Support NeoGAF

[SilentSpecter]

gotta give it to cyberpunk on this one. W3 does worldbuilding, story, and quests better, but at its core the combat just isn't as engaging

 

[fallingdove]

who care crud combat vs armazing waaaay more important game over

You're talking about the gameplay loop that consists of 20 minutes of excellent gunplay sandwiched between hours of exposition dumps, virtual replay, car rides at school zone speeds, and mindless navigation?

Glad you like Cyberpunk so much and that there are still people like yourself that are so easily impressed by shiny objects.

 

[GigaBowser]

You're talking about the gameplay loop that consists of 20 minutes of excellent gunplay sandwiched between hours of exposition dumps, virtual replay, car rides at school zone speeds, and mindless navigation?

Glad you like Cyberpunk so much and that there are still people like yourself that are so easily impressed by shiny objects.

what witcher 3 harv? follow smell bad combat terimble horse all bad gameplays

cyberpunk cars beter thens horses better combat better city night city

 

[fallingdove]

Because there's about 6 in the whole game where as Witcher sense is in like 90% of quests.

90% of quests huh? lol.

The actual Witcher sense fact finding missions are much less frequent than that. In other cases where you are prompted to use Witcher sense, it's to provide optional path markers. Still, much more engaging and streamlined than, slowly move in a few directions, rewind and fast forward the footage and make sure to stay within the boundaries of the hacked individual.

 

[NeverYouMind]

10 millions times better thens witcher 3 combats game over

I come from the school of big booms. Pea shooters need not apply.

 

[fallingdove]

what witcher 3 harv? follow smell bad combat terimble horse all bad gameplays

cyberpunk cars beter thens horses better combat better city night city

I don't know what you're trying to say dude. I don't speak keyboard smash.

 

[Lokaum D+]

the witcher 3 and its not even fair, this moded + RTGI + music + immersion shits all over CP77

 

[GigaBowser]

 

[fallingdove]

Are we just posting random YouTube videos now:



Seriously, you act like a grade schooler.

Cyberpunk and TW3 are both good games. Who cares which is subjectively better or worse? You seem to be disinterested in actually discussing anything; much more inclined to fanboy.

 

[GigaBowser]

I say Cyberpunk.
I played it on PS5 with all the patches so i don't have a negative experience with it.
Witcher, while having a great story has absolutley terrible gameplay.

Cyberpunk is a masterpiece and is the only reason I bought Witcher 3 and put in my backlog to get more of that CDPR magic. I never liked what I saw from W3 but some day I will get to it.

yes its true its all true my friends once they pach cyberpunk phantom liberties become a millions time better thens witcher game over

 

[RoboFu]

got to go with cyberpunk, the actual game play loop is a lot more fun. witcher's combat isn't that fun.

 

[zeroluck]

I didn't understand the hype for CDPR because I thought W3 was mediocre, but Cyberpunk was one of my favorite game.

 

[yet_another_alt]

Witcher combat is terrible. The only thing Witcher has over Cyberpunk is the number of waifus.

 

[yamaci17]

Witcher combat is terrible. The only thing Witcher has over Cyberpunk is the number of waifus.

phantom liberty may have changed things a bit with aurore and songbird

edit: no spoilers

 

[MSduderino]

W3 combat immediately turned me off to not trying it really, but y'all are making me consider to snag CP2077 on S2. That ninja shit looks dope.

 

[Bitstream]

W3 combat immediately turned me off to not trying it really, but y'all are making me consider to snag CP2077 on S2. That ninja shit looks dope.

If you saw the ninja in MGS1 and thought, holy shit, that motherfucker is bad ass?
2077 lets you do all that and more.

 

[MSduderino]

If you saw the ninja in MGS1 and thought, holy shit, that motherfucker is bad ass?
2077 lets you do all that and more.

I actually loved Metal Gear Rising: Revengeance when it came out on PS3 and I've been bummed you can't play it on modern consoles it seems. I haven't been a fan of melee combat in 1st person but that video makes it look fun as shit.

 

[Lokaum D+]

 

[Fbh]

I enjoyed both, but overall I'd go with the Witcher.
I just found the characters and quests more compelling. Cyberpunk definitely has the better combat, but I don't think it makes up for the rather underwhelming main story, somewhat forgetabble side characters and limited number o truly memorable sidequests (Phantom Liberty was way better in this regard, IMO. But Blood and Wine from the Witcher was awesome too)

 

[GigaBowser]

you dress wizard?? oohoohoohoo

 

[apocaliptic]

As someone that has played every witcher game the day they were relased on PC, the Witcher 3 is millions time better than Cyberpunk. I did preorder Cyberpunk and haven't played more than 2 hours. You guys don't know nothing about games if you think Cyberpunk is better. Leave the gaming discussions to the ones that have played since atari.

 

[TintoConCasera]

Had more fun with Cyberpunk than with TW3, but imo both are so-so games.

For me, TW2 is their better game.

 

[Saber]

I played Cyberpunk from start to finish and honestly would still side with Witcher 3.