• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

List your top 5 systems and their DEFINITIVE game~

m00 said:
The Wii Sports of Atari's Video Computer System. Combat.
Click to expand...

Thanks, m00. That "Pac-Man" in the OP made a vein in my head pop. Pac-Man, if anything, defined the downfall of the 2600 when it disappointed millions of buyers.

On a side note: why in the hell hasn't what's left of Atari made Wii Combat yet? Nintendo even made a demo for them and packed it with a remote for best exposure.


JodyAnthony: nice first reply. I like what you did there. Some systems have defining games that really can't be disputed, like the NES with Super Mario Bros. or the Xbox with Halo, but who wants to state the obvious as their pick. Good compromise.
 
Hive said:
What I mean by "definitive," I suppose, is a significant game release that propelled the brand, and ultimately, defined and shaped how we remember our favorite systems today~
Click to expand...

1. Saturn - Sega Rally Championship (proved that the system was capable of competitive 3D, and is still highly playable today).

2. NES - Rush'n Attack (along w/ Space Invaders on the 2600, the first game I can remember where I thought the console port was better than the arcade original).

3. Sega Master System - Phantasy Star (set the standard for console RPGs for me; I cite this game quite often as my favorite on the system).

4. SNES - Street Fighter II (a system seller and a damn good port of one of the most popular games of all-time).

5. PlayStation - Gran Turismo (pretty much changed the face of console racing games in a single stroke; it's still the one I've played the most).
 
PC: Marathon 2: Durandal
Xbox 360: Halo 3
Xbox: Halo 2
PSone: Winning Elven 2000
Super Nes: Metal Warriors
 
I'm heading off to work and will take time to think about this and respond later, but in threads like this, I'd love to see the "read the OP" rule used and people get slaps on the wrist for posting laundry lists of every system they've ever played. Nice thread concept and a lot of good replies, though.
 
System - My Choice | Defines

DS - Pokémon Diamond/Pearl/Platinum | New Super Mario Bros.
Wii - Super Mario Galaxy | Wii Sports
GC - Super Smash Bros. Melee | Super Smash Bros. Melee
Dreamcast - Power Stone | Sonic Adventure
Genesis - Sonic 3 & Knuckles | Sonic 2
 
top 5 and my definitive game? fuck.

genesis - phantasy star iv.
n64 - goldeneye
dreamcast - pso
ps2 - mgs3 or shadow of the colossus
ps3 - mgs4 or uncharted (so far)
 
1) snes - super mario world
2) DS - phoenix wright: ace attorney
3) NES - super mario bros
4) PSX - parappa the rapper
5) n64 - mario 64
 
PC = Doom or Quake
N64 = Goldeneye
360 = Halo 3
SNES = Street Fighter II or Super Mario World
DC...dear lord, the choices!...um = PSO or Shenmue

****

Stuff that would not fit in. :lol

GC = F-Zero GX
Saturn = Daytona or Panzer Dragoon
PS2 = Shadow of the Colossus
PS3 = MGS4
 
Leondexter said:
Pac-Man, if anything, defined the downfall of the 2600 when it disappointed millions of buyers.
Click to expand...
Disappointing, yes, but the 2600 was far from a downfall at that point. Quality games from Activision, Imagic, Exidy, etc. had yet to appear. The glut of crap games that came in the mid-'80s (that you could buy at your local toy store for $1.99 brand new) is when things just came crashing down for everyone. And then along came the Nintendo "Seal of Approval".
 
PsOne - FFVII
N64 - Perfect Dark
Ps2 - Metal Gear Solid 2
Ps3 - Little Big Planet
Xbox - Rainbow Six 3
 
1. SNES - Donkey Kong Country (Super Mario World)
2. NES - Super Mario Bros. (Super Mario Bros. 3)
3. 360 - Gears of War
4. N64 - Mario 64 (Goldeneye 007)
5. PS2 - MGS2 (God of War)
 
1. NES - Super Mario Bros. 3
2. SNES - Zelda: ALTTP
3. N64 - Zelda: Ocarina of Time
4. NGC - Metroid Prime
5. PS 2 (slim) - God of War II
 
ghibli99 said:
Disappointing, yes, but the 2600 was far from a downfall at that point. Quality games from Activision, Imagic, Exidy, etc. had yet to appear. The glut of crap games that came in the mid-'80s (that you could buy at your local toy store for $1.99 brand new) is when things just came crashing down for everyone. And then along came the Nintendo "Seal of Approval".
Click to expand...

I know, you're right. I wasn't trying to say Pac-Man killed the 2600, I was saying that Pac-Man kind of set the model for the crappy cash-in game.
 
1.- Xbox - Halo 2

2.- Nintendo Wii - Super Mario Galaxy

3.- Super NES - Super Mario World

4.- NDS - New Super Mario Bros

5.- Playstation 2 - Final Fantasy X



What can I say, Miyamoto always delivers for me...
 
DS - Defined by Brain Trainning. Personal favourite: Ouendan.
PS2 - Defined by Devil May Cry and Metal Gear Solid 2. Personal favourite: Persona 3.
PS1 - Defined by Final Fantasy VII. Personal favourite: Final Fantasy VII as well.
Super Nes - Defined by Street Fighter II. Personal favourite: Super Mario World.
PC - Defined by: Doom, Civilization, World of Warcraft (I know, only one, but we are talking about a platafform whose life spans trought decades). Personal favourite: Civilization, MDK.
 
NES - the legend of zelda
SNES - super metroid
GBA - wario ware: mega microgames
DREAMCAST - toy commander
GAMECUBE - metroid prime
 
Listing definitive games for me, not necessarily overall.

First and second places on this list are really easy to be certain of, but after that it gets much, much tougher... I'm not sure if I can choose 5, much less order them. :(

1. PC - Starcraft
2. Nintendo 64 - Super Mario 64 (Ocarina of Time a close second, but Mario 64 is the definitive title.)
3. Game Boy (B&W) - The Legend of Zelda: Link's Awakening (or perhaps Super Mario Land)
4. NES - Super Mario Bros.
5. Genesis - Sonic the Hedgehog

Top honorable mentions:

6. Gamecube - Star Wars: Rogue Squadron II: Rogue Leader (or perhaps Metroid Prime)
7. Dreamcast - Sonic Adventure (or perhaps Skies of Arcadia)

... That's tough, all of those and more deserve to be on the list...and I'm not certain that #s 4 and 5 really deserve to be ahead of #s 6 and 7. It's so hard to decide, they're all such great platforms, but so different that direct comparisons are quite difficult... and does the Genesis really deserve to be there if the SNES isn't? I generally think of them as about equal in overall quality... hmm... I'll leave it as it is because that's how I wrote it, but this isn't my definitive all-time list or something, that'd take more thought.

As I said though, I am at least quite sure of the top two spots. :)
 
Let's see...(not in order)
System defining game (my defining game)

1. N64 Goldeneye (Perfect Dark) - I would say Perfect dark overall, but no one implemented its innovations like bots very much.

2. NES Super Mario Bros. 3 (Tecmo Super Bowl) - Tecmo Super Bowl is the only football game I like. I can't really think of any other NES game I can say that for.

3. GCN Pikmin/2 (really the original) (Melee) - Weird choice, I know, but there isn't really a good one. I chose Pikmin because it represented the playfulness of the Gamecube and its neat style.

4. DS Nintendogs (Yoshi's Touch & Go) - ridiculous personal choice, but it was the first game that made me realize that touch controls can work really well and improve games. Phoenix Wright deserves a shout-out too.

5 - GBA Golden Sun (Fire Emblem) - Pokemon Ruby wasn't as popular, and I can't think of any one game that was far above all the rest. there were no Marios or Zeldas or anything besides ports. Golden Sun was at least big with me and my friends.

The Wii or 360 are too new for me to tell. I haven't played enough PS2 games for it to be my favorite, even if I love Persona 3 FES.
 
DC - Skies of Arcadia (Online DLC and VMU capabilities)
SNES - Super Mario World (Branching paths, special stages, and the inverted mode)
PS1 - Final Fantasy VII (Full 3D world to explore and a lengthy experience)
PS2 - Final Fantasy XII (Massive world with loads of content and detail)
X360 - Crackdown (One of the greatest open world games ever. Large environment to explore and so many options to choose from)
 
SNES | Personal Favorite: Chrono Trigger | Definitive Title: Super Mario World
N64 | Personal Favorite: Super Mario 64 | Definitive Title: The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time
GBA | Personal Favorite: Golden Sun | Definitive Title: Advance Wars
PlayStation | Personal Favorite: Chrono Cross | Definitive Title: Final Fantasy VII
Dreamcast | Personal Favorite: Phantasy Star Online | Definitive Title: Soul Calibur

Yes, I realize Chrono Cross pales in comparison to Chrono Trigger. No, I don't care because I enjoyed the game a ton...until that last bit.
 
Without a doubt:
PS2 - Final Fantasy XII
SNES - Chrono Trigger
Sega Master System - Zillion
N64 - Mario 64

Iffy:
NES - Duck Tales
 
Here are my top 5 systems along with the game that defined the system for me (no current gen).

Playstation - Final Fantasy Tactics
Playstation 2 - Metal Gear Solid 2 or Final Fantasy X (bought the system for both)
SNES - Chrono Trigger
Genesis - Sonic 2
NES - Super Mario 3


Next 5 (no current gen):

Dreamcast: Soul Calibur
Saturn: Dragon Force
Gamecube: Pikmin
GBA: Fire Emblem
GB/GBC: Pokemon Blue/Red
 
everyone has a different response with it being "my" game or the "systems" game so...

I guess I will roll with "my"?

1.SNES-Super Mario World
2.Playstation 1-Final Fantasy 7
3.Xbox-Rainbow Six 3(the true star of XBOX Live in the beginning)
4.360-Gears 1
5.PC-Doom 1
 
DS - Pokemon Diamond
Ps2 - Too many
Psp - Monster Hunter Freedom / twisted metal head on
360 - Gears of war
ps3 - I feel Like I forgot.. Best game I can remember is uncharted, or rfom.
Snes - sf2/super mario world
GBA - Megaman Zero 3
GC - Metroid prime
GB - pokemon red
pc - M.u.g.e.n
Dreamcast - vigilante 8 second offense
ps1 - FF7
 
Snes - Chrono Trigger
Genesis - Streets of Rage 2
DS - Picross ds
Nes - Mega man 2
Playstation - Resident Evil 2
 
NES - Mario Bros 3
SNES - Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past
PS1 - Metal Gear Solid
N64 - Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time
Dreamcast - Shenmue
PS2 - Gran Turismo 3
DS - New Super Mario Bros
PSP - LocoRoco
Gamecube - Legend of Zelda: Wind Waker/Super Mario Sunshine
Xbox - Halo 2
Xbox 360 - Halo 3
Wii - Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess/Super Mario Galaxy

edit: totally forgot about shenmue lol
 
Wii - Super Mario Galaxy (or Wii Sports)

PS3 - Metal Gear Solid 4

360 - Halo 3

GameCube - Super Smash Bros. Melee

Xbox - Halo 1/2

PS2 - Grand Theft Auto III

Dreamcast - Sonic Adventure (or Shenmue)

N64 - Ocarina of Time (or SM64)

PS1 - Final Fantasy VII (or MGS)

Genesis - any Sonic game

SNES - Super Mario World

NES - Super Mario Bros.
 
Top five systems in no particular order:

SNES
Chrono Trigger

NES
Super Mario Bros. 3

Sega Genesis
Sonic 2

Playstation
Metal Gear Solid

Playstation 2
Silent Hill 2
 
In order i got them;
Megadrive: Golden Axe
PS1: Final Fantasy VII (Seriously nothing comes close)
GBA: Pokemon Red/Blue/Yellow
Dreamcast: Shenmue
PS2: Final Fantasy X (This one is difficult, PS2 excelled in so many genres, so i could choose more than one here)
Xbox: Halo
PSP: I don't think there is one yet
PS3: I don't think there is one yet, but the closest would be Metal Gear Solid 4
Xbox360: I don't like it myself, but probably Gears Of War
 
5. TurboGrafx 16 - Bonk
4. Xbox - PGR
3. PS2 - Ratchet & Clank
2. GameCube - Zelda (including the collector discs)
1. PC - Way too many to list, best game system evah bar none. :D
 
1.PS3- Metal Gear Solid 4
2.PS2- Metal Gear Solid 3
3.Gameboy Color- Pokemon Yellow
4.PS1- Crash Team Racing
5.SNES- Zelda: Link to The Past
 
PS3 MGS4
Uncharted
GBCPokemon Silver/Gold
I had other systems(PS1, PS2, Wii, all Nintendo Handhelds), I just never played any of the "definitive" games for them.
 
in order:

1. Wii
Super Mario Galaxy

It's hard for me to not list Wii as first. It has VC, tons of great retail software, plenty of great DLC, and when I think about the system that I've had the most flat out fun with, Wii takes it hands down. To top it off it has IMHO the best entry in one of gaming's biggest, best and most historic franchises.

2. SNES
Chrono Trigger
SNES if you take out VC, Wiiware, and the fact that today's consoles are just superior to the ones of old, SNES wins hands down. Best library, still many unparalleled worlds, and playing Chrono Trigger for the first time to me was when I saw exactly how cinematic video games could be, a full 2 years before FFVII hit the scene.

4. Dreamcast
PSO/Shenmue
The Dreamcast was obviously the start of the next-generation despite what Sony would have you believe. One of the greatest software launch lineups to this day, a measurable leap in graphics over the previous gen, and features and overall functionality that wasn't matched until a full generation later. Four controller ports. Free online out of the box (XBX was not online until a year later and it still wasn't free out of the box thanks to Live). Voice enabled games. DLC. To this day it still stuns me how far ahead of its time the system was. But enough about that. The two games, yes two games, I was forced to pick are legends in this hobby. The first and still possibly best online console game, and arguably the first and definitely still one of the best sandbox games. PSO and Shenmue showed the world EXACTLY what the next-gen looked like, and behold it was VERY good.

4. Genesis
Revenge of Shinobi
Genesis was definitely not a "loser" in the 16-bit era. It had the superior versions of many games, usually had a faster feel to the games, and in the age of NES and SMS it was really the first time in my video gaming history (1979) that I felt as if the arcade truly came home. I picked Revenge of Shinobi because to this day, it was really the first time every that I felt like I was playing an arcade game at home (I hated altered beast and hang-on and space harrier II were just prettier versions of what we already had).

5. PSX
Final Fantasy VII
I almost feel guilty picking this. The system never really gripped me. I never held strong nostalgia for any single game on the system, except FFVII. I would be an absolute liar to say the first time I played FFVII that I wasn't blown away. I would be a liar to say that I didn't waste the first 14 days of owning it to the tune of 75+ hours beating every last nook and cranny of the game. I teared up when Aeris died, I stood in awe of the cutscenes, I rofl'ed at Barrett's dialogue, and I was stunned at the visuals (And length) of the final fight. The PSX as a system was decent and I had my fun with it, but it sits in my top five solely because FFVII will always stand out as one of the defining moments (for better or worse) of my gaming hobby.

Runner-Up
GBC
Pokemon Red
I see other people listed handhelds but I don't really consider them consoles. Still, I would be remiss to not include the GBC, or more appropriately Pokemon Red which accounted for around 130 hours of my life back in 1998. IT was my first real venture into handheld gaming (excusing very brief stints with GBs, a Lynx, and borrowing some Game Gears). Needless to say after having my GBC and wormlight glued to my hand for the better part of a month, I never disrespected the power of handheld gaming again.

edit - oh shit.. we're talking systems, not consoles? Well fuck, in that case my DS is the greatest system of all time. Best library ever, some of the best games ever, and it possibly changed the landscape of gaming more than any other system ever save for maybe the Wii. Defining game? Nintendogs. Anyone who says otherwise is a liar. Nintendogs single-handedly turned the DS from a neat system with a bit of potential into the fastest selling video game system of all time. DS sold 2 million units in one month, and it never would have done that without Nintendogs in 2005.
 
1. PS2 - Metal Gear Solid 2

2. Sega Genesis - Streets of Rage 2

3. PSOne - Crash Bandicoot

4. NES - Super Mario Bros

5. Gameboy Color - Pokemon Series
 
1. Amiga - Speedball 2
2. PC (windows based) - Quake 2
3. Spectrum 48k - Back to skool
4. Wii - RE4:Wii edition
5. Playstation 1 - Soul Blade
 
X360 - Halo 3
SNES - Super Mario World
N64 - Mario 64
PS3 - Little Big Planet
Wii - Wii Sports


I'm not sure if that is how I would rank the consoles but those are the games that defined them for me.
 
Assuming we're only taking into account games which were originally released on that system and not backwards compatibility and official emulation:

1. SNES/SFC - Chrono Trigger. Honestly, this was the hardest choice for me. The SNES is littered with amazing games that redefined genres and markets, but in the end, CT is the crown jewel for a console that will forever be remembered as the home to quite possibly the best RPG lineup ever.

2. PlayStation - Final Fantasy VII. I may not think the world of FFVII the game, but I'm fully aware of the impact that it had on the RPG genre.

3. NES/FC - Super Mario Bros. 3. The first Mario game saved the industry, the third perfected a genre. There is no more important franchise in gaming history (Pong isn't a franchise!), and there is no better Mario game than SMB3.

4. PlayStation 2 - Grand Theft Auto 3. I don't like the GTA games. The 2D ones suffered from completely horrendous controls, while the 3D ones I never got into because I'm one of those who happens to *not* like completely open-world games. That said, GTA3 is a landmark achievement in gaming, both in game design and in bringing 'adult' games into the mainstream.

5. Dreamcast - Soul Calibur. It was hard to imagine that there could be a system better than the Saturn for fighting game fans, but Sega managed just that. And Soul Calibur was the first and foremost among them.

And finally, I have to note that while I love PC gaming, and it will always be a part of me, I simply can't find a way to properly evaluate the PC as a gaming platform in the same way I do a console. So it'll just have to be left off.
 
This is a difficult one for me. Let's see here.

1. NES - The Legend of Zelda (hon. mention: Ninja Gaiden, Castlevania)
2. Gamecube - Metroid Prime (hon. mention: Monkey Ball 1, Mario Sunshine)
3. Genesis - Ecco the Dolphin (hon. mention: Streets of Rage 2, Sonic 2, Shining Force)
4. PSOne - Final Fantasy VII (hon. mention: Persona 2, Resident Evil)
5. Nintendo 64 - Zelda: OoT (hon. mention: Quest 64 (don't judge me), Starfox 64)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Rank your top 5 best and hardest roguelike games
35
2K
drotahorror replied
Predict what your top 5 games of 2026 will be and we'll see how accurately it turned out a year from now
2
91
867
Mownoc replied
Weekend GAF: What's Your Top Gaming Surprise and Disappointment of 2025?
2
58
617
TerribleAtThisGame replied
Your Top 5 PSOne JRPG's
2
83
3K
Plies replied
What is your 3 top games of last Gen and this Gen?
2
62
808
Putonahappyface replied
Top Bottom