Arstechnica: Don’t read too much into the PS4’s million day-one sales

Moneal

Member
Lee Hutchison is a sharp guy and writes neat, informative pieces for Ars. Check out his Web Served series on setting up a personal web server.

I don't really disagree with him either, console gamers really need to chill.

see that's the difference though. you are saying they need to chill, he is calling them a derivative of retard. which is both offensive to people with retardation and the people he is attacking(which are the people that read his work, and keep the money coming to his site). telling people to chill is fine, but name calling and being offensive is not.
 
He is not altogether incorrect, there's not a 1:1 correlation or anything, but without a good start, it's unlikely you are going to be a competitor.

Of course, that they felt the need to run damage control on whether people were "looking into" those PS4 numbers says it all - once again, it's a service against how shitty and dumb they perceive their audience to be, not a service any one actually needs in their readership (unless they're fanboys). It's straight up for their masters.

Who are their masters?
 

pestul

Member
What a horseshit article lol. A totally fanboy polarized piece on how they're truly upset by PS4s successful launch..

All the points stated are common sense. We all know every launch is a wait-and-see..
 
I don't see why people are so upset about this article. It is simply pointing out there is a low correlation between initial sales and final sales. It is a valid point. It is the best article? No, but that is hardly a reason to get upset. At this point I wouldn't be surprised if Microsoft was benefiting from an anti-Sony fanboy bias. The Sony defense force is a little ridiculous right now.

And to the people pointing out the difference between 24 hours and the first week, it is completely irrelevant when you sell out of 95%+ of your launch stock in day one. You rarely see replenishment stock until the following week. They are essentially the same thing. I'd be really surprised if Sony made an announcement of week 1 sales because it is unlikely to change beyond potentially passing 1.1M units.

Signed,
Day one PS4 console owner that valiantly attempted to get his wife to switch from Xbox to PS4 despite the fact that his first PS4 console was bricked
I agree with this. Usually I agree with the general consensus of GAF but it's too early to tell how well the PS4 will do. I hope it does well or I will be concerned about the future of my hobby.
 

TheCloud

Banned
see that's the difference though. you are saying they need to chill, he is calling them a derivative of retard. which is both offensive to people with retardation and the people he is attacking(which are the people that read his work, and keep the money coming to his site). telling people to chill is fine, but name calling and being offensive is not.

Somehow, I don't think the console fanboys that attacked Ars showed that kind of restraint.
 

Mxrz

Member
Man.

I just love all these websites and enthusiast press guys telling us how 'tarded' we are. You know, for being exited about a new console, and offering props to the company for a large sale through. How dare we, or anyone, point out any conflicting facts or numbers that might question their sacred opinion pieces.
 

Marc

Member
Just trying to get caught up on this thread.

- Ars releases a click-bait article

- GAF calls them out on it.

- Ars lashes out at GAF for calling them out on their bullshit "journalism"

Is that about right?

TRUTHFACTS hurt apparently.

Gamers can take a lot of shit, and they can give it out in spades... it just so happens gaming mouthpieces get oh so very hurt and yell timeout at the slightest valid critcism. At which point they close a circle round their wounded compadre and resort to ad hominem attacks, strawman fallacies, appeals to authority and a general "this set of people are fools haha, I am too great. I don't even need to respond to valid concerns as I am above all that yet I must sully myself to your level in order to insult you. I said good day sir!". You could argue that the odd idiot exists and crosses a line, they are welcome to name and shame them instead of lumping us all together.
 
If they mention sales at all...
"XBox One sold at a stately pace in both NA and EU. Balance is a game changer."

If this article is anything to go by, we can expect "healthy" sales of the Xbone.

Edit: And if you have no problem walking into a store and buying one Day One, that is evidence only of Microsoft's awesome production capacity. And nothing else.
 
I work for a major telecommunications company with millions of customers. I wish I could go on twitter as a representative of my company and trash our customers, even if they are wrong. I think my bosses would think it would be bad business though.
 
If we'd chilled when the gaming press told us to, Xbox One pre-orderers would be about to enjoy their DRM infested console on Friday. This attitude of 'The people we write for are morons who need to be told what to do and what to think' really has to stop.
Nothing wrong with the drm.
 

Moneal

Member
Somehow, I don't think the console fanboys that attacked Ars showed that kind of restraint.

being professionals, they should be above the crap. journalists and professionals in general, especially in entertainment industries, get that crap all the time. you don't see George Lucas bash his audience when they call the Star Wars prequels crap. no he just keeps himself above it and rakes in the cash.
 
