• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Got an absolutely retarded idea that would make a great game? POST IT HERE!

Everyone has some completely stupid thoughts once in awhile. They are often random, nonsensical, and sometimes borderline psychotic. But many of them might make great games!

I'll kick off this thread with a dialogue between a few friends about our idea for the BEST GAME EVER:

reederaid=me, friends 1 and 2 = my chaps
reederaid: Yeah, and Rian and I were just having a conversation about videogames, in which we devised an idea for the GREATEST GAME EVER
Friend 2: oh!?
reederaid:

---Friend 1: indeed.
Friend 1: dude two words.
Friend 1: B
Friend 1: O
Friend 1: correction
Friend 1: B
Friend 1: I
Friend 1: G
Friend 1: B
Friend 1: O
Friend 1: S
reederaid: BO!? BO!!! BO KNOWS STEALTH ACTION!!
reederaid: Seriously, best game ever: A game where Bo Jackson becomes a Ninja and has to infiltrate the white house to kidnap the president
Friend 1: omg he doesn't need a sword, just a baseball bat
reederaid: Hahahahaha
Friend 1: alright, later dude. ------

Friend 2: WOW, don't forget though, he played football too
reederaid: LOL, yeah, that's his projectile attack, a football to the face and/or crotch
Friend 2: hahahaha
Friend 2: now... will there be a deon sanders-like sidekick?
Friend 2: with the power of annoyance and bling?
reederaid: LOL, he'll be in the game via Metal Gear Solid-like codec conversations
reederaid: "Yo Deon!?"
Friend 2: hahahaha
reederaid: "SUP G!"
reederaid: ""I KNOW STUFF!!"
reederaid: ""BLAU!!""
reederaid: ""KEEP IT REAL HOMIE!""
reederaid: ""STAY KRUNK MOTHAFUCKA"
reederaid: OMG why isn't this a game yet
Friend 2: hahaha I don't know. john madden should be the Money penny of it all though
reederaid: hahahahaha
Friend 2: now here's a guy that if, uh, if, uh... the president has the ball, and you kidnap him, but he doesn't drop it... then, that's not gonna be a fumble

Yes, this absolutely insane idea was born as a result from a conversation about Metal Gear Solid 3. Does it make any sense!? Hell no!

What are some of YOUR retarded ideas!? Don't be shy, you ALL have them.
 
bjork said:
I'm just waiting for games based on the Lumberjack Olympics and the World's Strongest Man competitions.

c_man_g.jpg


Close enough?
 
That's not retarded. That sounds fucking awesome. I would buy that game. Anything with Bo Jackson would rule.

My idea would be:

You are John Madden. You have to make it across the country in the Madden Bus, but it cannot go under 50 mph. If it does, Al Michaels dies.
 
PuertoRicanJuice said:
That's not retarded. That sounds fucking awesome. I would buy that game. Anything with Bo Jackson would rule.

My idea would be:

You are John Madden. You have to make it across the country in the Madden Bus, but it cannot go under 50 mph. If it does, Al Michaels dies.

The point is that although the idea is retarded, the game would STILL RULE. That is the brainstorming objective of this thread.

And John Madden Speed would kick all sorts of ass.
 
how about this game where you roll a giant ball around collecting items to rebuild a planet? i know its a shitty idea, but it would give hardcore elite game fans something to proclaim game of the year (just for the sake of having a lesser known title be best game), and also they would jizz in their pants over the prospect of it becoming a rare game in the future :D
 
I once had an idea to rearrange some stuff together.

The game starts out like Shenmue, 3rd person dialogue, fetch quests, in a neighborhood. You slowly get to meet everyone.



Then 15-20 hours into the game, it jumps into a first-person shooter and you need to kill everyone in the village because they all got infected by some virus and they're insane. Alot of guts, completely unexpected because you really thought you were buying and playing a shenmue type game.

haha, it would be great if it didn't completely alienate the audience. Only maybe 20% of the people who will play it will understand. But they will bow down to the game as their new god once they do.
 
Date of Lies said:
I once had an idea to rearrange some stuff together.

The game starts out like Shenmue, 3rd person dialogue, fetch quests, in a neighborhood. You slowly get to meet everyone.



Then 15-20 hours into the game, it jumps into a first-person shooter and you need to kill everyone in the village because they all got infected by some virus and they're insane. Alot of guts, completely unexpected because you really thought you were buying and playing a shenmue type game.

haha, it would be great if it didn't completely alienate the audience. Only maybe 20% of the people who will play it will understand. But they will bow down to the game as their new god once they do.
Did you like From Dusk Till Dawn?
 
gahiggidy.gif


Seriously though, the retarded ideas can be pretty funny (as per the Bo idea). It only truely becomes annoying when the person explaining it becomes paranoid about said idea and how they think it may lead them on a rollercoaster ride to fame and moneyhats.
 
How about a game called Final Fantasy X-tasy-2 - now that would be fucked up....

Oh, someone alredy made that??
 
