When I lived in NYC I used to get myself a breakfast bagel with sundried tomatoes, turkey breast and cheese and I don't recall it being more than $4, got me through most of my conservatory days lol. Also I had their rewards card, which kinda tended to glitch out so I could always get a free "birthday" pastry throughout the whole month of November instead of just on the day of my birthday. But all that was 5 years ago, so I guess they raised prices?