• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Game Informer Football game comparison

retardboy

Member
According to someone at OS:

In the brand new issue of Game Informer, one of the most detailed heads to head on the 2005 new football games... here is a roundup...


Graphics ESPN =Winner

Franchise ESPN =Winner

Gameplay: Tied. Close but they say Madden wins and that the Hitstick beats out the Maximum tackle featue, but then goes on to say that for the arcade ballers, Madden is better, for sim ballers, ESPN is better.


Direct quote regarding gameplay: "My personal feeling on this is that with it being so close that those who want arcadey football will prefer Madden while the sim ballers will appreciate ESPN more."

Online ESPN = Winner

The Prognostication;

In the end when you factor in everything mentioned above, The Crib, First Person Football, The Possiblilities for the VIP profiles and the online seasons, and its affordable price;We think that while Madden will probably lead in sales, it looks like this is the year that ESPN Beats Madden as a game.

Online for ESPN 2K5..for the first time you and 31 people can play through an entire 16 game season (With injuries), including the playoffs.

ESPN offers 480p, 200 more cutscenes, Triple pass rendering..which means you can see the veins in the players arms, Xbox owners can drop their own songs in..PS2 owners can do the same but with preselected songs on the game.

ESPN offers 25 different Dances with 20 more unlockable through the crib..even signature moves like the Deon Sanders Primetime dane or the Warren Sapps aweful bunny hop move...

Also new are the booya matchups, These are challenges you get in your crib from celebs via phone on your bar, and you can win prizes by winning ..

Franchise -ESPN, instead of fiddling with Hot dog prices like in Madden ESPN is putting you in the coaches shoes during the week leading upto Sundays game, set the schedule, Study film..you get 60 hours a week to use, there is even sensitivity training and deep tissue massage, the depth is amazing, rehab your injured players to get them back and healthy.

each week there is now Sportscenter, with injury reports from Trey Wingo, Rookies will have randomly generated faces and Mel Kiper Jr. will give his thoughts on who is the best of the best in the college draft, all in all ESPN finally beats Madden in Depth and origanality..Long live the new Football king!
 

TheDuce22

Banned
Im not getting too hyped untill I play it for myself. Espn football has always been infinitly better than madden in almost every aspect except the franchise modes. Last year the problems with the run game, that nobody mentioned in their reviews, really turned me off so I ended up playing Nfl2k3 more than anything.
 

Musashi Wins!

FLAWLESS VICTOLY!
I'm excited that it's so cheap so I don't have to make any sort of immediate choice (no guilt). That said, I remember it winning a few review scores last year and Madden clearly was the better playing game then.
 

sprsk

force push the doodoo rock
hahaha as a gamestop employee who works under a maddenite i cannot wait to shove that article in his face.
 

Eggo

GameFan Alumnus
I can't wait for this game. Of all the NFL titles, this one has me most pumped, and the price and early ship date are just gravy.
 

Alcibiades

Member
sp0rsk said:
hahaha as a gamestop employee who works under a maddenite i cannot wait to shove that article in his face.

I hope in a few weeks this statement turns into:

"hahaha as a gamestop employee who works under a maddenite i cannot wait to shove those sales numbers in his face."
 

retardboy

Member
efralope said:
I hope in a few weeks this statement turns into:

"hahaha as a gamestop employee who works under a maddenite i cannot wait to shove those sales numbers in his face."


Guess you lose m0dus! It was less than one page!
 

Alcibiades

Member
retardboy said:
Guess you lose m0dus! It was less than one page!

doesn't matter, NFL 2k5 is out next week, we'll have to see how it catches on... If they can sell a million across both platforms that would be quite an accomplishment compared to previous years...

Madden will be old news for some people...
 
Top Bottom