My friend had an idea...around 10 years ago, where you would be a bus driver, and had to be the best in town. That mean you had to drive fast and pick up as many kids as you can. You'd have rivals who'd race you and you'd run into each other. But you can tell some kids to run outside the bus so you can use them as a shield. The more kids you can pick up = more shielding.
 
I don't think that would be soooo stupid to make a winning eleven based games with Captain Tsubasa characters and add some special shoot. Konami would sell big !
 
Fight for Freeform said:
My friend had an idea...around 10 years ago, where you would be a bus driver, and had to be the best in town. That mean you had to drive fast and pick up as many kids as you can. You'd have rivals who'd race you and you'd run into each other. But you can tell some kids to run outside the bus so you can use them as a shield. The more kids you can pick up = more shielding.

This idea brought to mind an image right away: An overhead, GTA2 style view of Otto's bus on "The Simpsons", only every time you slam the bus against another vehicle, a kid goes flying through a window on the opposite side. :lol
 
Crazymoogle, your avatar is SO FUCKING CUTE! GAH! It's killing me, I cannot even bear to look at it without squealing "OMG ITS SO CUTE" It is like the cutest thing I've ever seen. I cant. stop. looking!!!

I fully condone any Taiko/Moogle game anyone cooks up
 
This idea brought to mind an image right away: An overhead, GTA2 style view of Otto's bus on "The Simpsons", only every time you slam the bus against another vehicle, a kid goes flying through a window on the opposite side.

ROFL, knocking out kids was part of his idea, plus it was going to look like the Micro Machines titles...which is just like GTA 1/2. Funny that you saw it the same way without me mentioning it.
 
Harvest Moon: Blood Harvest

Rated M for Mature.

Imagine if you could use that sickle on anything or anyone in the game. You could sabotage neighbors' farms and become the sole supplier to the town. You could be a crime lord, and have minions do your bidding, and have people give you money and ask for favors in exchange for goods and services.
 
scola said:
Oregon Trail
online

That's an awesome idea, we talked about that on irc one night.

If you could ambush people and take their wagons and stuff, oh man...

$9/mo? I'm there.
 
Here's an idea for a game.

There's this guy. He doesn't have any sort of superhuman powers. What he has is a knack for being wherever people are doing stupid shit. He is also an official NINJA with a tire iron. Like, I'm talking NINJA. So he does what anyone would do: starts wearing a black on black suit, carrying around a briefcase with a tire iron inside of it, and calls himself Quality Control Man. I can only imagine what he would do to people like Olimario.
 
I'm working on this in my spare time.

You are a flying, ninja cock-donkey.

This is basically a unicorn like animal, but with a very huge cock that weighs it down a bit, and ninja skills, like being able steal things and hide very well.

You also have leprosy.

It's a stealth game with a difference - you can fly, hide, steal, but your flesh is constantly falling off, because you are a leper.

You cover your tracks by eating your own fallen flesh.

The objective of the game is to make enough money from stealing things, to be able to pay a scientist a large pile of cash to cure your leprosy.

The End.
 
Damn stupid idea for a game but here it is:

You are a company who has a history of making AAA videogames and consoles, but have been on a rapid decline for generations in a row. The objective is to manage the company so that they aren't forced to drop out of the industry.

It's a stupid idea because this could never happen in real life. Ever. Wait, it does sound kinda familiar though. OHHHHH... sh
 
I was thinking maybe a company could make an intentionally bad game. The whole premise of the game would be to use all the aspects of the bad game to your advantage, trapping enemies in invisble walls, finding the right walls to walk right through then locking enemies out, getting bad collision upgrades so you can hit enemies from longer and longer ranges. It would be nothing but taking advantage of, and avoiding bad glitches. Maybe bosses could be all the different bad programmers of the game, but since they are awful devs their implementation of themselves comes out horribly wrong and produces the freakiest glitch bosses with the weirdest half working abilities. The whole game could just be a 24/7 joke about bad games. It would be funny to see how the media people will review a game like this, will giving it a 1 be a compliment? :lol
 
hobbitx said:
I was thinking maybe a company could make an intentionally bad game. The whole premise of the game would be to use all the aspects of the bad game to your advantage, trapping enemies in invisble walls, finding the right walls to walk right through then locking enemies out, getting bad collision upgrades so you can hit enemies from longer and longer ranges. It would be nothing but taking advantage of, and avoiding bad glitches. Maybe bosses could be all the different bad programmers of the game, but since they are awful devs their implementation of themselves comes out horribly wrong and produces the freakiest glitch bosses with the weirdest half working abilities. The whole game could just be a 24/7 joke about bad games. It would be funny to see how the media people will review a game like this, will giving it a 1 be a compliment? :lol

:lol
 
A XXX MMO like the Sims Online that allows players to graphically screw each other.

Your character levels and learns more positions and animations the more he or she screws.

ALSO

A scuba diving game kinda like Pokemon snap

AND

A stealth game based on The Diary of Anne Frank
 
Duck of Death said:
Everyone has some completely stupid thoughts once in awhile. They are often random, nonsensical, and sometimes borderline psychotic. But many of them might make great games!

