Manga Discussion/News Thread |OT4| New Ch/Vols! - SEE FIRST POST FOR RULES!

Status
Not open for further replies.
Elaborate?

I think what he means is : "You'd have to be insane to think that Shirahoshi is going to join the Strawhats."

I agree with him.

Seriously, she fits the SH MO perfectly, and they old lady had legs in water 7 arc, so Shirahoshi can have legs when she is on land.

No, she can't. A Mermaid's tails splits when she turns 30, and Shirahoshi is 16. Unless Vander Decken comes out of nowhere and doubles her age, she isn't going anywhere.
 
NARUTO

Too much action... can't keep track of what's happening.

I fucking lol'd when Madara squinted his eyes after hearing Naruto say "Other Madara" and Madara remarking "God damn you Kabuto".
 
I think what he means is : "You'd have to be insane to think that Shirahoshi is going to join the Strawhats."

I agree with him.



No, she can't. A Mermaid's tails splits when she turns 30, and Shirahoshi is 16. Unless Vander Decken comes out of nowhere and doubles her age, she isn't going anywhere.

So. She can also call sea kings. So it´s not impossible for her to for her tails to turn to legs early. She is special from what we read in this arc.
 
One Piece C

Finally a closure to this arc. Sea kings appearing are pretty boss.


You lied about what I said about One Piece, I literally never implied or said One Piece was as good as the best written series ever. That is definitely disrespectful and misinformation only to make yourself look better.

All of my "balls to wall" hate for them is completely legitimate. Maybe if you sat down and read what I'm talking about, you'd realize there is nothing wrong with my complaints. Everyone of my complaints about Naruto, Bleach, and even One Piece are perfectly valid opinions to have on the three series and are well-backed up with actual facts. I'm not just bringing up my dislike of Naruto out of anywhere either. When this chapter is shit, I'm going to point it out as I was really displeased with this chapter. My points may line up with the entire Naruto series, but they apply to this chapter too, which is what I'm talking about.
Yes, "you lied about what I said about One Piece" is verrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrry specific. I can't say I'm shocked you're just being vague again. And just save that ridiculous old chestnut where whenever I tell you exactly what's wrong with you're doing, you announce I'm not reading your posts. It's patently obvious I AM reading your posts, and feel free to post exactly how and when I'm not "reading your posts," but I can't say I'm going to be shocked when you just do exactly what you did here and just say post the exact same, unsourced thing you just posted again and go "you aren't reading my posts."

If I went to the Skyward Sword thread to announce I hate every Zelda and I only played each game in succession to tell everyone I hated them despite knowing I hated them all since a Link to the Past sucked I would be considered a troll.
 
Yes, "you lied about what I said about One Piece" is verrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrry specific. I can't say I'm shocked you're just being vague again. And just save that ridiculous old chestnut where whenever I tell you exactly what's wrong with you're doing, you announce I'm not reading your posts. It's patently obvious I AM reading your posts, and feel free to post exactly how and when I'm not "reading your posts," but I can't say I'm going to be shocked when you just do exactly what you did here and just say post the exact same, unsourced thing you just posted again and go "you aren't reading my posts."

If I went to the Skyward Sword thread to announce I hate every Zelda and I only played each game in succession to tell everyone I hated them despite knowing I hated them all since a Link to the Past sucked I would be considered a troll.

You're really starting to jump the shark in these arguments, grimmy. Just let it slide man ..
 
You're really starting to jump the shark in these arguments, grimmy. Just let it slide man ..
You can't "jump the shark" in an argument. That doesn't' even make any sense. I'm just saying, if I have to "let it slide," why doesn't he have to let Naruto and Bleach "slide" and stop trolling them every single week. It isn't any different.

It's also wildly transparent why he keeps referring to being "disrespected;" it's because he's trying to reference the GAF posting rules so he can send reports to the moderators.
 
Never watched it. Have it on watch but am so behind on anime who knows.

I don't even...I really don't even...

You guys better not be part of the k-on/shaft shit generation.

my shaftbros will back me up on this - shaft > u

and 2007 was better than the years you listed!
 
my shaftbros will back me up on this - shaft > u

and 2007 was better than the years you listed!
2007 had Claymore and a lot of 2006 went into 2007. But it didn't have such strong hitters as previous years.

I like shaft shows a lot. I was just labeling a group of watchers who usually fit that shaft/moe label. But even my favorite shaft shows don't match up to the greats.
Meduca > you
Well, I haven't seen it so maybe.

Enough about anime apparently cause I'm getting a high dose of insanity. Anytime Cowboy Bebop is followed by shit and lulz I am OUT.
 
2007 had Claymore and a lot of 2006 went into 2007. But it didn't have such strong hitters as previous years.

I like shaft shows a lot. I was just labeling a group of watchers who usually fit that shaft/moe label. But even my favorite shaft shows don't match up to the greats.

Well, I haven't seen it so maybe.

Enough about anime apparently cause I'm getting a high dose of insanity. Anytime Cowboy Bebop is followed by shit and lulz I am OUT.

BhFGW.gif
 
I had fun with K-on. It was so silly I just had to smile.
Both true.

