I have some issues, but it's just too damn good even with those issues, nevermind that the lighting issue itself was likely just a (poor) fix to bad reception for the game being dark in the beta as it was hilariously easy to fall down a pit in that, though the torch mechanic wasn't clearly outlined in the beta either. If it weren't for Dark Souls late game design fumbles I'd argue it was the most flawed of the three, but as is it's more that it has a few boneheaded parts but only a few parts are as egregious, and some of those are optional anyway. So at worst the same level as Dark Souls 1, and with Demon's Souls perhaps ahead of both (though there IS World Tendency...)