• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

1up apparently has a webcomic now

RegularMK said:
Who's playing bass? Wedge, more than likely. No one cares about the bassist. :(

I think it's Darth, dude!

p.s. - this comic is horrible, but at least it's not another horrible comic pretending to be a review!
 
I made this mistake of reading a few more of his comics. I actually quit reading them after about three comics out of embarassment for the dude. I haven't done that since the last Piers Anthony novel I read 16 years ago. Thanks for nothing, 1up.
 
This guy isn't getting paid, is he? Let's assume he is so I don't feel bad for trashing his shitty comic.

It's bad enough that it's not funny or well drawn, but the lettering's just awful. Using Comic Sans MS is a crime on its own, but the balloons are even worse. The words got no room to breathe. It sure looks like he drew the strip first and crammed the lettering in afterwards, which is a big no-no. You can get away with a lot of crappy drawing if you can at least make your comic readable.

My skin crawls whenever I see all the amateur webcomics criticism that goes on here whenever someone posts a PA or VG Cats strip (and I don't like either of them), but God I can't help myself. This is a whole other level of bad. The twee dialogue ("drawed"??) and sidebar made me want to die. Made me want to die and kill someone else at the same time. I react pretty badly to crappy comics.

Kobun Heat said:
You have to applaud 1up's constant pursuit of outside-the-box content; whether or not it clicks with you, they're not getting locked into news/reviews/previews.
Yeah, totally loving them hopping on every obnoxious internet fad that comes along. HIP. WITH IT. They've got blogs and friendster and webcomics and lists but they're all about videogames!!!!!
 
It may suck, at least now, but we are only seeing two strips so far. I am going to give it a chance, just for the sake that it might develop into something.

Plus, 1up IS TRYING. While a lot of the stuff it does isn't perfect, and the site has gone gradually downhill since the summer (it has, I used to be a 1upaholic), at least they are still trying to do what they set out to do, which is spice up the gaming community with some new and different stuff outside of just news, previews, and reviews.

Not only that, but the 1up show owns. It really does. It is the best thing on the website right now. It shows off the personalities of the staff very well, while showing off videos of some of the newer games coming out. The show even has humor to it (more than the webcomic does, that's for sure).

I think 1up is getting better. The plagarism thing didn't help them, but they are at least trying to improve.
 
See, the problem with fans of "enthusiast" hobbies is that they remember everything. Newtype USA gave a bad review to some Gundam anime or another in its premiere issue, which was December 2002, and we still get flack for it on the anime message boards, even though that was several redesigns and editorial staffs ago.

So lighten up already. I don't think anyone can remember a mistake their local newspaper made back in 2002.
 
Bloodwake said:
It may suck, at least now, but we are only seeing two strips so far. I am going to give it a chance, just for the sake that it might develop into something.

look at his blog if you want to see more comics:

http://wafflehouseninja.1up.com/do/my1Up?publicUserId=5244814&pager.offset=3

se7en.jpg



palmer.jpg



bauer.jpg


mitch.jpg


but I agree about the content of 1UP
 
Sho Nuff said:
At the very least, it's funnier than Hsu and Chan.

HSU AND CHAN IS NOT AND HAS NEVER BEEN FUNNY TO ANYONE (APART FROM WHOEVER LETS IT WASTE A PAGE OF EGM EVERY MONTH)

most true thing I've ever read on GAF

Also, this webcomic is meh so far.
 
OK, I feel kinda bad about trashing the guy. Those other strips are a little better. I mean yeah, they're still annoying in-jokey pop culture reference crap, but at least it's more than a two talking heads. And the balloons are kinda better.
 
I'd like to take back all the awful thing's i've ever said about VGCats. Seriously, this redefines what I classify as awful.
 
Did anyone save that thread of intentionally bad comics from awhile ago? It was a poster here and I remember it was deleted before too long. </vague>
 
I tried posting this in chat and no one gave an opinion or cared, maybe it'll fare better here. I made it in like 2001.

otakugaming.gif

otakugaming2.gif


In all fairness the 2nd strip about women was redrawing from something a friend of mine did, a freind with a better understanding of the english language and of the funny.
 
the text for the first panel should be like this;

> Like, um, like natalie!
> Like, I've um Like, got like a joke for you!
< Oh, ok, so, like um... joke me! I guess...
> Haha, so uhm ok, what's, like, Mother Brain's favorite DS game?

much more realistic.
 
Top Bottom