I watched and enjoyed K-on (both seasons). I've become a slice of life anime fan in the past year. From Shaft, I watched Soredemo, Arakawa, Bakemonogatari, Denpa, Zetsubou, Maria Holic, and Arashi. I watch Ika, Working, Ben-To, Pengiun, Gintama, Chihayafuru, and C3 with more on deck. My favorite anime are probably Cowboy Bebop and FMP. My favorite manga are Karin and Lovely Complex.

So yea, I don't know what the fuck I like. But damn if I will accept shows like Bebop, GitS, and FMP getting hate. Well...I actually don't care that much but I find it unacceptable...so yea...not sure what that means.
 
Both true.

I watched and enjoyed K-on (both seasons). I've become a slice of life anime fan in the past year. From Shaft, I watched Soredemo, Arakawa, Bakemonogatari, Denpa, Zetsubou, Maria Holic, and Arashi. I watch Ika, Working, Ben-To, Pengiun, Gintama, Chihayafuru, and C3 with more on deck. My favorite anime are probably Cowboy Bebop and FMP. My favorite manga are Karin and Lovely Complex.

So yea, I don't know what the fuck I like. But damn if I will accept shows like Bebop, GitS, and FMP getting hate. Well...I actually don't care that much but I find it unacceptable...so yea...not sure what that means.

I don't know you, it just seemed appropriate :lol
 
Both true.

I watched and enjoyed K-on (both seasons). I've become a slice of life anime fan in the past year. From Shaft, I watched Soredemo, Arakawa, Bakemonogatari, Denpa, Zetsubou, Maria Holic, and Arashi. I watch Ika, Working, Ben-To, Pengiun, Gintama, Chihayafuru, and C3 with more on deck. My favorite anime are probably Cowboy Bebop and FMP. My favorite manga are Karin and Lovely Complex.

So yea, I don't know what the fuck I like. But damn if I will accept shows like Bebop, GitS, and FMP getting hate. Well...I actually don't care that much but I find it unacceptable...so yea...not sure what that means.
Going off from what you like. I think you'd have a field day watching Honey & Clover. It's a pretty quality series.
 
Asides from having some of the best shows of the decade, sure, it didn't have strong hitters.
I'm guessing Gurren Lagann but...
I don't know you, it just seemed appropriate :lol
It is appropriate. The avatar is actually a gaming reference...but it still fits.

Who wants to marathon read TLR and watch Macross Zero?

Dats the craziness
Going off from what you like. I think you'd have a field day watching Honey & Clover. It's a pretty quality series.
Couldn't get past the fake loli.
 
Doesn't really seem that much more offensive than TLR in terms of silly nonsense

You sure you're not looking at this from an internet point of view?
I think TLR Darkness actually has a plot to justify the naked school girls, but I'm not about to go read it to find out.
 
Doesn't really seem that much more offensive than TLR in terms of silly nonsense

You sure you're not looking at this from an internet point of view?

I tried to watch the first episode but found it completely off-putting. Which says a lot, since I watched Lucky Star in its entirety.
 
I tried to watch the first episode but found it completely off-putting. Which says a lot, since I watched Lucky Star in its entirety.
The moe stuttering was pretty frustrating but fighting it was part of what was so silly about it

I dunno, I think I'll love any series which is confident and goes full force with how ridiculous it is. It's really fun. I still think the internet made K-on into something slightly different though.

When I say it like that it seems like I'm just insecure/easily influenced
I totally am

I think TLR Darkness actually has a plot to justify the naked school girls, but I'm not about to go read it to find out.
That makes it even more silly
 
The Loli is a non-starter!

Spoiler about the loli looking girl
It's not like she hooks up with anyone. edit: wait maybe they did is was a while back

It just seems weird to not watch one of the better series around, because of the aesthetics on one character. Especially since the series has 6 main characters.
 
Spoiler about the loli looking girl
It's not like she hooks up with anyone.

It just seems weird to not watch because of the aesthetics on one character. The series has 6 main characters.

I will admit I'm far less likely to want to read something when I come across a loli. Shonen manga is often a cliche'd genre and I know way too much about what I'm going to get with lolis.

Wasn't there like a GAF moratorium on Vampire Bund at one point?
 
I think TLR Darkness actually has a plot to justify the naked school girls, but I'm not about to go read it to find out.
Coward
Get over it. It's arguably the best comedy, romance, drama, slice-of-life series around.
I'll strongly consider it. My favorite romances are probably Planetes, Place Promised, Lovely Complex, Library War, Karin, and Love Hina. My shoujo goes to manga with Aishiteruze Baby, Lovely Complex(again), Prince Ludwig, Monkey High, Special A, Red Haired Snow White, Dengeki Daisy, etc...

I kind of watch/read for the medium if you get what I'm saying. I don't have many SoL on my lists but they have grown on me in the past years.
 
Spoiler about the loli looking girl
It's not like she hooks up with anyone. edit: wait maybe they did is was a while back
It just seems weird to not watch because of the ascetics on one character. The series has 6 main characters.

I see what you did there

edit fail


Late on this but

Fairy Tail

Really? A tournament arc?

seinfeld.gif
How can anyone open an issue of Fairy Tail expecting anything better? Next thing you know people will be mad that it's resolved by Natsu powering up more than normal and/or eating the wrong substance.
 
I will admit I'm far less likely to want to read something when I come across a loli. Shonen manga is often a cliche'd genre and I know way too much about what I'm going to get with lolis.

Wasn't there like a GAF moratorium on Vampire Bund at one point?
This isn't shounen, it's Josei. She isn't sexualized in any way, none of the characters are for that matter.

I'll strongly consider it. My favorite romances are probably Planetes, Place Promised, Lovely Complex, Library War, Karin, and Love Hina. My shoujo goes to manga with Aishiteruze Baby, Lovely Complex(again), Prince Ludwig, Monkey High, Special A, Red Haired Snow White, Dengeki Daisy, etc...

I kind of watch/read for the medium if you get what I'm saying. I don't have many SoL on my lists but they have grown on me in the past years.
With your tastes it seems a major waste not to watch it.

I see what you did there

edit fail

Yeah lol messed it up again. xD
 
How the fuck is that even possible? Aren't Neogaf adds done by Google adds? Doesn't google have policies against this?
You would think, given that was how somemanga got shut down.
 
Not the first time its happened.

Google: Smoking, Drug Talk, Sexual Talk unacceptable. Piracy? Hell yeah!
 
I sort of wonder what Akira Toriyama does all day other than count money from video game rehashes of DBZ.
 
Yes, "you lied about what I said about One Piece" is verrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrry specific. I can't say I'm shocked you're just being vague again. And just save that ridiculous old chestnut where whenever I tell you exactly what's wrong with you're doing, you announce I'm not reading your posts. It's patently obvious I AM reading your posts, and feel free to post exactly how and when I'm not "reading your posts," but I can't say I'm going to be shocked when you just do exactly what you did here and just say post the exact same, unsourced thing you just posted again and go "you aren't reading my posts."
You've admitted many times in the past that you don't read my posts, including the actual explanation to why I read Bleach and Naruto.

Secondly that isn't a vague comment at all. This is what you said, in quote:
Pretty much everyone knows you're a joke character like DTL at this point after your insane Oda is among the best writers in the world rant.
This right here is a straight up lie, and never happened, ever. The only reason why you would even remotely think that is your failed interpretation of one of my posts.

I do not appreciate you straight up lying about things I said only to make yourself look better at all.

If I went to the Skyward Sword thread to announce I hate every Zelda and I only played each game in succession to tell everyone I hated them despite knowing I hated them all since a Link to the Past sucked I would be considered a troll.
The difference here is that Zelda is known amongst gaming itself to be a high quality franchise and is commonly accepted as such. Naruto and Bleach are commonly accepted as being low quality franchises in the entire manga fanbase, and everyone of my complaints about them are perfectly valid. Your analogy would be better if you said it's like going into a Sucker Punch thread and saying Sucker Punch sucks.
 
I sort of wonder what Akira Toriyama does all day other than count money from video game rehashes of DBZ.

He probably just moves over to counting his Dragon Quest money. That, and training people to emulate his style so Shueisha can nag someone else to milk every last drop out of Dragon Ball.

You've admitted many times in the past that you don't read my posts, including the actual explanation to why I read Bleach and Naruto.

Your explanation was poor. "I read them because they're popular and I want to discuss the popular manga" just sounds like a justification for trolling
 
Your explanation was poor. "I read them because they're popular and I want to discuss the popular manga" just sounds like a justification for trolling
How is that a justification for trolling or a bad reason? I guess I should never watch movies that are popular anymore.
 
How is that a justification for trolling or a bad reason? I guess I should never watch movies that are popular anymore.

Constantly exposing yourself to something you don't like just because other people do goes against common sense. There are plenty of popular shows that I don't don't like, except I don't watch them week in, week out.
 
Constantly exposing yourself to something you don't like just because other people do goes against common sense. There are plenty of popular shows that I don't don't like, except I don't watch them week in, week out.
Well not everyone is like you. I'm a completionist so once I'm on something, I have to finish it.

I also feel like that one can't really have a proper opinion on something unless they've completely experienced it. If I were to write a series review for Naruto, I wouldn't do so without finishing it first. I feel like this should be the standard for anyone who wants to talk about these series, which is my main goal in reading both Naruto and Bleach.

To me anyone who tries to have an extensive opinion on something without finishing the thing they have an opinion on is someone with a failed opinion.
 
So. She can also call sea kings. So it´s not impossible for her to for her tails to turn to legs early. She is special from what we read in this arc.

So, literally, it would require a Deus Ex Machina.

Okay, here is precisely why Shirahoshi will never ever join the Straw Hats ever: has actual responsibilities to fill, just like Vivi. COMPLETELY AND TOTALLY USELESS IN A FIGHT, and that's the biggy, because she would get tentacle raped in the New World. After the timeskip powerups by the crew, any new crew members will have to be already on their level. Sabo is the only possible exception to this. Obviously, she can't go on land (and no, this is not going to be handwaved away). She's way too ****ing big. If the Straw Hats are going to get a fishman in the crew, Jinbe is the perfect size.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom