• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Reality TV Survey (short and by me)

Status
Not open for further replies.

SD-Ness

Member
Yes, please keep this conversation serious. I'm writing an editorial for the newspaper and need some motivation. Answer these questions if you feel like it.

1. What do you think of reality TV? Explain your stance.

2. Why do you think it's so popular?

3. When did you remember first hearing about it?

4. When do you think it will lose its flair?
 

Vlad

Member
Zero said:
Yes, please keep this conversation serious. I'm writing an editorial for the newspaper and need some motivation. Answer these questions if you feel like it.

1. What do you think of reality TV? Explain your stance.

In theory, it's a neat idea. When it started with stuff like The Real World and it was enough to just watch a bunch of people in a house. However, it's been pretty well run into the ground at this point with what seems like every channel under the sun doing way too many of their own takes on the reality thing. While there's still a few good shows in the genre, like Amazing Race, there's way more garbage than actual entertaining television.

And then there's the fact that perfectly good shows are being cancelled left and right, with a seemingly endless stream of reality shows still popping up.

2. Why do you think it's so popular?
Well, from the network's perspective, it's mainly because they've gotta be cheap to produce. There's more of a chance of profiting off a reality show, or at least any losses will be far less.

As far as their apparent popularity with the public, I think a lot of it has to do with the novelty of having "real" people to watch. It appeals to the voyeur in people, being able to watch what they think are real people reacting to whatever situation they're in. There's a novelty there that doesn't exist with a scripted show.

3. When did you remember first hearing about it?
Well, the first show in the genre that I can remember seeing was the original Real World. However, I don't remember hearing the term "reality TV" until a short while after Survivor's popularity, and the ensuing flood of reality shows.

4. When do you think it will lose its flair?
I think it's already starting to lose its a little bit of its luster, personally. I don't know the actual ratings numbers, but I get the feeling that aside from the more popular shows, people just aren't as interested in the stuff. Of course, it could just be wishful thinking, in the hopes of getting back to actual good TV.
 

Escape Goat

Member
1. What do you think of reality TV? Explain your stance.

I think its a bunch of crap. Its not real and whatever is going to create controversy or "good TV" will be shown. I need compelling characters, involving plot among other things to keep my interest. I don't care much for how homosexual Joe will get along with homophobe Steven on the desert island.


2. Why do you think it's so popular?

People's lives are so mundane they look to find excitement in other people's lives who their peers. Its the same reason Jerry Springer, Cops and MTV exist. Though its a cheap show to produce and generates high revenues for TV networks



3. When did you remember first hearing about it?

Back in high school, probably 1998.


4. When do you think it will lose its flair?

I don't know but it wont be soon enough.
 

Memles

Member
1. What do you think of reality TV? Explain your stance.

As someone who routinely watches, even sits up waiting until the torrents finish downloading (Damn University...or more simply, damn lackk of money for cable), reality television, I can honestly say that the reason I enjoy it as much as I do is because of the interpersonal relations.

However, there is a limit to how much of this I can take. I love some shows because on top of providing that interpersonal dynamic, they offer something else. The Amazing Race has people racing around the world, doing awesome stuff. They are slowly moving further towards more of a personal attack realm (The Yield, the constant emphasis on Colin and Christies vs. Mirna and Charla this past season), but in the end the show is still about waiting to see who will cross a finish line first. You get so attached to these people, that when that team crosses that finish line you scream out loud, start cheering, and then lose all self control.

This is why I love reality television. You become invested in these people not unlike yourself. I related to Chip because he was so AMUSED by everything. I related to him because he said "It's on like Donkey Kong" and "We're on the NILE" with such youthful exuberance, despite being one of the older guys on the race. You get to enjoy these people so much that the emotional investment keeps you there, not the show itself.

Survivor falls into the other category; where it's all about these people fighting out amongst one another. The tasks are there to provide reward and immunity, but too often it falls into product placement, and fails to really provide something other than pure bitching. And do you know what, it has its charms as well.

The Apprentice has enough of both to be a perfect amalgamation. It has the bitchiness of the boardroom combined with the task at hand, which themselves can be really cool to watch. Watching the Saturday reruns of The Apprentice, where it has like 40 minutes of Boardroom footage, is so interesting, because it's like a different show without the balance. An interesting one, but different.

It's about balance. Part of it is about the game; the other half is about the people. The more you get invested in one, usually the more you get invested in the other. Some shows, like Big Brother, or The Surreal Life, are nothing but people. Reality Competition Programs (As the Emmy category calls them) have enough of everything to keep me entertained, unless the subject matter (To an extent, American Idol [Although I get addicted to it, I don't consider it good TV] and, definitely, Last Comic Standing) isn't what I like.

2. Why do you think it's so popular?

Because people like to see people they could be doing stuff they could do and interacting as they would. And, because it's cheap to produce, they cana pump out so many of them that they almost promote each other.