I'll kick off this thread with a dialogue between a few friends about our idea for the BEST GAME EVER:

reederaid=me, friends 1 and 2 = my chaps


Yes, this absolutely insane idea was born as a result from a conversation about Metal Gear Solid 3. Does it make any sense!? Hell no!

What are some of YOUR retarded ideas!? Don't be shy, you ALL have them.

Shaq Fu comes to mind.

What about a game where you're a fat plumber who has to save a princess by eating magic mushrooms and flowers that make him throw fireballs from his mouth? Oh wait..
 
Stealth Wank. Attempt to get away with masturbating in potentially embarrassing locations while others remain oblivious. It could have Shenmue-like button control.
 
riverdance ds. it would come with tiny shoes for your index and middle fingers. it's the game the ds was built to do.
 
Hide And Go Seek!

I actually remember playing a Hide And Go Seek game as a kid on either a Colecovision or Atari console. The best part? You could hide under the frickin house!!!!! hahaha :lol
 
When I was a kid, I programmed about a billion BASIC/assembler games on my family's Apple II. Most of these were completely retarded, of course. A couple of them:

Kamikaze: Fly your unarmed Japanese plane, avoiding the US planes that are trying to shoot you down, make it to the enemy fleet, and crash it into the enemy battleship. If you hit the ship at a good angle, you'll sink it! THE END.

Continental Drift: For some reason that could be easily explained in some shitty sci-fi novel, you are experiencing time at an extremely slow rate. Because of this, the continents are drifting at an extremely fast pace! Jump from one piece of land to another, (I guess you're also really fucking huge) as the continents split and move around, and avoid falling in the acid oceans (uh...) while avoiding these... things... that, uh, chase you? (um, sentient glaciers?) Okay, this one was REALLY retarded, but the continents moving and breaking up was cool, AM I RITE?

Then there was the one I never got around to making, although I had it pretty well worked out in my head. We had a labrador/german shepherd mix dog, and she shat all over the damn lawn. It was my job to scoop poop and mow the lawn, and for some ungodly dumb reason I thought it would make a good game. Basically, you have a backyard, where the grass keeps growing, and there's a dog that runs around it, periodically taking a shit. You have a pooper scooper and a lawnmower, and you can only use one at a time. If you run over poop with the lawnmower, you get stalled for a bit, and if a patch of grass grows too tall, the game is over. I had some other ideas about also needing to keep the dog fed and bag the clippings, but that's about the gist of it. Instead of actually making this game, I just decided that the best thing to do with a lawn is to pour acid on it, and it's better to have a cat for a pet because they know how to bury their shit. :P
 
This is an idea of mine.

The game is called "Fort". It's a first person shooter.

In this game, you occupy an apartment building, castle, military compound, etc. (upgrades are unlockable)

The objective of this game is to blow up your opponent's building, and theirs is the opposite. And when I say this, I mean that the building has to crumble to the ground. It's completely online-based.
 
A stealth game where you're trying to sneak out of the office early on Friday. You must avoid things like running into people from the HR department, and the cameras by the door.
 
Speevy said:
This is an idea of mine.

The game is called "Fort". It's a first person shooter.

In this game, you occupy an apartment building, castle, military compound, etc. (upgrades are unlockable)

The objective of this game is to blow up your opponent's building, and theirs is the opposite. And when I say this, I mean that the building has to crumble to the ground. It's completely online-based.

Cue "will there be mods based on real life disasters?" post
 
tedtropy said:
Stealth Wank. Attempt to get away with masturbating in potentially embarrassing locations while others remain oblivious. It could have Shenmue-like button control.

*deet-deetdeet BZZZZ*

"YOU SICK FREAK!"
 
Always dreamed of a fighting game featuring French Canadians. It would feature swear words, made in Quebec and only for Quebecers.

Some quotes from different characters would be:
- "Première ronde, pognez-vous!"
- "Tin mon tabarnak"
- "J'te pète la yeule!"
- "Salope!"
- "Criss de tapette"
- "T'es aussi fif que ton père"

It would feature local stars like:

Anne-Marie Losique:
213_1.jpg


Claude Rajotte:
pop2_claude_rajotte_qc.jpg


Roy Dupuis:
roydup34.jpg


Some different stages would take place in Drummondville, St-Eustache and Longueuil.

"Riot in Quebec City" would be the name of the game.

UbiSoft Montréal, make it happen! :D
 
There's these ugly polygon puppies, and you play with them WITH A STYLUS


Actually, I'd buy a DS if they had a game where you could pistol-whip a blubbering Nintendo fanboy using the stylus. The top screen could have a map or the sky or something.
 
OK here's my RETARDED idea:

You make any sports game ! Then, every year, you update the player roster, maybe add a few new player faces, then tack a new year at the end of the title !

The best part is, you charge 50 bucks for it ! Every year ! With (maybe) one new feature and a bunch of new faces and player names !

And hey, just to mix things up, sometimes you have a bug in the online play, and then give the players a lame-ass "fix" that actually destoys the gameplay completely !

I'm telling you, this is the best idea in the...

oh wait...
 
Top Bottom