-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
(Square Enix) sales of FF16, FF7 Rebirth and Foamstars fell shorts of expectations
- Thread starter ArtHands
- Start date
- Status
//DEVIL//
Member
Because their expectations is 200 million copies for Foamstars that was on PS+ day one and 1 billion for each final fantasy.
They sold 3 Million copies of final fantasy 16 on ps5 alone when it was released and the ps5 was barely 3 years in.
How many fucking copies you want from a midcore game outside of the boss battles ???
They sold 3 Million copies of final fantasy 16 on ps5 alone when it was released and the ps5 was barely 3 years in.
How many fucking copies you want from a midcore game outside of the boss battles ???
Last edited:
James Sawyer Ford
Member
5 console teams?
1. DQ team
2. FF online team
3. FF16 team
4. Rebirth team
What’s the 5th? Forespken team? Thought they were integrated into other teams
1. DQ team
2. FF online team
3. FF16 team
4. Rebirth team
What’s the 5th? Forespken team? Thought they were integrated into other teams
adamsapple
Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
James Sawyer Ford
Member
So they made a new 5th team? The others are pretty well defined at this point
Hardensoul
Member
I guess it’s the 2D HD team? Octopath and Bravely Default devs are now under Square now?
Hardensoul
Member
I lost interest when combat became more action focused. Was hyped for FF7 remake until I saw the changes.
Last edited:
Tiago Rodrigues
Member
They spent 2 decades making mediocre games. They can't expect to repair that damage with a few game releases.
I'm still traumatized by those 3 FFXIII games, FFXV, etc...all that happened in a 15 year period. The exception was FFXIV and even that one released so bad that they had to re-release it later.
saintjules
Gold Member
Varteras
Member
James Sawyer Ford
Member
Hero_Select
Member
Yikes.
Hardensoul
Member
adamsapple
posted Bloomberg saying same thing.
Square Enix Shares Tumble by Most in 13 Years on Weak Outlook
Shares of Square Enix Holdings Co. tumbled 16% in their biggest decline in 13 years after its president said sales of recent big-budget games disappointed and that it would take years for a recent reorganization to bear fruit.
www.bloomberg.com
Fbh
Gold Member
FFXVI doesn't surprise me. The game kinda sucked, hype was high which seems in line with the initial momentum, but word of mouth was probably quite poor once people realized it's an ok action game locked to super easy mode and then merged with a 4/10 RPG.
Shame about Rebirth , from what I've heard it's a pretty solid game and released only 4 years after the last one which is pretty decent for modern standards. Personally I skipped it because of the terrible presentation in the demo, games are too expensive now to pay full price on anything but the best of the best.
Foamstars... lol.
The Square brand is damaged.
There was a time knowing a game was made by Square was enough to get me hyped, sort of like From Software these days.
Now it's pretty hit or miss. There hasn't been a good mainline FF (at least non MMO) in like 18 years (some would argue longer) and the smaller titles are very inconsistent in quality, you've got awesome stuff like Triangle Strategy and mediocre stuff like Diofield Chronicle. It's ok for games to have different budgets and scopes but everything should at least have a minimum standard in regard to story and gameplay.
The retarded names probably don't help either.
Shame about Rebirth , from what I've heard it's a pretty solid game and released only 4 years after the last one which is pretty decent for modern standards. Personally I skipped it because of the terrible presentation in the demo, games are too expensive now to pay full price on anything but the best of the best.
Foamstars... lol.
The Square brand is damaged.
There was a time knowing a game was made by Square was enough to get me hyped, sort of like From Software these days.
Now it's pretty hit or miss. There hasn't been a good mainline FF (at least non MMO) in like 18 years (some would argue longer) and the smaller titles are very inconsistent in quality, you've got awesome stuff like Triangle Strategy and mediocre stuff like Diofield Chronicle. It's ok for games to have different budgets and scopes but everything should at least have a minimum standard in regard to story and gameplay.
The retarded names probably don't help either.
Last edited:
bigdad2007
Member
SE is a broken record at this point it’s every time they release a game with broad appeal on not every platform and wonder why sales don’t meet expectations .
James Sawyer Ford
Member
Square Enix Shares Tumble by Most in 13 Years on Weak Outlook
Shares of Square Enix Holdings Co. tumbled 16% in their biggest decline in 13 years after its president said sales of recent big-budget games disappointed and that it would take years for a recent reorganization to bear fruit.
That guy is Bloomberg lol
adamsapple
Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
Square Enix Shares Tumble by Most in 13 Years on Weak Outlook
Shares of Square Enix Holdings Co. tumbled 16% in their biggest decline in 13 years after its president said sales of recent big-budget games disappointed and that it would take years for a recent reorganization to bear fruit.
The tweet in this topic's OT is linking to the same article.
Hardensoul
Member
Last edited:
Haint
Member
They lost like 2-3+ million full priced FF16 sales and 2-3+ million full priced Rebirth sales they'll never get back thanks to Sony's money hats. You got to be braindead as fuck to trade $100's of millions in sales for $10-$30 million dollar exclusivity contracts, it's not 1997 anymore.
Last edited:
ChorizoPicozo
Member
bro.... again... no hate... just harsh reality... SE has been so fucking mismanaged that they neeed to go under and rise from the ashes. they suuck hard at everything.
