-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Dusk Golem: Konami is developing a Silent Hill game internally
Kenneth Haight
Gold Member
ChorizoPicozo
Member
Konami has devs?!
Bring Back Scalebound
Banned
As always, while Capcom treats Resident Evil like their graceful and loving wife, Konami treats Silent Hill like a 2 dollar retired "whore" that is being forced to do things at gun point.
- Ascension, flies-infested garbage.
- The Short Message, out of touch with mental health issues, and mediocre.
SH 2 Remake is not aiming up to be fantastic.
Which is exactly the problem. It can't be just good. It has to be at the very least great. And I very much doubt it will be.
SH F is interesting, VERY interesting in fact, and had a beautiful trailer, but is coming after one trash and one mediocre game, and a probable underwhelming Remake.
And NOW, if this is real, they are making more.
Konami should just release a collection of PORTS of SH 1, 2, 3, 4 and Shattered Memories, and let Silent Hill rest.
- Ascension, flies-infested garbage.
- The Short Message, out of touch with mental health issues, and mediocre.
SH 2 Remake is not aiming up to be fantastic.
Which is exactly the problem. It can't be just good. It has to be at the very least great. And I very much doubt it will be.
SH F is interesting, VERY interesting in fact, and had a beautiful trailer, but is coming after one trash and one mediocre game, and a probable underwhelming Remake.
And NOW, if this is real, they are making more.
Konami should just release a collection of PORTS of SH 1, 2, 3, 4 and Shattered Memories, and let Silent Hill rest.
Punished Miku
Human Rights Subscription Service
Silent Hill is an ancient franchise at this point, mostly fondly remembered for 1 game (Silent Hill 2) made by a very specific group of artists at a specific time, that can't really be recreated.
My advice to everyone is to just forget that anything coming says Silent Hill on the box. It's just some new horror game. Give it a shot and you might even enjoy it. If you cling to thinking it's "Silent Hill" you're literally never going to be happy.
My advice to everyone is to just forget that anything coming says Silent Hill on the box. It's just some new horror game. Give it a shot and you might even enjoy it. If you cling to thinking it's "Silent Hill" you're literally never going to be happy.
West Texas CEO
GAF's Nicest Lunch Thief and Nosiest Dildo Archeologist
Clear
CliffyB's Cock Holster
SH2 remake looks solid to me. Its just the terminal malcontents that have been dogging on it from the start.
Sorry, but when you have people who are more invested in seeing a thing fail -presumably to prove they are "right"- than the possibility that it might turn out good in the run-up to release, nothing else for it but to "tune them out".
Sorry, but when you have people who are more invested in seeing a thing fail -presumably to prove they are "right"- than the possibility that it might turn out good in the run-up to release, nothing else for it but to "tune them out".
GrayChild
Member
That doesn't mean much to me.
The first 4 Silent Hill games were masterpieces not because they were Japanese, or developed by an in-house Konami studio. It was the people in Team Silent and they they lent their unique talents to each other. Unless Konami has pouched some geniuses or they find a way to bring back the majority of that creative force, I'm remaining skeptical.
The first 4 Silent Hill games were masterpieces not because they were Japanese, or developed by an in-house Konami studio. It was the people in Team Silent and they they lent their unique talents to each other. Unless Konami has pouched some geniuses or they find a way to bring back the majority of that creative force, I'm remaining skeptical.
Capcom isn't that different actually, what will they do after releasing all the remakes? A shooter game that will eventually have straight forward campaign from the first try? typical re games have difficult places and usually you get stuck in between, but that didn't happen after the first re remake.
Last edited:
Lunarorbit
Gold Member
Oh great. Now we get to hear rumors for 4 years
Bring Back Scalebound
Banned
adamsapple
Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
So a Pachinko machine, then?
tomato shrub
Member
Yeah, doesn't matter how you feel about Metal Gear Delta, or Persona 3 Reload, etc. - at least the original versions are officially available in HD in most modern e-stores. But screwing up SH2 without a decent legal way to play the original just sucks.
Last edited:
Bloobs
Al Pachinko, Konami President
Badlucktroll
Member
For all we know they got the old band back together to make Silent Hill 5. It's safe to assume Konami knows the lightning in a bottle they captured. But what i think Konami should do is remake metal gear 1 and metal gear 2 solid snake on unreal engine 5 and have david hayter write the script.
adamsapple
Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
Killer8
Gold Member
Capcom have handled Resident Evil better than Konami handled Silent Hill, but they are not perfect and treated their own franchise horrifically in the mid-2010s. People forget that in a 5 year period their output was Resident Evil 6, Operation Raccoon City, Umbrella Corps and the middling Revelations 2. Just trash.
It was only through what was essentially a first-person reboot (RE7), its sequel, and a slew of remakes that have all followed a very similar formula, that they got the series back on track. Even then, they still released multiplayer flops like Resistance and Re:Verse, and as much as I liked the RE3 remake it also had its detractors.
RE was also always a much, much bigger franchise than Silent Hill. You could throw a dart at a board and hit a RE game with higher sales than the entire SH series put together. Capcom have a winning formula again and much higher budgets to throw around, versus the guerrilla publishing approach that Konami have to do where they're licensing the IP out to cheap indie and AA developers to see what will stick after a 10 year hiatus.
Bring Back Scalebound
Banned
Completely agree. I meant in recent years. But I didn't specify that, my bad.
After RE 1 and 2 Remake, 3 broke the streak they were having, for sure... I really like it too, but yeah...
You are right, yeah...
Doom85
Gold Member
Revelations 2 slaps and was a big improvement over the mixed bag that was Revelations 1.
bitbydeath
Gold Member
Silent Hill 1 is still the best IMO
2 is better than 3 though.
All three are fondly remembered.
Punished Miku
Human Rights Subscription Service
"Mostly." But sure, I agree.
TerribleAtThisGame
Member
Let's not forget that while it looks like an interesting Horror game, SH f looks like Konami threw some money and the franchise name at a random Horror game project. Much like the other shit they're throwing against the wall to get on that RE Remake hype, if it didn't have the name attached, it would have no discernible elements of the series. This one just happens to not come off like PURE bargain bin trash like the other random multimedia nonsense.
Last edited:
yurinka
Member
Yes, they have been developing games since over 40 years ago.
ChorizoPicozo
Member
Dirk Benedict
Member
Pretty much. I am well prepared to endure the shitty writing from start to end, if that's what it ends up being.
I think the graphics look nice, so I don't really feel there is a problem there.