• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

"We're the Only Plane in the Sky": Inside Air Force One on 9/11

Status
Not open for further replies.

Jintor

Member
Here's a super interesting read about what it was like around President Bush when the September 11 attacks took place, from a whole heap of oral interviews with the people around him at the time (though none with the man himself).

Sonya Ross, reporter, Associated Press: This was a garden variety trip. It was low-ranking staff and a lot of the top journalists didn’t come. It was a scrub trip.

Mike Morell, presidential briefer, Central Intelligence Agency: I walked into his suite [for the president’s morning intelligence briefing]; he was surrounded by breakfast foods and he hadn’t touched any of it. He asked me if I’d gone to the beach the night before, and I told him I’d just gone right to bed. The second intifada was well underway then, and the briefings at that time were very heavy on Israeli-Palestinian stuff. A good bit of the briefing that morning was about Israeli matters. There was one thing that caught his attention, and he picked up the phone to call Condi [Rice] to ask her to follow up on it. There was nothing in the briefing about terrorism. It was very routine—just him, me, Andy Card and Deb Loewer from the Situation Room.

Andy Card: The president was in a great mood. He had that George W. Bush strut that morning.

B. Alexander “Sandy” Kress, senior education adviser, White House: The whole point of the trip was education. He was pushing No Child Left Behind as Congress was coming back to Washington. [Secretary of Education] Rod Paige and I briefed him ahead of his remarks to the press. It was a beautiful day—we were in his suite. He was in a really good mood. We were out of the Oval and he was relaxed. Those were probably the last carefree moments he had in his term.

Andy Card: I remember literally telling him, “It should be an easy day.” Those were the words. “It should be an easy day.”

Staff Sgt. Paul Germain, airborne communications system operator, Air Force One: We thought it was weird even just when the first plane hit. People who know airplanes, that’s some real stuff right there. Big airplanes just don’t hit little buildings. Then, as soon as that second plane hit, that switchboard lit up like a Christmas tree.

Col. Mark Tillman: Everything started coming alive. We were hooked into the PEOC [the White House bunker] and the JOC [Joint Operations Center], for the Secret Service. They’re all in the link now.

Andy Card: Another plane hit the other Tower. My mind flashed to three initials: UBL. Usama bin Laden. Then I was thinking that we had White House people there—my deputy, Joe Hagin, and a team were in New York preparing for the U.N. General Assembly. I was thinking that Joe was probably at the World Trade Center, that’s where the Secret Service office was, in the basement.

Mike Morell: I was really worried that someone was going to fly a plane into that school. This event had been on schedule for weeks, anyone could have known about it. Eddie [Marinzel, the lead Secret Service agent] wanted to get the hell out of there as fast as possible.

Rep. Adam Putnam: There’s some debate within the staff that I can hear about how the president needs to address the nation. They’re saying, “We can’t do it here. You can’t do it in front of fifth-graders.” The Secret Service is saying, “You’re doing it here or you’re not doing at all. We’re not taking the time to do it somewhere else. We need to get him secure.”

Dave Wilkinson: We’re talking to folks back at the White House, we’re beginning to get the motorcade up and running, getting the motorcycle cops back, we’re ready to evacuate at a moment’s notice. All of a sudden it hits me: The president’s the only one who doesn’t know that this plane has hit the second building. It was a discomfort to all of us that the president didn’t know. The event was dragging on, and that’s when Andy Card came out.

Andy Card: A thousand times a day, a chief of staff has to ask “Does the president need to know?” This was an easy test to pass. As strange as it sounds, as I was standing there waiting to talk to the president, I was reflecting on another time that I’d had to be the calm one: I’d been acting chief of staff to President George H.W. Bush when he threw up on the Japanese prime minister. I was all business in that moment. He’d refused to get in the ambulance—he didn’t want anyone to see the president get in the ambulance—and in the limo, he’s still sick and he’s getting sick on me. In the hotel, I take out my laminated “in case of emergency” card. I went down my checklist. I was telling people, “He’s not dying, he’s still the president.” My job that day was to be calm, cool, and collected. Not the same magnitude, of course, but I knew my job on 9/11 was to be calm, cool, and collected.