Nothing wrong with the drm.
image.php
 

undu

Member
I still remember when Ars was a respectable gaming news outlet, I'm getting old

By the way, they should fix their Microsoft RSS feed, there are "unrelated" news popping up there:

k17hf9W.jpg
 

antibolo

Banned
Wow. Never reading Ars again.

The article itself doesn't bother me, it's the way Aurich and Lee are just openly name-calling their readership on Twitter. I don't want to give ad revenue to these clowns anymore.
 

Hyunashi

Member
I don't see why people are so upset about this article. It is simply pointing out there is a low correlation between initial sales and final sales. It is a valid point. It is the best article? No, but that is hardly a reason to get upset. At this point I wouldn't be surprised if Microsoft was benefiting from an anti-Sony fanboy bias. The Sony defense force is a little ridiculous right now.

And to the people pointing out the difference between 24 hours and the first week, it is completely irrelevant when you sell out of 95%+ of your launch stock in day one. You rarely see replenishment stock until the following week. They are essentially the same thing. I'd be really surprised if Sony made an announcement of week 1 sales because it is unlikely to change beyond potentially passing 1.1M units.

Signed,
Day one PS4 console owner that valiantly attempted to get his wife to switch from Xbox to PS4 despite the fact that his first PS4 console was bricked

The Sony 'Defense force' is ridiculous right now? I see things differently. Totally differently.

Its pretty ridiculous to downplay Sonys record of sales withing the first 24-hours. Not many think the generation is won, they should not, but Sony's continued support of its console was a prevalent trend with last gen. That in itself should be enough to incite confidence.
 
What does my misspelling have to do with anything? I get paid a lot to write, you mad?


you're a member here and you have the gull to write that?
Rather than engage your audience as well as your detractors with a meaningful dialogue to back up your points, you dismiss them in one fell swoop in the name of what? When you have some of the most hardcore MS fans on our forum calling this article "pointless" yes, we are mad, maybe even envious that you get paid to do something you might not be that great at.


EDIT: sarcasm meter is broken -__-
 

sephi22

Member
I don't have a problem with the article (didn't read it)
But how can a grown man justify using the word 'tard', let alone a reviewer.

We Xbox live now
 
I agree with this. Usually I agree with the general consensus of GAF but it's too early to tell how well the PS4 will do. I hope it does well or I will be concerned about the future of my hobby.

Well, wouldn't you feel more concerned if the PS4 didn't perform as well as it has? To say that launch sales don't guarantee long term success is correct, but if the PS4 had come out of the gate selling poorly, you had better believe those numbers would have mattered to everyone.
 

DeBurgo

Member
being professionals, they should be above the crap. journalists and professionals in general, especially in entertainment industries, get that crap all the time. you don't see George Lucas bash his audience when they call the Star Wars prequels crap. no he just keeps himself above it and rakes in the cash.
People really should think carefully about pulling the professionalism card every time somebody makes a tweet or facebook post you don't like. It really works both ways, even if you aren't somebody that deals with the public.

Also, none of these people are exactly George Lucas famous. Also, fame is a disgusting concept, anyway.
 

verbum

Member
Never, ever read Ars for gaming news. Tech and science coverage have gone downhill in recent years, but they're still somewhat worthwhile. Their gaming coverage has always been abysmal.

I remember they were more PC games- centric but have been increasing the console coverage the last 5 years.
I like Ars, I don't want to see them go away. Perhaps they'll do a little more editing on the contributions. I'll bet they've gotten away from editing as much as they used to, maybe start doing more. Not just proof read, critical editing. Fewer articles, more depth.
 

vcc

Member
They don't? Didn't someone just show that both the Wii and the PS2 (market leaders in their respective generations) also had the highest launch day sales?

Any data from previous generations?



People are annoyed (I don't think upset is the right word), because it's a condescending article no matter how you look at it. It's telling its readers, "hey, you know that record-breaking impressive achievement that just happened? I'm going to tell you why it's not actually impressive at all! I'm going to tell you why you're wrong if you think it means anything." Who is it being directed at? The writing history of its author also indicates a pretty heavy bias, which is annoying when it's being posted on a tech site from which you'd hope for some neutrality.

Ps2 had 500,000 sell through on day one NA (supply capped). GC sold through 310,000 in NA day one (750,000 shipped). XB original sold 300,00 day one in NA (supply capped). DC dols 376,000 day one NA.

Wii had 600,000 sell through day one NA (supply capped). XB360 sold 326,000 day one NA (supply capped), PS3 sold 197,000 day one NA (not supply capped, 400k were expected to be shipped).
 

