Support NeoGAF

[RedDwarf]

I know that there are copyright laws regarding the sale of region specific DVD's, but is changing a players firmware to be region free illegal? I know certain shops offer these modded players for sale, but can't figure out the actual legality. Anyone know?

 

[luxsol]

As legal as buying a modchip for your PS2 to play Japanese/America/whatever-reigion-you're-not-in games.

 

[Naked Snake]

Who cares? I bet the president of the MPAA region-freed his DVD player.

 

[demi]

I wish my DVD was region free, so I can watch my Spaced Collector's Set and DANGER 10,000 VOLTS dvds

 

[RedDwarf]

I found my answer in the Digital Millennium Copyright Act which reminded me that anything that circumvents copy protection is currently illegal. Silly DMCA.

 

[Shinobi]

I wish my DVD was region free, so I can watch my Spaced Collector's Set and DANGER 10,000 VOLTS dvds

Buy the latest Action Replay Max or similiar device from Gameshark for PS2...that should help you out.

 

[Neo_ZX]

I found my answer in the Digital Millennium Copyright Act which reminded me that anything that circumvents copy protection is currently illegal.

Remember that marker trick? Sharpies are illegal!

Copyright law needs an overhaul.

 

[belgurdo]

I wish my DVD was region free, so I can watch my Spaced Collector's Set and DANGER 10,000 VOLTS dvds

J-list or Ebay

 

[Miburou]

I found my answer in the Digital Millennium Copyright Act which reminded me that anything that circumvents copy protection is currently illegal. Silly DMCA.

What does making a player region-free have to do with copy protection? Bootleg DVDs are all-region anyway.

 

[mrkapawutzis]

Remember that marker trick? Sharpies are illegal!

Copyright law needs an overhaul.

What's the 411 on the Sharpie trick?!?

 

[RedDwarf]

What does making a player region-free have to do with copy protection?

In most cases, removing the region coding also messes with the discs copy protection, enabling the copying of said disc. I don't care and have a region free player, this question came up with a co-worker and the legality was questioned.

 

[cvxfreak]

It doesn't seem to be illegal.

Either way, I have DVD Players from Region 1 and Region 2 (as well as Region 3-5 via my modded Panasonic Q ).

 

[Phoenix]

Remember that marker trick? Sharpies are illegal!

FALSE

The act of circumventing the CD protection with the marker is what's illegal - not the posession of the marker itself. Its the same reason why you can own a duplicator for just about any form of media in existence - legally.

 

[G4life98]

FALSE

The act of circumventing the CD protection with the marker is what's illegal - not the posession of the marker itself. Its the same reason why you can own a duplicator for just about any form of media in existence - legally.

but if some of the crazy legislation they are proposing goes through... the shear fact that they can enable piracy would make them illegal