brokenbeans
Banned
Maybe we play more that protagonist?
mafia is still the prominent theme of the game. this seems like a fresh change of pace.Every Mafia game? Yes.
And if you have new ideas dump it in a new IP.
"Mafia" has a broader definition than "Italian Mafia". The series is progressing from a specific Mafia to mafias in general.Every Mafia game? Yes.
And if you have new ideas dump it in a new IP.
Every Mafia game? Yes.
And if you have new ideas dump it in a new IP.
A gluttony? I can count them on one hand, good ones with one finger.
Yeah, but that's so cliche. The guy who starts with good intentions and is cautious and conflicted about letting go of his humanity, eventually becomes ruthless and more comfortable with violence as he becomes more poweful? That's been done so many times
That line of thinking will cause the series to become stagnant. Surely you see this?Every Mafia game? Yes.
And if you have new ideas dump it in a new IP.
Where those gameplay pics and gif in the OP taken from? The trailer didn't show any gameplay and was all CGI.
Was Playboy mentioned in any of the videos?
Every Mafia game? Yes.
And if you have new ideas dump it in a new IP.
I'm not sure I understand what you're saying. The main protagonist is definitely a black guy (as seen in gameplay footage) and according to the cinematic trailer, apparently the Italian Mafia murdered his family and he's on a quest for revenge now to take down the Italian Mafia. I'm pretty sure I'm as close as can be.
I'm not sure I understand what you're saying. The main protagonist is definitely a black guy (as seen in gameplay footage) and according to the cinematic trailer, apparently the Italian Mafia murdered his family and he's on a quest for revenge now to take down the Italian Mafia. I'm pretty sure I'm as close as can be.
I'm not feeling the "fresh" change. Mafia has 2 games, of which the second I don't even dare to talk about in the. Same sentence as the original. There's hardly any fatigue and thus adding something "fresh" will likely hurt this than not. It's not a surprise quite some people are disappointed and it hardly has anything to do with the visuals.mafia is still the prominent theme of the game. this seems like a fresh change of pace.
I'm aware of that and I don't like it."Mafia" has a broader definition than "Italian Mafia". The series is progressing from a specific Mafia to mafias in general.
So in fact you wanted a new IP?Your view point is stuck in the past and boring. We've had two Mafia games about the Italian Mafia as the main player focus and I applaud 2K for trying something new with this franchise and the Mafia as a whole. This is exactly what I wanted from Mafia 3, new characters, new locations, new stories, new mafia.
I can definitely see this, which is why I wouldn't want it annualised or anything, four or five games tops, maybe even a trilogy, and then let it rest for quite some time before rebooting it.That line of thinking will cause the series to become stagnant. Surely you see this?
why would racial problems in a mafia game, escpecially one set in this era, be bad?racial problems. in a mafia game. that's what I was looking forward to!
[...]
DAY FUCKING 1 of course!
fuck me, this all is so bad...
So in fact you wanted a new IP?
I'm a member friend, all my life.Does this actually exist?
Apparently because it won't be the Godfatherwhy would racial problems in a mafia game, escpecially one set in this era, be bad?
When you say Constructor, do you mean this?A gluttony in comparison to other non-Godfather/Goodfellas/Italian mob kind of games. The vast, vast majority of games dealing with modern organized crime relies on the same trope of Italian mobsters inspired by Godfather and Goodfellas. Stuff like Mafia, Constructor, the Godfather games, most of the entries in the GTA series, Omerta, Scarface, etc.
No. YOU clearly want this to be a new IP, I wanted Mafia 3 to break away from the main player focus and alliegance being the heavily used Italian Mafia and Mafia 3 has done that.
So in fact you wanted a new IP?
Non-American post.Joke, absence of mind, or non american post.
Very poor judgement by IGN
why would racial problems in a mafia game, escpecially one set in this era, be bad?
Basically, because you've been fed one thing your whole life, you don't want to try anything different. You associating mafia with one thing doesn't mean that they need to keep doing that same thing over and over and over again.For those that have quoted me I never said I had any issues with the setting, my main issue is you're not playing as an Italian American and from looking at the gameplay a lot of the "feel" is gone as well. I'm not a fan of the jazzy era that New Orleans is apparently famous for, I'd love another "old school" New York around the same era as the first one. And for those comparing it to GTA, that's completely different. Crime isn't something reserved for a fixed set of nationalities, so they can be white, black, or any other colour. But I, and I'm sure a lot of others as well, associate the world Mafia with the "original" Italian/Sicilian Mafia. Sure, nowadays Mafia is just a term of organised crime regardless of nationality, but I don't think that's how this series began.
I for one wanted Italians, might sound bad but for me the mafia is the Godfather or if in Asia the Triads. Even Mafia 2 annoyed me a bit because we played at the edge of the family affairs instead of being part of it for most of the game.
When I play a criminal I want it to be something like the Godfather or A Bronx Tale. Not that interested in playing a character involved in street gangs.
There must have been a printing error on every copy I've ever seen, because I'm pretty sure the name of the series isn't "Italian Mafia." Black people developing criminal undercurrents can be explored in conventional and historically-grounded ways beyond "look this dude just stole cigarettes from a gas station even though he could have just bought them, must be something wrong with the culture." Granted, that doesn't mean ignorant folk are going to be happy about it because they'd rather just view people of color as a spooky scary card-carrying villain monolith, but more stuff like this is bound to happen. Whether or not you're cool with it is your call.
As other have pointed out, Mafia has a broader connotation.
Even beyond that:
They still feature heavily in the game.
But hey, not for you. We get it.
I want this to be a new IP because I want it to be more of the same? How is that even possible?
You might as well just say you want your criminals to be white men in suits and be done with it.I for one wanted italians, might sound bad but for me the mafia is the Godfather or if in Asia the Triads. Even Mafia 2 annoyed me a bit because we played at the edge of the family affairs instead of being part of it for most of the game.
When I play a criminal I want it to be something like the Godfather or A Bronx Tale. Not that interested in playing a character involved in street gangs.
...No, it isn't the same thing. Wtf?" Hey, let's make The Godfather 4 a romantic comedy about an ageing man who is a young teenager's godfather and they all go on silly adventures, because, you know, the word "godfather" means the same thing here as well "
I couldn't come up with a more silly comparison, but it's basically the same thing.
I think, he was kiddingI don't even ......
" Hey, let's make The Godfather 4 a romantic comedy about an ageing man who is a young teenager's godfather and they all go on silly adventures, because, you know, the word "godfather" means the same thing here as well "
I couldn't come up with a more silly comparison, but it's basically the same thing.
No, I'm well aware of the different kinds of organised crimes they're calling Mafia now, but none of them are remotely as interesting and captivating as the Italian/Sicilian kind to me, which is why this reveal has been extremely disappointing.Basically, because you've been fed one thing your whole life, you don't want to try anything different. You associating mafia with one thing doesn't mean that they need to keep doing that same thing over and over and over again.
Non-American post.
That never crossed my mind.![]()