• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

The Order 1886 | Impressions Thread of not shooting the messenger.

How dare they ship this without a dedicated photomode?

10989184_940087442691240_2315317197596703905_o.jpg


1618135_940087382691246_4694936728530035418_o.jpg


10974153_940087292691255_7758827530544535333_o.jpg


10986861_940087259357925_2880487467738671945_o.jpg


10856580_940087196024598_5338004916942062694_o.jpg


1397029_940087136024604_4464712652025028172_o.jpg


10925513_940099036023414_4565584376997112220_o.jpg


1491364_940098986023419_737692287022712618_o.jpg


10996640_940098856023432_6101751293177547956_o.jpg
 
I find it sad that in a time when so many games are getting released as broken games, bad dlc practices, and micro transactions; a solid game that seems to do everything right in that regard gets so much shit just for not being long enough, not even bad, just not long enough.
 
I have the amazon cart ready to go

Just... somebody tell me this

Did they manage to insert Werewolves of London at any point? Over the end credits, or possibly a piano player at the brothel?

This is very important.
 
Just finished it.

The story kicks into high gear at around chapter 10. Some great stuff from there on out.

Soundtrack is incredible.

Was a wild, fun ride. If the game was just a bit more open in terms of the encounter design and exploration fronts, it'd be so much better and probably get 9+ in reviews. There's very little experimentation for the encounters which sucked.

But still, it was a great ride.
 
I have the amazon cart ready to go

Just... somebody tell me this

Did they manage to insert Werewolves of London at any point? Over the end credits, or possibly a piano player at the brothel?

This is very important.

I saw a werewolf drinking a pina colada at Trader Vic's;
And his hair was perfect
 
Sony PR in your country must rock, cause Sony of america didn't even send my site a review copy and our scores are posted on metacritic. Go figure. lol

They are indeed very awesome. They were actually the first ones who gave me support for my blog. The other companies were harder to gain support from, but I got support from most of them in the end.

Reviewing games for my blog and making YT videos are just a part of my hobby, something I do in the spare time, so no job there.
 
I find it sad that in a time when so many games are getting released as broken games, bad dlc practices, and micro transactions; a solid game that seems to do everything right in that regard gets so much shit just for not being long enough, not even bad, just not long enough.


Do we know if it is truelly a solid game yet? Some seem to think so. You are right. At least it works from beginning to end. I suppose that should be applauded in 2015
 
can we get all the people insisting and insisting and insisting the 5hr youtube walkthrough is going to represent the typical experience, back in here to write 100 lines of apology?
 
I'm in the progress of writing my review and I'd like to share a small opinion of mine. Feel free to disagree. Trying my best to not break embargo here, so don't expect too much details.

Anyway, I have an issue with "buyer guide" reviews. That is: reviews telling you if the game is worth your money and not whether the game is good or bad. This is a personal thing for sure. I mean... gaming isn't free. Not everyone has the privilege to buy several $60 games every month. So I understand it's important for some people to know the value of a game next to its quality. As a reviewer, I am privileged to try out games for free. So it's easier for me to judge a game on its quality and not its value/$.

That said, I don't like the comparisons people make when we talk about value. Game length is a hot topic right now regarding The Order 1886 and that makes me sad. Kinda. People keep comparing the game to other games. They're not wondering if the length is right for this game. They're wondering why it is shorter than other games. It's unacceptable etc. But that's not the question we should ask. The question should be: does the length work for this game? I'm not gonna answer this question because I can't... not yet... but it's something to think about.

If I buy a really good book for $15 which is somewhat short and then another book which is equally good but ten times longer, I won't be disappointed. They're the same price but they're both good in a different way. I don't view length as something that is so important to the experience. I'd rather read, watch or play something that is really tight yet short compared to a bloated mess that takes forever.

The Wolf of Wall Street is a personal favourite of mine and it's about three hours long. Do I like it more than other movies because of its length? No. In fact, some people think it's way too long. It's the same price as any other movie, but compared to games, it doesn't seem to be as important. Now, I know this is not a 100% fair comparison. A game is $60. Movies and books are way cheaper and less of an investment. It's easier to just focus on the quality here.

But the price doesn't influence the quality of a game, only its "value". Would The Order 1886 suddenly become better if it was $30? No. It would become an easier buy, I agree. But the game quality will not change. Nothing will change. Only your perception. So many people want game to be "art", but it seems there is still a big business side to things that people have issues with. Again, in my opinion people aren't criticizing the game length because they're wondering if it'll work for The Order 1886, but because other games are longer and more deserving of their money. Despite not having played the game. They're only going off a number.

Now, keep in mind everything I wrote here is about the game length. I did not say anything about the gameplay. Don't take this text of mine as proof I think the game is incredible or anything. I'm just saying I disagree with the length drama. Feel free to disagree with me, as this is but an opinion piece of mine.
 
I feel like this is going to end up being 2015' Wolfenstein: The New Order in terms of how consumers and professional critics praise the game, being that the both sides will see the game vastly different from one another.
 
I feel like this is going to end up being 2015' Wolfenstein: The New Order in terms of how consumers and professional critics praise the game, being that the both sides will see the game vastly different from one another.

Didn't both sides like Wolfenstein though? I agree its metacritic score deserver a higher number but I have a feeling this game will have more extreme opinions.
 
I find it sad that in a time when so many games are getting released as broken games, bad dlc practices, and micro transactions; a solid game that seems to do everything right in that regard gets so much shit just for not being long enough, not even bad, just not long enough.

image.php


Your loaf of bread would of been alot longer too had that "The Order mustache" not come along. Coincidence ?
 
Only managed to get to my first firefight before having to leave, so far so good. The game looks beautiful. I'll play tonight once the kiddies are asleep, that type of game deserves my full attention.
 
My card still hasn't been charged and my Premium Edition still hasn't shipped. Should I be worried? I'm getting flashbacks to the Destiny Ghost Edition fiasco...
 
My card still hasn't been charged and my Premium Edition still hasn't shipped. Should I be worried? I'm getting flashbacks to the Destiny Ghost Edition fiasco...

Where did you order from? I ordered off Amazon and my game just shipped like 10 mins ago.

I think it's too soon to start worrying, as long as it goes out before tomorrow morning you are probably OK
 
Was considering this game, but just wanted to know if its worth getting, if it is I will order it right now from amazon since I have a 30 dollar credit available, will get that game plus Kirby and the rainbow curse
 
I've been stuck in a courtyard for an hour or more (thank god for quick restarts) because I'm so shit at this - I am a little tired though- so I guess I'm going to be taking about 30 hours to finish this one by the time I've gawped and died and gawped and died...

Was considering this game, but just wanted to know if its worth getting, if it is I will order it right now from amazon since I have a 30 dollar credit available, will get that game plus Kirby and the rainbow curse

It's worth getting if you like linear, single player games with a good story, loud guns and beautiful graphics (and I'm loving it so far, and I doubt that opinion will change, unless it does something incredibly stupid before the end) but the bigger question is whether you think it's worth paying full price for, just to get in on the early action.
 
Top Bottom