Polygon: Xbox Scorpio will be a ~6 TFLOP system (v PS4K's 4.14), unveil soon, Fall 17

I'm thinking final Scorpio spec will be something like:

semi custom APU -

8-core/16 thread Zen @ 2.5 GHz. Powerful, lots of IPC, clocked similar to a Summit Ridge for highend laptop / low-end desktop but same architecture, and much, much better than Jaguar.

semi custom GPU with new features drawn from R&D on Navi architecture - 48 CUs @ whatever clockspeed keeps thermals and power draw reasonable. 6 ~ 7 TFLOP GPU.

16 GB HBM2

Motherboard can be pretty small due to not having GDDR chips and external bus. Everything is on a single package (cpu, gpu, hbm2, interposer, etc)

$399 October / November 2017 launch.
This sounds like a pipe dream. Don't think HBM2 is gonna be cheap.
 
And Spring doesn't make sense too, the best time to launch a new console is Fall. And we're talking about MS here, they fucking love to cram everything in Fall.

inb4 NX, because that thing is a huge question mark.
 
And Spring doesn't make sense too, the best time to launch a new console is Fall. And we're talking about MS here, they fucking love Fall.

inb4 NX, because that thing is a huge question mark.

Spring is the new Fall! They are gonna pull a movie blockbuster timeline on us.
 
And Spring doesn't make sense too, the best time to launch a new console is Fall. And we're talking about MS here, they fucking love Fall.

inb4 NX, because that thing is a huge question mark.

Scorpio will come this year or by March. It would be completely and utterly insane for Microsoft to wait a year.

If the chips their architecture are ready for retail shipping this year, why would they wait a year for their console. I'm willing to bet it will be this November (all assuming this thing exists lol) or by March 2017 at the latest.
 
Well you can't just assume its' gonna cost $600 without some valid reasoning.

I'm gonna share this one more time.

It's not that big of a stretch cost wise. I mean I don't think they will launch $600 either.

But the point does stand, launching a console with a 6 TF GPU right now is going to be expensive. Like hypothetically if you launch a console this fall with 6 TF GPU we're easily talking $450+ or $500+ if break even probably.

It will be interesting if they do though, or if they don't. And it also depends on how they want to spread the cost of the console, or if they wish to take a loss or something else.

Would be interesting actually if MS decides to take a loss this gen as an aggressive tactic, who knows. That strategy has been laid to rest, but maybe it gets a revival this year.
 
I'm thinking final Scorpio spec will be something like:

semi custom APU -

8-core/16 thread Zen @ 2.5 GHz. Powerful, lots of IPC, clocked similar to a Summit Ridge for highend laptop / low-end desktop but same architecture, and much, much better than Jaguar.

semi custom GPU with new features drawn from R&D on Navi architecture - 48 CUs @ whatever clockspeed keeps thermals and power draw reasonable. 6 ~ 7 TFLOP GPU.

16 GB HBM2

Motherboard can be pretty small due to not having GDDR chips and external bus. Everything is on a single package (cpu, gpu, hbm2, interposer, etc)

$399 October / November 2017 launch.
Unlikely. For that price, at least.

That sort of money gets you GDDR5X. And I'm pretty certain they won't go higher than 40 CUs on the graphics part.
 
And Spring doesn't make sense too, the best time to launch a new console is Fall. And we're talking about MS here, they fucking love Fall.

inb4 NX, because that thing is a huge question mark.

So what happens if Neo ends up being Spring 17? I still think launching the Neo this year with PSVR launching this fall as well is kinda a mess. If companies really are moving to iterative models, the release window really shouldn't matter since these aren't necessarily meant as something like the launch of a generation.
 
Scorpio will come this year or by March. It would be completely and utterly insane for Microsoft to wait a year.

If the chips their architecture are ready for retail shipping this year, why would they wait a year for their console. I'm willing to bet it will be this November (all assuming this thing exists lol) or by March 2017 at the latest.

This year is not happening, the software will not be ready, because most (if not all) 3rd party have no access to Scorpio devkits.
 
And Spring doesn't make sense too, the best time to launch a new console is Fall. And we're talking about MS here, they fucking love to cram everything in Fall.

inb4 NX, because that thing is a huge question mark.

I think the only thing MS can do to keep everyone happy and blow our minds is releasing this 6TFLOP beat this holiday. Literally a mic drop moment. This is very unlikely and I do not think will happen. But this can definitely put them over the top. Considering Sony will announce their console later that day.

Other than that, people will be disappointed. Even if launched next spring or next fall (in that case, I actually think they will not even announce it this E3)
 
So what happens if Neo ends up being Spring 17? I still think launching the Neo this year with PSVR launching this fall as well is kinda a mess. If companies really are moving to iterative models, the release window really shouldn't matter since these aren't necessarily meant as something like the launch of a generation.

