Q: How should I rate the categories?
A: Rate them on a scale of 0-100% based on your opinion of them. The rating scale is as follows:
100% = Perfect. You should probably stay away from this rating since nothing is perfect.
99-90% = Great. This is the equivalent of an A grade. Reserved for those categories that you believe are so outstanding that they are nearly perfect in every regard.
89-80% = Above Average. This is the equivalent of a B grade. Given to those categories which are more than satisfactory, but not the best quality ever.
79-70% = Average. This is the equivalent of a C grade. Given to those categories that are merely average. This does not mean that the category is bad, rather, it means it is on par with the majority of RPGs out there, and doesn't do anything out of the ordinary to catch the eye, ear, imagination, etc.
69-60% = Below Average. This is the equivalent of a D grade. Categories that merit this rating are sub-par or below that of most other RPGs out there. It says that there is a flaw in the category which hampers it somewhat.
59-0% = Poor. This is the equivalent of an F grade. For a category to receive this grade, it must present itself in such a manner that it severely detracts from enjoyment of the game, or is a source of aggravation. Care should be taken when giving anything below a 60, for that is an indication that the category is shameful or reprehensible in some way. A more moderate rating would be a 69-60%