Well, just beat the game. a little over 60 hours on that character from start to finish. What a fantastic game!
I'm already making plans for my 2nd run with a DEX/Pyromancy character. My first run was pure sorcerer. I messed up a late game quest to get all the spells for the trophy, which kinda sucks, but I'll definitely be doing a new game + on my sorc, so not all is lost.
Overall, I feel this game had better quality consistently throughout, however there was little to no guidance on exactly where you should be going. Even Dark Souls 1's minimalist approach looks very helpful by comparison. At the end of the day though, there was not a single level i would dread going back to like old Lost Izalith.