Super Smash Bros Wii U & 3DS Thread 4: New Year, Old Arguments

No, it makes sense...the idea behind the "leak" is that there was an error on the site, and the picture ended up being uploaded early, and then quickly removed when the error was realized. Obviously I'm not saying that's what actually happened, but such things have happened before on the Internet so that's the idea.
And the one person in the entire world who happened to notice the error not only decided to screen capture the page instead of directly linking to the picture, but waited hours before telling anybody?
 
You can't compare a relevant character like Link to someone like Falco.

I'm not saying Falco isn't in the game, but I don't think he's secured a spot either.

I think you ignored everyone's response. So, how is Toon Link more relevant than Falco?
 
falco2_zps67665e2d.gif~original
They're clearly based on the same image. That's what 30 minutes of Photoshop will get you.
 
And the one person in the entire world who happened to notice the error not only decided to screen capture the page instead of directly linking to the picture, but waited hours before telling anybody?

Of course it doesn't, I'm just saying that's what the "leak" is implying happened.
 
Convincingly lay his SSB4 render over a Brawl screen shot and then we'll talk. The source of the Falco fake was found almost instantly.
I'm not saying it is real, but there's no dead giveaway that it's fake either.

It looks like graphical upgrade, yet similar enough to look a lot like the Brawl counterpart, exactly like fox.

What I really notice is the neck. It's vastly better in the "leaked" picture, and looks pretty much exactly like Fox's neck when it comes to lighting and the scarf.
comparison-wiiu-13.jpg


For reference, here's Brawl Fox: http://gengame.net/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/comparison-brawl-13.png


If this is a photoshop, then it's no quick 30 min job like you suggested.
 
I'm not saying it is real, but there's no dead giveaway that it's fake either.

It looks like graphical upgrade, yet similar enough to look a lot like the Brawl counterpart, exactly like fox.

What I really notice is the neck. It's vastly better in the "leaked" picture, and looks pretty much exactly like Fox's neck when it comes to lighting and the scarf.
The renders are much more high quality than the models themselves. The SSB4 renders all look great, so why would Falco's look like a slightly modified Brawl screen shot? The leak is stylistically closer to Brawl than SSB4. I'm more than 100% convinced that Falco's actual render won't look anything like that.
 
You can't compare a relevant character like Link to someone like Falco.

I'm not saying Falco isn't in the game, but I don't think he's secured a spot either.

The point is that we have no idea what the dev team's priority list looks like, other than that it clearly isn't sorted "unique characters at the top, clones at the bottom!" Falco's got two games of seniority going for him, does that make a difference? Maybe! It's impossible to tell.
 
Alright, Less than 1950 posts to go before OT5 so time for voting only one out of two subtitle for OT5. Yes, it will be Yoshi-related titles only.

  1. Super Smash Bros Wii U & 3DS Thread 5: Yoshi is Missing!
  2. Super Smash Bros. Wii U and 3DS Thread 5: Ridley Me This -- Where's Yoshi?
I vote the 1st one. Ridley has had his time to shine in the titles.
 
The renders are much more high quality than the models themselves. The SSB4 renders all look great, so why would Falco's look like a slightly modified Brawl screen shot? The leak is stylistically closer to Brawl than SSB4. I'm more than 100% convinced that Falco's actual render won't look anything like that.

Yeah, this is on my mind too. The renders on the main site are not only much higher quality (even with complex fur shading and everything), but a lot of them have subtly unique poses. Compare this with that Falco shot that already has near identical matches to a in-game Brawl shot.

bTZCFiO.png


To me, that Falco image sticks out compared to the rest of those renders. It just looks off, plus the whole situation around that "leak" is confusing. Why would Falco just pop up, and we only have a JPG screen capture for proof?
 
Alright, Less than 1950 posts to go before OT5 so time for voting only one out of two subtitle for OT5. Yes, it will be Yoshi-related titles only.

  1. Super Smash Bros Wii U & 3DS Thread 5: Yoshi is Missing!
  2. Super Smash Bros. Wii U and 3DS Thread 5: Ridley Me This -- Where's Yoshi?