Karl Rove: I remember [Andy Card] pausing at the door, before he went in, it seemed like forever, but it was probably just a couple heartbeats. I never understood why, but he told me, years later, that he needed to spend a moment formulating the words he wanted to use.

Andy Card: When I was standing at the classroom door, I knew I was delivering a message that no president would want to hear. I knew that my message would define the moment. I decided to pass on two facts and an editorial comment. I didn’t want to invite a conversation because the president was sitting in front of the classroom. I entered the room and Ann Compton, of ABC, in the press pool, gestured, “What’s up?” I gestured back to her, two planes crashing. She gestured “What?” Then the teacher asked the students to take out their books, so I took that opportunity to approach the president. I whispered in his ear, “A second plane hit the second Tower. America is under attack.” I took a couple steps back so he couldn’t ask any questions. The students were completely focused on their books. I remember thinking what a bizarre stage we’re standing on. I was pleased with how the president reacted—he didn’t do anything to create fear.

Ellen Eckert, stenographer, White House: There are six stenographers who work for the [White House] press office. One of us always travels with the president. I always said I typed fast for a living all over the world. [That morning] was uneventful until Andy walked in.

Ari Fleischer: For Andy to interrupt a presidential event, [we knew] it had to be of monumental consequence. You just didn’t do that.

Master Sgt. Dana Lark: Everything started lighting up. We saw Andy Card whisper in the president’s ear. We still didn’t know what the hell was going on. We’re just monitoring the Secret Service and staff radio channels. It was chaos. What’s next? All of a sudden, other reports start coming in—explosion at the White House, car bomb at the State Department. We’re under attack. I was 35 years old. My military career and my perspective is, I’m thinking Cold War, the big bad Soviet bear. This was an extensive attack. Could this be a nation-state?

Gordon Johndroe: Having been in that room—and it wasn’t an issue until the Michael Moore documentary [Fahrenheit 9/11]—it would have been odd if he’d jumped up and ran from the room. It didn’t seem like an eternity in the room. He finished the book and went back into the hold room.

Karl Rove: When the president walked back into the staff hold, he said, “We’re at war—give me the FBI director and the vice president.”

More at the link: http://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2016/09/were-the-only-plane-in-the-sky-214230

Fascinating stuff.
 

Media

Member
I kinda feel bad for W at times. I was no fan, but he seemed like a pretty happy go lucky president. Imagine having to get that message so soon into your term. Man.
 
I kinda feel bad for W at times. I was no fan, but he seemed like a pretty happy go lucky president. Imagine having to get that message so soon into your term. Man.

I think everyone believed he would be one of those presidents that wouldnt have to deal with something so monumental. I mean having a challenge in your presidency is expected, but surely nothing of this magnitude.

Really interesting read.
 
Read this a couple of days ago and thought it was fucking fascinating. Took me back at certain parts.

Almost posted a thread myself but it would have taken me an hour to find all my favorite quotes ;p
 

Nephtis

Member
To this day I still don't blame W too much for all that went on as far as the shitshow that ensued is concerned.

Rove and Cheney on the other hand...
 

MIMIC

Banned
This part was really fascinating to read. I mean, you know he's trying to figure out just the right words to say, but it's still interesting to hear (second hand) his thought process

Karl Rove: I remember [Andy Card] pausing at the door, before he went in, it seemed like forever, but it was probably just a couple heartbeats. I never understood why, but he told me, years later, that he needed to spend a moment formulating the words he wanted to use
 

Dalibor68

Banned
Just watched the 9/11 Bush Interview documentary and yeah it's crazy to see it from that perspective. Even if any of those 9/11 inside job conspiracies were true I don't think Bush wouldve known.
 