Moneal

Member
People really should think carefully about pulling the professionalism card every time somebody makes a tweet or facebook post you don't like. It really works both ways, even if you aren't somebody that deals with the public.

Also, none of these people are exactly George Lucas famous. Also, fame is a disgusting concept, anyway.

no they are not as famous as george lucas but they are on twitter accounts being representatives of their employer. and its not about me not liking what they say. its the offensive name calling and attacking of their own readership. it is harmful to their business.
 

NHale

Member
I love how the gaming media way of handling criticism is always dismiss the criticism, not debating it and just ad hominem by saying "entitled", "consoletards", "the kids", "fanboys" etc. You don't have to agree with the critics but at least spend a couple of minutes analyzing if it's possible that the criticism has any validity. Gaming media members need to stop believing they are the holders of the TRUTH that have the mercy to share it with peasants like us, because if that was true then the X1 would have the secret sauce, Sony would definitely have the same DRM on the PS4, etc.

It's quite remarkable to see how most of the gaming media actually behave like kids but nothing happens to them. It's probably the only job in the world where you are allowed to throw unsubstantiated rumors, spread misinformation or deny any criticism by dismissing your client and not suffer any consequence.

Maybe Kyle Orland should make another article about "Don't read too much into website/magazines owners accepting gaming media members behaviour in 2013." because the future might not be as bright as they think it is.
 

spwolf

Member
He is not altogether incorrect, there's not a 1:1 correlation or anything, but without a good start, it's unlikely you are going to be a competitor.

Of course, that they felt the need to run damage control on whether people were "looking into" those PS4 numbers says it all - once again, it's a service against how shitty and dumb they perceive their audience to be, not a service any one actually needs in their readership (unless they're fanboys). It's straight up for their masters.

Imagine when Apple sold 100 million new iPhone's, Wired writing about how it does not mean anything at all.

Or when Toyota sells 10 million cars, Automotive News writing how it does not mean anything.

Gaming press is the only press that goes against its own readership. It is pretty pathetic.

And the tweets from Ars - amazingly wrong.
 
Well, fucking duh. Why did he feel the need to educate us raging consoletards about this?
Or perhaps more curiously, why did he feel the need to insult his audience and come off like a twat?

edit
Oh, Twitter guy (Lee Hutchinson) and article guy (Kyle Orland) are different guys.
Apologies to the latter for the misguided hostility.
 
People who get defensive and make snide generalizing comments to their inner circle of followers on Twitter are such a shameful lot. It's always an embarrassing thing to witness.

Simple. It really seems these "journalist" monkeys cannot seem to be able to deal with finally being called out on their shameful idiocy on the regular by GAF, etc.

They then lash out at the very people that they are responsible to and that indirectly pay their salaries.

Well I mean the ones not being paid by Microsoft, Gies.
 

Ganondolf

Member
"Yet the Xbox 360 went on to be one of the most dominant consoles of its generation"

we have had 3 consoles this gen. and xbox 360 is 3rd (except if he is only talking about US market).

it seems like they want the xbox to come out on top and will say anything. ps4 has done amazing sales of 1m in 24 hrs just in the US. by years end it will have a healthy lead worldwide and then the japan launch next year will extend it.
 

Pie and Beans

Look for me on the local news, I'll be the guy arrested for trying to burn down a Nintendo exec's house.
When backlash begins, double down, sneer, and insult your reader base.

Was there some western games media seminar all these jokers attended with this game plan plotted out in PowerPoint? Or are games writers hired on the basis of how unable they are to exhibit humility and open mindedness?

"Hey boss, this applicant told someone to go fuck themselves over their choice of popsicle flavour a couple years ago on Myspace! I think he's a shoe in!!"
 

Clear

CliffyB's Cock Holster
The funny thing about articles like this is that as much as they rile up Playstation fans, they aren't actually doing Xbox any favours because its dominating the online conversation at a time when MS I'm sure would like to be attracting more attention.

Its kind of like the Streisand Effect where trying to deflect attention is in fact fuelling interest.
 

Jburton

Banned
Click bait is what a lot of these sites rely on, hence they post these type of articles.

This article makes some obvious and sensible points (of course nothing is won etc) but a lot of times titles are inflammatory as can be the wording or sentiment derived from it.


I will no longer be visiting many sites not based a perceived anti PS / MS slant but because I find them irrelevant.

I get better quality discussion and insight from this forum and I don't want to support sites that must rely on / endorse this kind of click bait driven business model.


We will see how this whole generation plays out, I hope for success for all so we still have a healthy industry for another go next gen and many good games on all platforms this generation.

Fuck all the rest of it, I'm done with it.
 
Top Bottom