ChorizoPicozo
Member
not the issue
bitbydeath
Gold Member
feynoob
Banned
Square invested in nfts. Lost their fundings on that crap.
Hardensoul
Member
Maybe Square should do the Legend of Zelda model. A 2D and a 3D FF versions. I want the old school 2D turn base. Pixels art or any other 2D art.
vaibhavpisal
Member
-Has been relied too much on an individual's creativity. Will promote sharing game making how-how among teams and will seek best balance of individual creativity and organizational discipline
This sounds like a good move. Wonder why it took them so long to make this change.
At this rate maybe in a couple of decades they will start making decent games.
This sounds like a good move. Wonder why it took them so long to make this change.
At this rate maybe in a couple of decades they will start making decent games.
Aenima
Member
Square Enix expectations just lack common sense.
They made a main FF game (FF16) that is more an action game than a JRPG, what did you expect? (I loved FF16 for the combat, but is not the type of game FF fans expect from a main FF)
They made a remake of one of the most beloved FF games but splited a story already told between 3 games, are you expecting to sell more copies of the episode 2 compared to episode 1?
They made a main FF game (FF16) that is more an action game than a JRPG, what did you expect? (I loved FF16 for the combat, but is not the type of game FF fans expect from a main FF)
They made a remake of one of the most beloved FF games but splited a story already told between 3 games, are you expecting to sell more copies of the episode 2 compared to episode 1?
intheinbetween
Member
FF is such a big IP it can’t stand as an exclusive, its budget requires it to be released on as many platforms as possible to recoup the investment and make it profitable, e.g: Capcom managing the Resident Evil IP.
Btw FF XVI being a pure JRPG wouldn’t make it sell more copies, enough of excuses with it. Just another bland FF entry
semiconscious
Member
a formerly visionary developer that no longer has any vision. but, hey, thanks for all them good times...
This. When FF xv and ff7 remake came out, it was on an already established ps4 with a lot more console sales. Currently PS5 has not been sold that many times (not like ps4 at the time of the release) and so the audience is smaller. Also they made FF to be just another action game instead of a real jrpg FF. So they also lost much of their fan base there. Multiplatform release could have helped but that would have to include the switch.
Btw, FF7 rebirth was a nice nostalgic trip, but they changed so much, not everyone really liked it (including me). So they also lost some Fans of the series there, who will not pay full price or buy it at all.
MagiusNecros
Gilgamesh Fan Annoyance
And now it's all they have. They put all their eggs in one basket. The only IP to be excited about from them is Dragon Quest and maybe the odd AA game or two.
Their best games have been Octopath and SO2R.
StreetsofBeige
Gold Member
I never cared for SE games since JRPGs aren’t my thing.
Just want them to remaster a $20 version of einhander.
Just want them to remaster a $20 version of einhander.
ShadyAcshuns
Member
Give us lower budget AA games and stop chasing graphics so your games don't need to sell 10 million copies per game to be a success, and don't need 5-6 years of development.
Jinzo Prime
Gold Member
Don't forget about Kingdom Hearts:
- Rebirth Team (CBU1)
- Dragon Quest Team (CBU2)
- FF Online/FF16 Team (CBU3)
- Kingdom Hearts Team (Osaka Team)
- Team Asano (Maybe?)
- Mobile Team
Fabieter
Member
Square Enix Shares Tumble by Most in 13 Years on Weak Outlook
Shares of Square Enix Holdings Co. tumbled 16% in their biggest decline in 13 years after its president said sales of recent big-budget games disappointed and that it would take years for a recent reorganization to bear fruit.
With the same troll making the article.
ShaiKhulud1989
Gold Member
Mochizuki, really? Guy is lying like a congressman and you still believe his takes lol.
Jinzo Prime
Gold Member
I forgot about Tri-Ace!
Are they still going to be a separate company within SE?
Are they still going to be a separate company within SE?
Fabieter
Member
Wasn't tri ace always independent?
MagiusNecros
Gilgamesh Fan Annoyance
More like 2nd party inside SE. SE never really gives them enough funding to make Star Ocean or Valkyrie Profile as great as they could be.
Jinzo Prime
Gold Member
Wikipedia has them listed as a subsidiary of Square Enix, so if Square as a whole is doing poorly, Tri Ace may suffer budget cuts and talent poaching.
Fabieter
Member
You are right strange as they did games for alot of different publishers.
demigod
Member
Of course leave it to arthands to make a thread about it.
adamsapple
Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
Tri-Ace isn't a Square Enix subsidiary. They just have a really strong publishing partnership with them. They're owned by a holdings company.
tri-Ace Inc.
Official homepage of tri-Ace Inc. Company information and career information for game designers, programmers, artists, and other positions have been posted.
LavitzSlambert
Member
Hopefully this doesn't affect FF7 Part 3 too much. They need to finish this strong, it's basically the reason they exist as they do today. Do players right with your big game and the rest will take care of itself.
MagiusNecros
Gilgamesh Fan Annoyance
I wouldn't expect much. They are going down the KH story path. I don't really find the story all that compelling in regards to OG FF7. And I don't think the combat system on it's own is gonna carry FF7 like they think it will.
ChuckeRearmed
Member
So basically what every normal person expected did happen. With stock being 15% we can say that SE is not doing great and FF also is not doing great 
- Status