I didn't like Chutes Too Narrow all that much the first time I listened to it, but I got a free ticket and saw them live. The live show sold me on 'em. They're great. My friend went and saw them a few weeks back, with fucking Calexico opening (and he informed me that "Calexico was the best live band I've ever seen, bar none"). I'm bummed I missed that show. But it seems like they tour constantly, so I'm sure I'll get to see them again. "Turn a Square" is about the best song ever.
MAF: You should check out Dressy Bessy, I could see you absolutely loving them. It's 60s-esque power pop with awesome fuzzy guitars, and great songwriting. As a plus? Their singer, Tammy Ealom, is gorgeous and a great singer. I think they'd be right up your alley. I'm not sure where you could check out any tracks online, but I'm almost guaranteeing you'd dig it, they're fantastic.