It's not going to matter. It'll sellout and probably be in short supply until fall. Then flood the market for the holiday season.

What difference does it make?
 
And i'm telling you its not likely. You can't have it both ways. Either you want the system significantly more powerful with Zen, and HBM2 and a Vega architecture cheaper or the same price.

Or you want it to be close to PS4K with a slight upgrade of Jaguar and maybe a GDDR5 refitting and the same Polaris GPU upclocked running hotter

Pick one

We'll have to agree to disagree on that one. My bet is that MS has been working with AMD on the Pro APU alongside the 480 and Zen development to release in the same window.

Yeah, I suggested that first in this thread.

Great minds and all that :)
 
So what happens if Neo ends up being Spring 17? I still think launching the Neo this year with PSVR launching this fall as well is kinda a mess. If companies really are moving to iterative models, the release window really shouldn't matter since these aren't necessarily meant as something like the launch of a generation.

That's a good point when you say that the release window shouldn't matter since it's not the grand launch of a new generation, however; it's a little different because this would be the first launch of the iterative system concept of that's what it turns out to be. So what I'm saying is that it's not a normal iterative launch because it's the very first one for the gaming community.
 
I didn't assume, it was an estimate if they launched it this year. Not meant to be taken as gospel at the dollar lol, come on people. The point being more expensive then neo, considering neo is less flops and using jaguar if the specs leaked are true. Not sure what x1 and Ps4 have to do with anything. In order for Scorpio to up NEO by that many flops it would need a new CPU....

It goes to show that both Sony and MS don't paid consumer prices for their hardware hence it would probably never exceed $499
 
I really don't think HBM2 is feasible this year or next year. I mean we haven't even seen HBM2 in a PC GPU yet.......

16 GB of HBM2 for a console, this year, or next year? I mean.... I don't think so. If they do it, I'll be very impressed though.
 
Unlikely. For that price, at least.

That sort of money gets you GDDR5X. And I'm pretty certain they won't go higher than 40 CUs on the graphics part.

HBM2 can actually make the overall price cheaper since the console will run cooler, the mobo would be less complex due to lack of bus, and the bus interconnect would be absent from the soc. Itll definitely be cheaper for the console in the long run.
 
This year is not happening, the software will not be ready, because most (if not all) 3rd party have no access to Scorpio devkits.

I don't think they'll need dev kits that soon since they're not targeting the console. I said earlier that I think the box will have its own method for doing a quick nasty improvement to existing titles.

1st parties will get a patch. 3rd parties will get their dev kits towards the end of the year and have the option to release a patch.
 
Well Brad Sam's podcast was leaking their E3, and focused on Scorpio, so yeah he's implying it'll be announced at E3, no?

Then after all of the Scorpio stuff leaked, Phil Spencer is on twitter saying lots of creative chatter today, can't wait to share our story at E3. I think it's clear he's responding to the Scorpio rumours, in that case, if they aren't revealing it at E3 what story do they have to share at E3 (taking the context of the tweet into consideration, unless I'm misunderstanding the tweet?)?

There's also the investigation Ekim did and found out two hardware consoles FCC NDA's expiring this year.

Couldn't it not being finalized be referring to upclock/downclocking, which can be done whenever really.




In response to your edit, if it's not coming out this year, I agree, they should wait until 2017 to reveal it at their event. But if it's going to be at this years E3 (or at any 2016 event), it's coming out this year IMO.

Brad Sam's podcast mentioned multiple things, each with different and unknown or unconfirmed timelines. Those things included a small Amazon Fire-size device, a smaller Xbox One he said will come out this year, the Xbox interface coming to Windows 10 PC probably around Redstone 2 (spring 2017), and that MS was doing some "crazy" things with a new Xbox and he heard from one source that it was targeting 10 TF, as well as something about spring 2017. Kotaku heard 5-6TF and sometime 2017.

I agree that if they announce something at E3 it's coming this year. I just don't see it happening if they are going for significant changes like Spencer suggested.
 
So what happens if Neo ends up being Spring 17? I still think launching the Neo this year with PSVR launching this fall as well is kinda a mess. If companies really are moving to iterative models, the release window really shouldn't matter since these aren't necessarily meant as something like the launch of a generation.

Neo will end up in 2017 only if Sony fucked it up somehow (no software, low shipments...etc), not because they think it's better timing.

And even with iterative models, companies will choose the best timing to launch their new products which have been historically Fall.
 
It's not going to matter. It'll sellout and probably be in short supply until fall. Then flood the market for the holiday season.

What difference does it make?

Well specifically in regards to marketing, what do you focus on? Are you pushing PSVR and at the end of every ad for any of the games it just says play it on PSK4 or whatever? Does PSVR just stay as a smaller thing while they build the units sold to the people desperate to jump into VR before making a wider push to everyone else? It's a weird thing to have 2 expensive pieces of hardware coming out close to each other.
 
Brad Sam's podcast mentioned multiple things, each with different and unknown or unconfirmed timelines. Those things included a small Amazon Fire-size device, a smaller Xbox One he said will come out this year, the Xbox interface coming to Windows 10 PC probably around Redstone 2 (spring 2017), and that MS was doing some "crazy" things with a new Xbox and he heard from one source that it was targeting 10 TF, as well as something about spring 2017. Kotaku heard 5-6TF and sometime 2017.

I agree that if they announce something at E3 it's coming this year. I just don't see it happening if they are going for significant changes like Spencer suggested.

just fyi, that's not true. He did not heard or claim he heard. He was reading the chat and someone in the chat mentioned 10TF. He did not talk about spec at all, since he had no idea.
 
perma-ban me if scorpio releases in 2016
hqdefault.jpg


Bai.

=P
 
And Spring doesn't make sense too, the best time to launch a new console is Fall. And we're talking about MS here, they fucking love to cram everything in Fall.

inb4 NX, because that thing is a huge question mark.

I think it was supposed to be this fall, but delayed when Redstone 2 got delayed as well.

At that point there wasn't much they could do. Scorpio will probably feature stuff that needs Redstone 2 (I suspect it will bring improvements to uwp on xbox so uwp games can be a reality), so it can't launch sooner. And fall 2017 might be too late.
 
So if MS did pull this off for 2016 at 399, that would be just like the release of the 360, correct? Advanced tech in a console before it's released on PC.


And I'm just daydreaming, I really don't know what's gonna happen or claim to be a good analyst, just having fun getting hyped.
 
just fyi, that's not true. He did not heard or claim he heard. He was reading the chat and someone in the chat mentioned 10TF. He did not talk about spec at all, since he had no idea.

You're right, he did read the chat on the spec. Thanks for pointing that out.

He did say he is hearing Xbox, hardware, spring.
 
So if MS did pull this off for 2016 at 399, that would be just like the release of the 360, correct? Advanced tech in a console before it's released on PC.

Depends on what's in it. The 480 comes out this month for $199 so that card will be available well before this or the Neo come out. The memory and CPU situation is the real question.
 
My Scorpio spec prediction, assuming Fall 2017 release.

4-8 Zen core depending on zen benchmarks and tdp.

Vega with possibly Navi stuff. 48 CUs clocked at around 1ghz. 6 - 6.5 teraflops
1 stack of 8GB HBM2.

4GB of DDR4 on a 64 bit bus. 20 gb/s. OS only.

Various DSP, such as Shape, graphics related, VR related on the SOC.
 
Wait 16 gig of stacked memory? lol no way is that gonna happen. Way too expensive. And isn't one of the purpose of stacked memory is to be able to use LESS and perform better?Even 4 gigs of HMB2 would compare favorably to 8 gigs of GDDR5 from my understandstanding. Could be wrong.
 
I don't think they'll need dev kits that soon since they're not targeting the console. I said earlier that I think the box will have its own method for doing a quick nasty improvement to existing titles.

1st parties will get a patch. 3rd parties will get their dev kits towards the end of the year and have the option to release a patch.

Yeah, that's pretty much impossible.
 
Jesus, this thread went crazy for a moment. Either way, Scorpio wont be announced until Spring 2017. Scorpio probably will be alluded to a little bit at E3 and some at gamescom talking about newer devices. The spring event is for all hardware made by Microsoft. It's really been easy to understand that. Scorpio releasing in Fall 2017 seems very reasonable. I think too many people are hyped up about it and think MS has to talk about it very soon. Nah, if anyone does, it would be Sony since they are presumably launching this fall.

Be realistic here guys.
 
My Scorpio spec prediction, assuming Fall 2017 release.

4-8 Zen core depending on zen benchmarks and tdp.

Vega with possibly Navi stuff. 48 CUs clocked at around 1ghz. 6 - 6.5 teraflops
1 stack of 8GB HBM2.

4GB of DDR4 on a 64 bit bus. 20 gb/s. OS only.

Various DSP, such as Shape, graphics related, VR related on the SOC.

Doubt they'll be split memory.
 
but rumours point towards neo being the result of sony trying to make a slim ps4 and being forced to upgrade the chips in order to keep cost down. They werent going towards making a powerful new system. I cant see it being expensive

Im sure MS was forced down the same path while wanting to slimline their console but chose to dial it up to 11.

That rumor sounds kind bullocks for me. If it was cheaper going for the newer archictecture why not change the cpu as well?
 
Top Bottom