Support NeoGAF

[Snowball]

How many games were able to get a perfect score on Edge?

Am i missing any title?

Mario 64
Zelda: Ocarina of Time
Gran Turismo
Halo


Thanks!
Snowball

 

[Lakitu]

Let's hope Halo 2 is eventually added to that

 

[SantaC]

While we are at it, has any game ever got a 10 from gamespot?

 

[Buggy Loop]

While we are at it, has any game ever got a 10 from gamespot?

According to gamespot's search engine

Zelda oot
Soul calibur
Chrono cross
THPS 3

 

[Catchpenny]

^^

Damn, beat me to it.

 

[SantaC]

According to gamespot's search engine

Zelda oot
Soul calibur
Chrono cross
THPS 3

Thanks. Kinda agree with those.

 

[teepo]

Let's hope Halo 2 is eventually added to that

lets hope everygame in the universe is added to that.

 

[GaimeGuy]

According to gamespot's search engine

Zelda oot
Soul calibur
Chrono cross
THPS 3

Yes, Yes, WHAT, NO!

 

[deadhorse32]

Let's hope Halo 2 is eventually added to that

From what i read here and there it won't ....

I'm so BANNED

 

[Lakitu]

From what i read here and there it won't ....

I'm so BANNED

You're judging that on people who've played the **** (not a swear word) version, who honestly can't write or judge for shit? I'm going to wait for some decent reviews, that's why I'm avoiding any impressions. Damn killjoys!

 

[brandonnn]

http://www.ga-forum.com/showpost.php?p=414130&postcount=15

 

[DopeyFish]

You're judging that on people who've played the **** (not a swear word) version, who honestly can't write or judge for shit? I'm going to wait for some decent reviews, that's why I'm avoiding any impressions. Damn killjoys!

99% of the "impressions" i've read so far from those morons have all had inconsistencies, sheer bias or were pretty much bullshit.

I don't trust most peoples opinions which are based on a pirate copy or a free copy.(unless they're a trusted reviewer)

Oh, and I can't imagine having fun playing Halo in french. It would pretty much ruin any immersion going for it for me =P (another reason I don't trust any "impressions")

 

[deadhorse32]

Thread successfully derailed

 

[Coen]

EDGE will never give Halo 2 a ten, just because it's Halo 2.

 

[Sjoerd]

99% of the "impressions" i've read so far from those morons have all had inconsistencies, sheer bias or were pretty much bullshit.

I don't trust most peoples opinions which are based on a pirate copy or a free copy.(unless they're a trusted reviewer)

Oh, and I can't imagine having fun playing Halo in french. It would pretty much ruin any immersion going for it for me =P (another reason I don't trust any "impressions")

Agreed, the game seems to be exeeding expectations, or so I've hear from a very reriable source
Let's wait untill november when the reviews come in. Most people in the 'warez scene' only care about downloading anyway, playing the games isn't even important to them.

 

[8bit]

Snowball, considering you've been privy to early Edge scores before, does the next issue have anything notable in it like another perfect score?

 

[RevenantKioku]

:lol
God bless damage control.

 

[Deleted member 1235]

Agreed, the game seems to be exeeding expectations, or so I've hear from a very reriable source

Likewise.


The only negatives I really read were from retards who kept yelling things like "FUK AM ROCK!" seemingly at random, probably not a solid opinion.

 

[Chittagong]

EDGE will never give Halo 2 a ten, just because it's Halo 2.

If Driver 3 is taken as an analogy of that, Halo 2 wil get a 2.

 

[Kiriku]

Agreed, the game seems to be exeeding expectations, or so I've hear from a very reriable source
Let's wait untill november when the reviews come in. Most people in the 'warez scene' only care about downloading anyway, playing the games isn't even important to them.

My sources state that the game is good, but not 10/10 amazing. And I wonder...if people in the "warez scene" don't even spend time playing a game, why would they care about writing up impressions?

 

[Dead]

According to gamespot's search engine

Zelda oot
Soul calibur
Chrono cross
THPS 3

Only Zelda and CC deserve that score. THPS3? no.....

 

[eso76]

EDGE will never give Halo 2 a ten, just because it's Halo 2.

Half Life 2 is a 2 too, but it's going get a perfect ten from edge. Well i don't know for sure, but i think so.

I don't think halo 2 could ever represent what its prequel did 3 years ago; with that said, i wouldn't give much credit to the opinions of ppl who pirated it right away. Just another dvd-r release for them...

 

[Prine]

99% of the "impressions" i've read so far from those morons have all had inconsistencies, sheer bias or were pretty much bullshit.

I don't trust most peoples opinions which are based on a pirate copy or a free copy.(unless they're a trusted reviewer)

Oh, and I can't imagine having fun playing Halo in french. It would pretty much ruin any immersion going for it for me =P (another reason I don't trust any "impressions")

IAWTMotherFuckingP!


OA is not the place to go for impressions. Especially when its written Xbox haters

 

[Mike Works]

Half Life 2 is a 2 too, but it's going get a perfect ten from edge. Well i don't know for sure, but i think so.

Oh well there you go folks, I was on the fence about this issue but there's your proof right there

 

[gofreak]

I'm thinking Halo2 = 9. Just my prediction.

 

[MetatronM]

Only Zelda and CC deserve that score. THPS3? no.....

Ironically, the only game you didn't mention is the only one on the list deserving of a 10.

 

[AlphaSnake]

All 4 of GameSpot's 10s deserved it.

 

[Insertia]

after chatting with a buddy of mine, I don't think Halo 2 will recieve mass 10's...

 

[Deleted member 1235]

after chatting with a buddy of mine, I don't think Halo 2 will recieve mass 10's...

whys that? I heard the opposite. And the multi play sounds kickass. No more bloodgulch being the only great level.

From the E3 beta I got to play, while only zanzibar, that level is absolutely wicked.

 

[Ristamar]

THPS 3 didn't deserve a 10, IMO. It was good, but I'd hardly consider the game legendary. I had much more fun with THPS 2.

 

[djtiesto]

Ugh, none of the Tony Hawk games deserve a 10... They're decent games, but there's not enough depth to them at all. And Chrono Cross was such a mess that it'd be lucky to get a 7, let alone a 10...

 

[miyuru]

I don't think THPS games should receive 10's. They're great, and I think they get 10's because reviewers can't think up many improvements to be made to the games themselves (objectively speaking). But 10's should be reserved for you know, those certain really special games. Give THPS a 9.5 or something, it sounds more reasonable IMO.