Super Smash Bros Wii U & 3DS Thread 5: Doc Louis stole mah Yoshi!
 
The Falco leak looks like a quick Photoshop job. I work with Photoshop for a living and it looks really doable. Not saying it's fake or real, just saying I could personally mock it up super quick.
 
Aura Sphere looks nice, but I just want to know how much damage it does after Lucario takes a beating.


Alright, Less than 1950 posts to go before OT5 so time for voting only one out of two subtitle for OT5. Yes, it will be Yoshi-related titles only.

  1. Super Smash Bros Wii U & 3DS Thread 5: Yoshi is Missing!
  2. Super Smash Bros. Wii U and 3DS Thread 5: Ridley Me This -- Where's Yoshi?

Cries

#2
 
It hasn't even entered my head people would think Falco had a chance to be cut. That's just being silly. He's a staple of two Smash Bros games and popular enough to be a major character in the Subspace and in Brawl's design right from the start.

There probably hasn't even been a question to the Smash 4 dev team on if he's coming back or not. They probably designed him just as they would Ice Climbers or Sheik or some other very obviously returning Melee newcomer.
 
Yeah, this is on my mind too. The renders on the main site are not only much higher quality (even with complex fur shading and everything), but a lot of them have subtly unique poses. Compare this with that Falco shot that already has near identical matches to a in-game Brawl shot.

bTZCFiO.png


To me, that Falco image sticks out compared to the rest of those renders. It just looks off, plus the whole situation around that "leak" is confusing. Why would Falco just pop up, and we only have a JPG screen capture for proof?

God I hate Fox's ugly ass boots and head shape. Want the older design so bad
 
Yeah, it doesn't matter. I'm just positive the leak is BS. (I'm getting sick of these "leaks" in general, honestly.)

No way. Leaks and fake leaks are the best. They're like little puzzles. Trying to tear them apart or waiting for them to be revealed to be fake is part of the smash bros cycle. So fun!
 
I like the Ridley one. But why does it gotta be Yoshi based? Yoshi's inevitably gonna get revealed on New Island day.

Btw Heath, this is super nitpicky and all, but can you use the games' official titles in the thread title? Super Smash Bros. for 3DS / Wii U is how Nintendo refers to them.
 
God I hate Fox's ugly ass boots and head shape. Want the older design so bad

I think the head is fine but overall all his boots were not really that good looking to begin with.

snes -probably my fave. I like that they actually look like robot legs. still not really lookers and would look really weird in smash today.
309px_Snes_Star_Fox.jpg


64- Is the next best alternative nice and simple
Fox_SF643_D.png


DS- to tall and skinny
Foxcommandera.jpg


Adventures GC- not terrible but bulky
388381_wallpaper_starfox_01_l.png


Assult GC-This is where the grossness began.
Fox_A2.jpg
 
I like to imagine that a Kamiya Star Fox would bring back the robo-legs and allow Fox to do all sorts of stylish character action (although the bulk of the game's focus would be squarely on vehicle segments). Fox could have a jackhammer kick, missile launchers in his legs, a super-jump, thruster-powered double-jump and more.
 
I don't think they ever really got rid of the robot legs, so much as they just covered them up with ugly boots.
I hope the idea with the robo-legs is that Fox and company willingly augmented themselves for enhanced combat prowess, and not that it's, like, how non-human animals wound up colonizing the stars, lol.
 
Heh, personally I much prefer the assault "boots" over the SNES one, though I really like the 64 one as well.

As for his face, I liked the Melee one the most. I quite enjoy his Alt costume in Project M.
 
Alright, Less than 1950 posts to go before OT5 so time for voting only one out of two subtitle for OT5. Yes, it will be Yoshi-related titles only.
  1. Super Smash Bros Wii U & 3DS Thread 5: Yoshi is Missing!
  2. Super Smash Bros. Wii U and 3DS Thread 5: Ridley Me This -- Where's Yoshi?
Super Smash Bros Wii U & 3DS Thread 5: i guess yoshi at the end of the month will be good
 
Top Bottom