Now that I'm home from work, I've been able to watch the trailer a couple of times. Have a lot on my mind here, and I'm going to let it out.
THE TRAILER
First thing's first, this was way better than the Wii U debut trailer. In every single way. Easy to understand, straightforward, presented games we knew were coming (Zelda), ports of games we are familiar with (Splatoon, Kart, Skyrim) and entirely new games (3D Mario). Overall, it was good stuff.
Now lets break it down. This pic from the OP does a good job illustrating everything shown in the trailer, but I'm going to break it down in chronological order.
We start with a guy playing Zelda on the TV. Doge wants to go for a walk. Like anyone in a Nintendo commercial, instead of taking a fucking 10 minute break from the kideo games, why not continue to strain your eyes and take the gaming experience with you! Fuck you doge!
The name is revealed at last: Nintendo Switch. I don't know how I feel about the name yet. Unlike the Wii U, it certainly explains the concept (Switch from your TV to a handheld!), Switch is really an every day word and doesn't really roll of the tongue for me. I think I would have liked Nintendo Go better. Switch isn't horrible, though. Anyways...
Dude doesn't even look at his furry friend as he changes control methods. and then BOOM
The fucking frame rate drops to the teens. Dude. What. I don't understand this at all. Trailers like this are supposed to be full of bullshit. Why was the footage of handheld Zelda so choppy? Will playing games on the go result in a framerate drop? Will this be fixed come launch? Was it just an error with the trailer? Yikes...
We switch to the airport. The most important thing here is our introduction to 3DS-esque carts as the physical media for the system, and the angle at which we see the hardware. It looks like there will be 4 shoulder buttons in their traditional positions... and are those analog triggers I see? Yessssssss Nintendo.
I barely go on airplanes, but even if I did, I'd never use that stand or detach the controllers from the main unit like that. Just seems like such a rare use case. If I'm going to play a handheld... what's wrong with playing it with the joycons attached to the unit? I guess they want to give people options.
Then he gets home and picks up the pro controller. aww yeah. That's what I'm talking about. We're back to asymmetical analog sticks as it should be, and the sticks themselves look like Xbone's, which is great. This is how I will play Switch 99% of the time.
Skyrim is a big get for Nintendo. I hope the third parties don't get scared off when it sells like shit, though. It's going to be a worse looking version of a 5 year old game on a Nintendo platform for the first time. I hope Nintendo offers Bethesda some incentive here.
And now we come to the dumbest, most unrealistic part of the video imo... people crowding around a screen and playing with insanely small "controllers" with 1 analog stick and 4 buttons. I personally can't ever see a situation where my friends or I would ever partake in such an activity. Playing a game that way looks insanely uncomfortable, too.
I know when I play pickup ball outside, sweaty as fuck, the first thing I want to do is grab my expensive ass video game system that I left in my bag and play fake basketball IMMEDIATELY after playing real basketball.
"It's a beautiful day, come outside and chill with us you fucking introvert!"
"fiiiiiiiiiine but i'm bringing my nintendo out with me you boring fucks"
now gather round the tiny screen outside and play video games with me in this totally realistic situation
Now we enter the esports portion of the video, which caught me off guard. This tells me that Nintendo has plans for getting more involved with esports going forward. Possibly hosting their own tournaments? With prize money?
Earlier this year, the fake tournament that filled up a stadium in this advertisement was a reality at Evo 2016 in July, where Super Smash Bros Melee filled up an entire stadium for the finals day, with over 100k viewers on the stream. In real life, Splatoon will not fill up a stadium... Smash Bros will. Specifically, Melee HD. If Nintendo really wants to get into esports, they need to push Smash HARD.
Overall, while silly and unrealistic, a good video and some nice game announcements. I really hope the frame rate drop was a mistake, though.
GENERAL THOUGHTS ON SWITCH
While it's still early (no price or games really announced besides Zelda), from this trailer it seems the Switch is pretty underpowered compared to the PS4 and Xbox One. Impressive for a portable, yes, but... I'm not sure how much of a selling point that is these days. I do expect a $199 or $249 price point on this thing, but I'm not sure if that will be enough to actually sell the thing to the masses. If the big, third party games look noticeably worse than the competition... that is going to hurt this console. Nintendo can not get by these days with first party output alone. This will not be another Wii.
So overall, looking at the market appeal of this thing, I honestly don't see a machine that is much more appealing than the Wii U or 3DS. The gimmick (Console gaming on the go) doesn't seem that appealing to me, much less the general public. The core gamer will be happy with their Playstation or Xbox, the casual gamer will be happy with their mobile games... this appeals to someone in between. The people that bought the Wii U and 3DS. Die hard Nintendo fans... and some other people. That's my early prediction.
But forget the market. The market shit on the Wii U and I loved it. What do I think? Well, to me, I was looking out for three things today:
1. Hardware power
2. Controller
3. Software
I can look at the hardware power in two different ways: Optimistically and pessimistically. Pessimistically, this thing is an underpowered console that appears barely more powerful than Wii U, that I can take on the go. meh.
However, optimistically... this thing is a huge jump from the 3DS in power, AND I can play it on my TV! WAOW VERY NICE
So I'm not too concerned there. While deep down I long for a Scorpio-equivalent in power that plays Nintendo games, I knew that wasn't going to happen. The Wii U first party games, running at 720p/60fps with Nintendo's god tier art design looked fantastic. If this thing is a bit stronger than Wii U, it should look fine.
The controller, that is, the pro controller, also looks great. As I mentioned, analog triggers seem to be in tact, and it's taken the superior form of the asymmetrical analog sticks. I will barely play Switch without this controller, so it looks like they nailed that aspect. I'm also assuming the GC controller adapter will be compatible, as the dock had USB ports
Finally, the software. We got a bunch of ports (it looks like) and one new game.
Zelda BOTW
Mario Kart 8 w/ double dash item style and King Boo
Splatoon 1.5 (or 2? Was unclear)
Skyrim Special Edition
3D MARIO!
Not much more can be said about Zelda. I'm looking forward to it, of course. Seeing Mario Kart 8 and Splatoon close to launch would be sweet. These games are too good to die on the Wii U and should be experienced by a larger audience. Additional characters, gameplay modes and other various features are a great idea. Cheap, easy and a fantastic way to fill up the launch day/window lineup for Switch. I'm going to guess that Smash 4 will also be coming to Switch, with new stages and hopefully characters too (Ice Climbers!).
The star of the show was 3D Mario. From the brief look we had, it looks like it will be heading back to the 64/Sunshine style of 3D Mario, at least a little bit. Those few seconds of the game just LOOKED way better than 3D Land and 3D World when they were first presented. I want to see more. Badly. I need it.
SO OVERALL:
I come away from today's announcement pretty happy. I'm happy the crazy speculation is over, and we at least have something to talk about until... probably January, when Nintendo talks about Switch again. I look at today's news excited to play Zelda with that pro controller. I'm excited to play the greatest hits of the Wii U with some neat twists and extras. Most of all, a new 3D Mario masterpiece is coming, and it looks fantastic.
Not bad Nintendo, not bad at all.