Hey, I played through the core game and didn't see what all the fuss was about and overall it just bored me :\

@LegendX48: Oh yeah, few things more controversial than bashing Super Paper Mario and Sticker Star :P

Super's worlds were so damned claustrophobic, I couldn't help but hate how they made everything feel so condensed and tiny :\
 
• I prefer a controller over mouse and keyboard for FPS games on PC.

• I enjoy the Dual Shock 3 and 360 controller equally much.

• Mass Effect 3 had one of the greatest endings ever.

• Gran Turismo 5 looks like crap.

• I really enjoyed the voice acting in FFX the first time I played it.

• I had to force my way through the first two Bioshock games because they were so boring.
 
  • PC gaming is a money-suck, and consoles are more powerful and more efficient. Case-in-point, my graphics card (Radeon HD 7570) costs $139.99 on Dell's website, which is more than a PlayStation 2 costs these days. I bring that up because it can barely emulate a PS2 game properly. Any card that has came out within the last few years should be able to handle last-gen games with ease. Also, gaming on PC pretty much sucks with AMD hardware because no game is specifically coded for it, and nVidia is too damn expensive.

  • Anyone who plays GTA just to kill and blow up stuff without playing any of the missions is a mindless idiot.

  • I actually enjoy Final Fantasy XII's story because it's more about overall plot themes/devices (political espionage, power struggle, secret power structures, political ambition & war) that it is about character-driven shenanigans. That's why the game is played through Vaan's eyes, because it's less about him, and more about everything that is going on around him. Anyone who wants wonky animu characters should play FFX or FFXIII.

  • Anyone who plays games just for the multiplayer has bad tastes in video games.

  • Sony is the best company of the big 3.

  • Current-gen Madden contains some of the laziest programming in video game history. It's barely decent at being a functional video game, let alone an accurate representation of pro football.

  • Speaking of sports games, any game not named NBA 2K or The Show needs to take some notes from those two games.

  • NFL 2K5 is the most overrated game in history. It's semi-realistic, other than the fact that every player runs like a girl, DB AI sucks, and the sprint button is completely broken.

  • David Cage is a visionary.

  • "Indie" is becoming synonymous for "talentless hacks who have shitty ideas who have to go mobile just to make video games, because no one takes them seriously enough to put them on a console."

  • Tekken is better than Street Fighter.

  • There is no "sexism" problem in the industry. There is, however, a problem with getting women (and minorities, for that matter) involved with game development in the first place. Patricia Hernandez, you want to see more women at Sony's pressers? Then give DigiPen a call and tell them to lower their damn mortgage-esque tuition for a Bachelor of Arts & Science in game development.

  • Xbox LIVE is the worst thing to happen to gaming.

  • The "secret sauce" for both of the next-gen consoles' success will be social gaming and interaction.

  • Infamous 2 is the best PS3 game. Uncharted 2 is a close second.

  • The first Mass Effect was a decent game with a decent story with terrible AI, terrible animation, and terrible characters (other than Garrus & Liara). The second Mass Effect had a good story with good gameplay, good AI, and terrible characters (again, other than Garrus. Liara was barely in the game because EA DLC). The third Mass Effect had great gameplay with great AI, a terrible story and (you guessed it) with terrible characters (once again, excluding Garrus & Liara). Which makes Mass Effect 2 the best in the trilogy. Fuck those characters and all their daddy issues, though.

  • Tower defense games are shit.

  • Steam and subsidized hardware pricing have ruined the perception of market pricing in the game industry.

*Austin Powers voice* And I'm spent...

EDIT: Also, Driveclub looks better than GT6...
 
Here's something controversial:

Both Super Metroid and SotN are unique and amazing games that don't need to be directly compared to each other each time one of them is mentioned.

Here's another:

I didn't have an SNES or PS1, so when I played Metroid and Castlevania on my GBA and loved them (LOVED them, let me emphasize that), I went back and played Super Metroid and SotN. They're not nearly as good as the GBA games. Not even close. I couldn't bring myself to finish either of them.
 
Metroid Prime is probably one of the most overrated franchises in gaming. It is just so fucking bland. Literally it's only redeeming factor is it has a female protag which doesn't happen often.
 
The Spread gun in Contra is the worst.
Square Enix has been nailing it lately.
EA is a wonderful, charitable company, with happy employees.
 
  • PC gaming is a money-suck, and consoles are more powerful and more efficient. Case-in-point, my graphics card (Radeon HD 7570) costs $139.99 on Dell's website, which is more than a PlayStation 2 costs these days. I bring that up because it can barely emulate a PS2 game properly. Any card that has came out within the last few years should be able to handle last-gen games with ease. Also, gaming on PC pretty much sucks with AMD hardware because no game is specifically coded for it, and nVidia is too damn expensive.


  • I had to stop here. There's opinions, and then there's being factually wrong. You really have no clue what emulation is, eh?

    The PS2 and Wii are likely the last consoles to be emulated on PC because their architecture is simple enough. Everything past that (including the og Xbox) is too complicated to ever emulate without a huge team of dedicated programmers being paid to make it work.
 
Bethesda can't write worth a damn.

Bethesda is a common whipping boy - there's really no negative opinion you could share about Bethesda that would be considered controversial anymore. I'm actually a huge Bethesda fan and I agree with your assessment. They're masters of world-building but they're terrible at writing stories set in those worlds.

Now if you were to say Obsidian's writing was awful, that'd be another story entirely.
 
I had to stop here. There's opinions, and then there's being factually wrong. You really have no clue what emulation is, eh?

The PS2 and Wii are likely the last consoles to be emulated on PC because their architecture is simple enough. Everything past that (including the og Xbox) is too complicated to ever emulate without a huge team of dedicated programmers being paid to make it work.

I don't claim to be the paragon of emulation standards, but I remember a quote that I read in an Android forum regarding possible PS2 emulation on tablets: "The hardware has to be more powerful than the console it's emulating for it to work." Call me crazy, but I would like to think that a graphics card and CPU made in the last two years are more powerful than 10 year old hardware. But when the only games I can run are FFXII at 59 FPS with occasional slowdown during certain cutscenes, Kingdom Hearts at 59 FPS and Tekken 5 at 30 FPS, I start to wonder. That, and I don't want to have to do a bunch of tweaking to make my games work.

As far as normal PC gaming... I can barely get 20 frames out of GTA IV. That's the whole reason I bought my new PC, to play that and make movies using the clip editor...

EDIT: For reference -

HP ENVY hd1534
Beats by Dre Audio
10GB DDR3 RAM
Radeon HD 7570 2GB
AMD FX 6200 Six-Core Processor
HP Pavilion 1080p HDMI Monitor
 
As far as normal PC gaming... I can barely get 20 frames out of GTA IV. That's the whole reason I bought my new PC, to play that and make movies using the clip editor...

GTA IV has a notoriously bad PC port. It's hardly indicative of PC gaming as a whole.
 
  • PC gaming is a money-suck, and consoles are more powerful and more efficient. Case-in-point, my graphics card (Radeon HD 7570) costs $139.99 on Dell's website, which is more than a PlayStation 2 costs these days. I bring that up because it can barely emulate a PS2 game properly. Any card that has came out within the last few years should be able to handle last-gen games with ease. Also, gaming on PC pretty much sucks with AMD hardware because no game is specifically coded for it, and nVidia is too damn expensive.


  • Opinion? This is just ignorance.
 
Top Bottom