Dr.Guru of Peru said:
I disagree. The uniqueness of Pikmin 1 was what made it so great. Ive yet to finish Pikmin 2, but I have no interest in doing so because now that the freshness of the concept has worn off I see no fun in the game. I have several other major complaints(dungeons, lack of time limit, etc.) against Pikmin 2 as well, but thats my biggest beef.
Holy shit, so it's not just me?!?
I swear, every time I pipe up in a thread where somebody's asking if Pikmin 2 is any good with those same complaints, it's usually followed with lots of posts along the lines of "you're absolutely nuts", or similar.
The above ground stuff is actually pretty neat, but I have the exact same problems with the game you do. The lack of an overall time limit removes pretty much all the challenge, and instead of spending all your time in the beautiful, lush overworlds you're wandering around in the drab, dull caves.
Now, if I can find another soul on the planet who agrees that F-Zero GX is the cheapest mess of a game ever I won't feel quite as "off"...
As far as the topic goes, I've gotta say that, for some reason, MP2:E and VJ2 hold no interest for me. I really enjoyed the originals of both titles, but I think it's really a case of the original games having the perfect amount of content, and I don't want to start a whole other game along similar lines.