I kinda feel bad for W at times. I was no fan, but he seemed like a pretty happy go lucky president. Imagine having to get that message so soon into your term. Man.

maybe if he wasn't so happy go lucky his administration could've prevented the attacks.
 
To this day I still don't blame W too much for all that went on as far as the shitshow that ensued is concerned.

Rove and Cheney on the other hand...

he still listened to those vile men.. he's as bad as them. empty soulless psychopaths can pretend to be charming and relatable, they can fool us.
 

jacksnap

Neo Member
Good article. It's easy to forget how caught unawares everyone was about who the perpetrators could have been.

Funny bit about Putin, though. Truly mind boggling that the man has been in power for so long, while Americans are on the verge of 4 presidential terms.
 
What a great read.

Must have been so bizarre to be there expecting more cities to be attacked, AF1 to be shot down, biological weapons to be used.

It's sad reading it knowing the response to the day was so poorly planned and messy though. By those accounts, at least, everyone acted very smart on the day itself.
 
9/11 is a truly fascinating moment in history. It's probably one of the biggest moments in history that has been so very well documented, it's not hard at all to get a feel on what the country was feeling exactly as it happened. I can't think of any other moment in history that was so well documented.
 

zsynqx

Member
Really interesting read so far. Just got to this bit, made me chuckle.

Putin was fantastic that day. He was a different Vladimir Putin in 2001. America could have had no better ally on September 11th than Russia and Putin.
 
Really interesting read so far. Just got to this bit, made me chuckle.

Putin was genuine in a desire to oppose Islamic terrorism. Not necessarily for selfless ends, but there was cooperation on the transfer of Russian intelligence and files from the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan, from what I recall.
 

Polari

Member
Putin was genuine in a desire to oppose Islamic terrorism. Not necessarily for selfless ends, but there was cooperation on the transfer of Russian intelligence and files from the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan, from what I recall.

Also pulled out all the stops to try and prevent the Iraq War.
 

Admodieus

Member
I kinda feel bad for W at times. I was no fan, but he seemed like a pretty happy go lucky president. Imagine having to get that message so soon into your term. Man.

I have no problem with W as a person. Years back I caught a Rangers game where he was in the booth for part of it and really enjoyed listening to him.

I really wonder how some of us would feel about his presidency if the administration didn't decide to go into Iraq.
 
Bill Clinton warned them bin Laden was determined to attack us. We know how seriously they took his warning.
Bill Clintons presidency and his failed foreign policy on terrorism allowed them to plan and execute with impunity. If Clinton was so sure he should have done something about it.
 
Air Force 1 just seems to be such a futuristic thing to me. This massive 747 designed to look like an apartment suite with offices, high-grade tech, and everything else. Flying for hours and hours while walking throughout this massive plane as it becomes the most secure place in the world. Kind of blows my mind.
 
Bill Clintons presidency and his failed foreign policy on terrorism allowed them to plan and execute with impunity. If Clinton was so sure he should have done something about it.
Pretty sure Clinton did make moves to go after him. But he was often criticized for getting too involved in Middle East affairs....
 

Blablurn

Member
the part about putin is interesting

Gordon Johndroe: [Putin] was important—all these military systems were all put in place for nuclear alerts. If we went on alert, we needed Putin to know that we weren’t readying an attack on Russia. He was great—he said immediately that Russia wouldn’t respond, Russia would stand down, that he understood we were under attack and needed to be on alert.

Ari Fleischer: Putin was fantastic that day. He was a different Vladimir Putin in 2001. America could have had no better ally on September 11th than Russia and Putin.

Read more: http://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2016/09/were-the-only-plane-in-the-sky-214230#ixzz4K8ha8UVt
Follow us: @politico on Twitter | Politico on Facebook
 

Blader

Member
Bill Clintons presidency and his failed foreign policy on terrorism allowed them to plan and execute with impunity. If Clinton was so sure he should have done something about it.

He did. But even if he hadn't, that doesn't change the dozens of intelligence reports Bush received over an eight-month period, warning of an escalating threat by bin Laden, that Bush did absolutely nothing about. Bush was the president during 9/11, not Clinton. It happened on his watch and was his failure.
 

AxelFoley

Member
Pretty sure Clinton did make moves to go after him. But he was often criticized for getting too involved in Middle East affairs....

He did. But even if he hadn't, that doesn't change the dozens of intelligence reports Bush received over an eight-month period, warning of an escalating threat by bin Laden, that Bush did absolutely nothing about. Bush was the president during 9/11, not Clinton. It happened on his watch and was his failure.

Exactly. Amazing how some GOPers/Clinton haters tried to blame Bill for Bush's failure on 9/11.
 

kittoo

Cretinously credulous
Can anyone recommend a good 911 documentary? I dont want the conspiracy theory docs about how it was an inside job or some shit, nor do I want ones focusing on Iraq war. I just want one on what happened that day and how the administration and people reacted over the coming days.
 

sikkinixx

Member
The thing that makes me feel so old is looking at the pictures, and how grainy and shitty they are compared to modern cameras.
 

daveo42

Banned
Man...this story takes me back to that day. Remembering all the events of the day and how much the world seemed to change in a matter of just a few minutes. Truly facinating and heartbreaking all at the same time.

Thanks for sharing OP.
 
a fantastic piece, great read - thanks for sharing OP... really takes you into the lives of the ordinary people trapped in the mother of all panic room situations.
 
RH3zCbt.jpg


That expression.
Beyond just forgetting how young G.W. looked in 2001, I can't even imagine how he felt getting that news. Despite my personal feelings for him, he handled that moment remarkably well.
 
I've never been a fan of Michael Moore, even though many of my views mirror his, and his attack on Bush's immediate response to the news still angers me. I think W was a terrible president but he handled the school situation perfectly. There's literally no one else alive right now who has dealt with a situation like that. Being the most powerful man in the world and weighing the path you're about to take, the lives that will be lost due to your decision. He had the weight of the country and world on his shoulders as he sat and calmly read along with children. It's a stunning, historic moment.

It's easy to forget how well the situation was initially handled. From Bush's speech at Ground Zero to him visiting a mosque and declaring that the US was not at war with Islam, most Muslims are peaceful, etc. What a god damn shame he squandered all that good will with the war in Iraq. Imagine how different the US and Iraq would look if we had simply attacked Afghanistan/gone after AQ. The lives that would have been saved, the trillion dollars that would have been saved, etc.
 

Makonero

Member
Ari Fleischer: As we were flying out of Sarasota, we were able to get some TV reception. They broke for commercial. I couldn’t believe it. A hair-loss commercial comes on. I remember thinking, in the middle of all this, I’m watching this commercial for hair loss.

This is a fascinating article.
 
holy crap, great read in the op. gonna check it out when i get back home. a few months ago i was watching some documentary on netflix about this and the air force one
 
Going to check this out, thank you OP.

Amazing that it's been 15 years. I was 21 at the time, and on the West Coast. When I woke up and went downstairs to shower my Dad was watching the news (he was a firefighter) it looked like a fire at a high rise. I said "that sucks" and took a shower. When I got out, the tower had collapsed and the other was getting close.

I worked at Blockbuster Video in Malibu, and drove in to work and there wasn't anyone on the road, the police had cars parked at every intersection. It was surreal.

All day long, the rich and famous kept coming into Blockbuster to rent something for their kids since all the channels were covering the news. We had a DirecTV kiosk and had it tuned to the news. EVERYONE had an "inside scoop" about what was really going on. Flight 93 was downed by F-16's, said one lady, "I know someone who knows the truth".

I think I watched the news all day long. After work, I had a date scheduled with a girl, we were supposed to meet at Starbucks, but Starbucks ended up being closed due to the attack (go figure). We went back to her place and just sat watching the news until late in the night.

It wasn't until some time later that I realized I'd been on Flight 93 two weeks prior, in August 2001, when I came back from a family vacation in New Hampshire.

Sigh.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom