I'm going through the 2011 GOTY casts again because I fucking hate myself. I remember it being bad, but not this bad, and honestly it's mostly Brad. The whole Skyrim thing aside, up to where I'm at in the podcast, he made some really strange and paper thin arguments for trying to keep Renegade Ops on the list. One of them went something like this:
Vinny: I think Renegade Ops is pretty shallow.
Brad: No, it's not. It has RPG mechanics!
Patrick: Yeah, but the RPG mechanics are pretty shallow.
Brad: No they're not. If you level up and pick the perk that gives you more special ammo then you can use the special attack more.
Then he goes on to compare Rayman Origins to fucking Bubsy! I... what?! God, I feel like my brain is fucking melting. One redeeming part was when he tried to cut SR3 early and everyone laughed at him.