TheGreatDave said:
I dunno, most of GH:2's new stuff doesn't strike me as a huge deal breaker. The only new feature that really mattered to me was the co-op, and even then the way you couldn't play bass/rhythm in single player seriously lowered the usage I got from it personally. Especially when my girlfriend never wants to play any mode but Pro Face Off and it didn't have any online modes on 360. I think BotB and online World Tour are a bigger deal than anything in GH:2, but I guess it comes down to your own needs, wants and DESIRES.
Ah, therein lay the issues stripped bare, ugly, and naked for the whole world to see and laugh at how pathetically small they are and how quickly they likely... erm, this is getting a bit too far now.
Anyhow, my girlfriend doesn't like competitive games so we
never play Face-Off. We also don't play any multiplayer games where we compete which works out well because I can't think of any that I own that would interest her for any reason anyhow. It's probably for the best as, well, she just can't compete. I'm much, much better than her and I play far, far more often.
While it sucks that bass has never had a solo career (until now!) I still spent a solid amount of time playing bass in practice mode on full speed for the full song. I never really cared that I didn't get stars or a score and I never did badly enough to have to worry about failing out so it was all pretty moot that I couldn't. It was an annoying kludge, but it worked.
BotB relies heavily on having a dedicated group of people on your friend's list to compare scores to and the desire to be very competitive on your score. Something that doesn't apply much to me. I care much more about playing perfectly and having fun than I do tweaking my score out.
Online BWT requires friends who would play with me. It also was something that was supposed to be in RB1 so I don't entirely count it. You don't get a reward for saying you'll do something, not doing it, and then eventually getting around to it. I know, I've tried this with my girlfriend and it doesn't work. You just get hit quite a lot. In the bollocks usually.