Dean Takahashi's GOTYs 2004

Chittagong

Gold Member
Not too controversial, except that GTA: SA not there. WTF?

http://www.mercurynews.com/mld/mercurynews/living/10447512.htm?1c

Game of the year: ``Half-Life 2,'' from Vivendi Universal for PCs (Mature). It balances a captivating story, graphics, physics so real that nothing looks or feels fake, mental puzzles and a lot of tough combat.

2. ``Halo 2,'' from Microsoft for Xbox (Mature). The cliffhanger ending makes its story disappointing after a three-year wait, but it adds better game play to the already outstanding original.

3. ``Rome: Total War,'' from Activision for PCs (Teen). Two games in one. Takes you from the view of the Roman Empire in Risk-style strategy to the commander's view on a 3-D tactical battlefield.

4. ``Far Cry,'' from Ubisoft for PCs (Mature). A tropical island makes a great setting for both close-up jungle combat and long-distance sharpshooting in this first-person shooter.

5. ``Doom 3,'' from Activision for PCs (Mature). A scary experience made startlingly real with dark lighting and atmosphere.

6. ``The Sims 2,'' from Electronic Arts for PCs (Teen). You get to control smarter, better-looking Sims who still have minds of their own. Great for new gamers.

7. ``Battle For Middle Earth,'' from Electronic Arts for PCs (Teen). This late arrival has magical graphics, even on its strategic map, and re-creates the feel of battles from the Peter Jackson ``Lord of the Rings'' films.

8. ``Pathway to Glory,'' from Nokia for the N-Gage game phone. (Teen) Yes, finally a cell phone game that is hard to put down.

9. ``Full Spectrum Warrior,'' from THQ for Xbox and PCs (Mature). My esteemed colleague blew it when he panned the game in his review. In this warfare tactics game, protecting your squad is your mission.

10. ``Zoo Tycoon 2,'' from Microsoft for PCs (Everyone). This zoo-building sequel lets you zoom in on every animal or guest now.
 
Doom 3 isn't a game, it's a tech demo. And even then, UE3 owns it. There's not even a single PS2/GCN Game on that list.

buchtakah.jpg


Oh, that's why.
 
8. ``Pathway to Glory,'' from Nokia for the N-Gage game phone. (Teen) Yes, finally a cell phone game that is hard to put down.


GBA/NINTENDO DS OWNED

NOKIA MONEYHAT LOL

FUCK MORON
 
10. ``Zoo Tycoon 2,'' from Microsoft for PCs (Everyone). This zoo-building sequel lets you zoom in on every animal or guest now.


Which makes it a better game than MGS3, San Andreas, Katamari, Paper Mario 2, and MP2!

What a toolio.
 
Completely worthless list. Someone should get this man a PS2 and Cube for Christmas because as this list indicates he doesn't have either.
 
how does this have anything to do with MS/Xbox? reaching... really reaching....

Dean Takahashi is part and parcel of MS pr. Peopel want to know who he is and why his game list is devoid of non-pc/xbox/ngage[sic]. A best of list with only pc/xbox/ngage[sic]
is quite abberant until you find out who wrote it, especially when his best handheld game is on ngage of all places.
 
well, I imagine it's not so much what does MS have to do with ngage but more like what does MS not have to do with the GBA. IOW, there's not a GBA game on the list but there is an ngage game. Ngage != Nintendo/Sony so it's ok to like them.
 
Do you not find it strange that the author of a book on Xbox has ZERO GC, PS2, or GBA games on his list?

You think it normal that an N-Gage game, and the latest Zoo Keeper beat out MGS3, San Andreas, Katamari, Paper Mario 2, and MP2?
 
1. Half-Life 2 - Agree
2. Halo 2 - Too high
3. Rome: Total War - Well deserved
4. Far Cry - Too high
5. Doom 3 - Forget it
6. The Sims 2 - No
7. LOTR Battle For Middle Earth - Can't say.
8. Pathway to Glory - Can't say but over the likes of GTA:SA and MP2E? I doubt it.
9. Full Spectrum Warrior - Can't say either.
10. Zoo Tycoon 2 - If the demo is indicative of the game then no, certainly not over games like Pirates anyway.
 
Also, Far Cry is crap. Nice engine, sure, but the game is just soooooo stale. Half Life 2 and Rome:TW are the only games that deserve to be on that list.
 
Scottlarock said:
MS is making a GBA competitor?

Not literally, but they are throwing support at the CE-based Gizmondo.

Takahashi's clearly going for a more "executive" list here, stressing mainstream appeal and graphic prowess over the "hardcore." It's not surprising that people here aren't in agreement -- it's more a list of the games my dad would be apt to try out, were he apt to try much of anything (I did spy a still shrinkwrapped copy of The Sims in his office last time I visited).

And for the conspiracy theorists, note that [if you actually read the article] while he says it was a weak year for kids titles,

Give ``Mario Tennis'' an honorable mention for plain old fun.
 
brandonnn said:
And for the conspiracy theorists, note that [if you actually read the article] while he says it was a weak year for kids titles,

when I clicked the link it said I had to register and I don't know the address of the page that has all of the different registration information, do you know the one I'm talking about?

so no, I didn't read it.
 
Top Bottom