The funny thing is, Bill Clinton was a president that actually BOTHERED to reach out to the Black community and nominate prominent blacks into government after 12 years of being demonized as welfare queens and criminals by the Reagan/Bush administration. Hell, I'm pretty sure they blamed AIDS on us too. I don't know how old you are, but living through that shit was AWFUL.
Yeah, the 90s crack epidemic and subsequent crime explosion led to some aggressive expansion of state and federal prisons, but you were looking at an era where violent crime was double to triple the rate of current day. That was going to happen no matter who the president was, and there were more than a few black people that were in favor of it. No one enjoyed crack fueled shootouts in DC, black or not.
Keep in mind as well that Clinton presided over a period of relative peace, wealth and prosperity at all economic levels, after a bush era recession and prior to yet ANOTHER bush recession and 8 years of nigh endless war.
So no, Black voters having fond memories of the clinton presidential years is not irrational, nor does it revolve around Arsenio Hall OR Toni Morrison- and if you had read her column in which she refers to Clinton it was not meant as as flattery or an endorsement.
I missed this and want to respond to it because I think that it's important to dispel the notion that Bill Clinton didn't know what he was doing when he formed policy in the '90s.
I'm sorry, but what Bill Clinton did to reach out to black voters and what he actually did policy-wise are two different things, and to act like ignoring the latter to celebrate the former is at all a logical way to decide the legacy of a president is devoid of any real, critical evaluation of how good or bad the Clinton presidency was for black folks.
Impoverished black folks became MORE impoverished in the Clinton era. The general lessening of unemployment did, in fact, help some lower-class and middle-class black people, but those gains were undone by Clinton being tough on Welfare users because he accepted the Reagan-era idea that Welfare was being defrauded by LaShonda and her four kids in a Cadillac. Many jobs that black folks of low-income got in the '90s were the type of low-income, last-hired first-fired jobs that kept them trapped in a cycle of poverty. The economic gains made by black folks during the Clinton years are massively overstated and misunderstood.
I remember the '80s well enough, being in my early thirties. Your argument that the Reagan and Bush era demonization of black people was awful is true, but Clinton ENACTED ACTUAL POLICY based on that demonization that even Reagan didn't do, and Reagan might be the biggest example of a wealth-redistributing president that we've ever had.
You can talk about "tough on crime" being something that some black folks wanted, which is certainly true, but the truth is that law-and-order politics were a Nixonian invention that always hurt black people and used law enforcement to harm black folks, and Clinton carried on and codified that policy in numerous ways.
We both know that the Morrison quote is taken out of context by people, so much so that even though you are right, Morrison's intended meaning doesn't matter. There is this weird inflation of Bill's friendliness to black folks because he went on Arsenio and pretended to give a fuck about us.
I think of the Dave Chappelle joke in "For What It's Worth." He was talking about wishing that he could vote for Clinton again in 2000 because he liked that Clinton would kiss black babies when stumping for votes. It's funny, but it's also a pretty astute observation of how black folks were so desperate for positive attention from a president that they assume that he was better for them than he actually was. Studies have been done to show that black folks think they did better economically than they did in the '90s.
I don't blame black folks for this, but we need to be fucking honest so we don't get played by some gladhanding president again when he says sweet words, but knifes us in the back on policy. President Obama isn't perfect, but he actually enacted policy and supports policy that actually helps black folks in this country. I hope Hillary is more like the latter than the former.