I wouldn't have an issue with more expensive costumes, or tiered pricing, if they actually offered something new.
If we have to make an MK comparison, look at how long SFIV kept characters with the same into and outro animations, with nothing special between various characters.
MKX Has LOADS of special intros between characters, animation and voice wise; characters have multiple "Cinematic" victory poses, and each brutality basically brings unique victory poses, as well. In SFIV, even the mid-round victories rarely ever changed / were updated, and there were still no character-specific ones, even though the game went through loads of updates and arcade re-releases.
If SFV offered some updates to these things, such as costume-themed intros, taunts, new lines, entirely new outros, and had the other characters react to said changes (Guile acting Bro-like to classic Charlie, appalled and disappointed to Zombie Charlie), then I think that kind of thing would be worth a dollar or 2 more.
Sorry for re-using this gif (and possibly disrupting your cool moment...), but I was just wondering why Capcom seems unwilling to include a few custom fight intro animations like this one again now that they are willing and able to use the in-game graphics to make a movie almost.
I mean, how much work would it relatively be to have Ryu and Ken bump fists, to have Zangief and Mika do a tag team pose (like in the trailer) or to have Guile and Nash greet each other in a special way? Can't be that much work can it, not in comparison to the story mode, and for many of us these animations will get much more use out of them.
They just... didn't seem to care. Even Blazblue introduced special intro poses and outro lines, often times re-using animations from other parts of the game (Like Kokonoe and Azrael's special intro is just a bunch of attack clashes, special moves, and supers, for example.)
I mean, they could do some BASIC Stuff (like just changing a few voice lines, that match the same mouth flaps), and it'd still be better than the stagnant stuff we had for YEARS in SFIV. They spend all their time writing a few unique text lines, but skimp on the voice and animation work beyond that point entirely.