And of course, people love clusterfucks. And these shows will give you such bitchiness and terrible human relations skills in fine form, and people love seeing people destroy their integrity. It's just human nature.

3. When did you remember first hearing about it?

Entertainment Tonight was on. Mary Hart was speaking far too excitedly, and Bob Goen was...well, I don't have an adjective for him, so sue me.

Anyways, they talked about how CBS had gotten the rights to a Swedish show where people were put on a deserted island and had to fend for themselves.

My thought was "How stupid! What, they watch people starve? Who cares about that!?". I have since watched every single season of the show, and consider it to be good television. It has had its off moments, but the concept was so much more than people on a desert island. It was about the game, and how they worked as tribes. THAT was the true beginning of reality TV, when someone combined those two aspects well enough to make engaging television.

4. When do you think it will lose its flair?

The good shows won't. The Apprentice, Survivor and The Amazing Race have enough of the right qualities to keep going and going, because the nature of people to be competitive and sometimes complete idiots will not change. The viewing tastes of the public will be what will have to change for these shows to lose their flair.
 

tt_deeb

Member
Zero said:
Yes, please keep this conversation serious. I'm writing an editorial for the newspaper and need some motivation. Answer these questions if you feel like it.

1. What do you think of reality TV? Explain your stance.

I got really addicted to it about 2 years ago but I haven't been watching any TV recently at all so I guess I'm indifferent. I'd probably still enjoy watching some (I wish I could've seen Joe Schmo 2) but I just don't have time for it. I only keep up with Real World since it's always being replayed on MTV and therefore not hard to miss.

2. Why do you think it's so popular?

As others have mentioned people just find excitement in others lives and I guess they can relate to them at a point. It's interesting to picture yourself in some of the situations and how you would react.

3. When did you remember first hearing about it?

Probably Real World during the late 90s but the first one I watched was the first season of Survivor in 1999. Unless you consider America's Funniest Home Videos which I've watched since I was a kid.

4. When do you think it will lose its flair?

Compared to the last few years it's already beginning to lose it's flair. I remember at a point it seemed like there was new ones being introduced weekly. Now, we have an occasional new idea pop up but only traditional ones like Real World and Fear Factor seem to be getting any attention. Survivor has been milked enough and will hopefully stop soon. Most new ideas don't have much of a chance to become successful enough to be noteworthy. As far as I'm concernced, it's lost most of it's flair but they'll still always be some shows(specifically the good ones which can hold our interests) around like the above mentioned.
 

Ollie Pooch

In a perfect world, we'd all be homersexual
1. What do you think of reality TV? Explain your stance.
i get tired of the 'talent show' ones - which are basically like a focus group in which you pay to participate :p i get hooked on the amazing race and america's next top model though.. and the apprentice! i generally dislike any shows that involve the public voting on them.

2. Why do you think it's so popular?
well with many of them you can jump in at any time without knowing about a backstory/characters and it's easy, lazy entertainment.

3. When did you remember first hearing about it?
when the first australian big brother was on. *shudder*

4. When do you think it will lose its flair?
well i think it will stay a workable form of tv but only if people keep thinking up new concepts for it
 

Tsubaki

Member
1. What do you think of reality TV? Explain your stance.

I love some, avoid others. What I dig are things like Survivor and The Real World where group dynamics between varying personality types are what it centers upon. The more game-show-y types are just stupid, especially the reality dating ones. Ugh.

2. Why do you think it's so popular?

Because it's unscripted. Sure, the producers can do a lot of things to influence the course of events. And the editors can create tense drama out of bits they capture. But ultimately, everything does happen spontaneously, and the result is far more engaging than any written plot IMO.

But there are two types of people when it comes to entertainment. People who love realism, and enjoy things that talk about real life issues, that portray believeable characters, etc. And people who love escapism, where their entertainment comes from watching things that make you forget about real life. If you're an escapist, of course you would hate reality TV.

3. When did you remember first hearing about it?

About the time when Real World came out. Never had cable though, so I probably didn't get into reality TV until the first Survivor came out.

4. When do you think it will lose its flair?

I don't know, but I also hope it does lose its flair so that only the quality ones would remain on the air.
 

Diablos

Member
1. What do you think of reality TV? Explain your stance.
I hate it. Old real world/road rules was good, now it all sucks. But for some reason I find myself watching Big Brother every other year.

2. Why do you think it's so popular?
Because Americans are bored

3. When did you remember first hearing about it?
Dunno

4. When do you think it will lose its flair?
Not for at least another 5 years
 

Brian Fellows

Pete Carroll Owns Me
1. What do you think of reality TV? Explain your stance.

Outside of Survivor I dont watch the crap and even Survivor is losing its charm.

2. Why do you think it's so popular?

Cuz the mindless masses enjoy crap.

3. When did you remember first hearing about it?

After Survivor exploded. I dont really consider the Real World to be reality TV.

4. When do you think it will lose its flair?

3 years ago.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom