Support NeoGAF

[Cloudy]

With all the TDs, they've called back this year, THAT stands?

 

[Futurevoid]

Don't agree with that call but whatever. Nothing you can do about it since you don't know what the hell a catch is anymore.

 

[The Frankman]

... are you kidding me?

REALLY? God damn it just make up the rules as you go, NFL.

Fingertip catches don't count as catches now? Since Tyree never pulled it into the breadbasket should it have been ruled incomplete?

Tyree had that secured on his helmet. The ball appeared to be moving in his fingertips.

Like FutureVoid said, I'm guessing not enough evidence to overturn.

 

[Goro Majima]

"ruling stands"

means there wasn't enough evidence I guess

 

[3N16MA]

Packers selling shares to earn money in order to pay off refs. Run with it Giants fans.

 

[Spectral Glider]

Fix is in, Giants would need Tebow to get the W now.

 

[Doomsayer]

Holy SHIT Aldon Smith!

 

[Elfforkusu]

... are you kidding me?

REALLY? God damn it just make up the rules as you go, NFL.

I have no idea what's a catch anymore. It makes it more exciting!

Spoiler

Not really, it's just stupid.

 

[etiolate]

Aldon Smith yessh

 

[eznark]

I think the only reason that was ruled a touchdown is because Jennings never went to the ground.

I fucking hate this league so much.

Tyree had that secured on his helmet. The ball appeared to be moving in his fingertips.

Actually that slo-mo replay showed the ball was not moving in his fingers for at least 3 steps. Who know, I'd be furious if I were a Giants fan.

 

[MetatronM]

The left hand looked like it had the ball for a few steps at the end there...

A catch?

You could see on that last replay that the left hand clearly did NOT have the ball for the whole time. It did control it for about one step and then was promptly knocked out again by the defender.

No idea how they could call that a touchdown, but I'm not surprised they did.

 

[Gully State]

Aldon Smith...holy fuck...just pancaked the fuck out of Goldberg

 

[mastershake]

Don't agree with that call but whatever. Nothing you can do about it since you don't know what the hell a catch is anymore.

.

 

[Nemesis121]

cmon giants-gaf... yall are beter than that

Please all game long JPP, Canty, and Tuck is being held, the Giants have to beat the Packers, the Refs, and the NFL who want you to go 19-0....

 

[Oozer3993]

Kevin Kolb is a franchise quarterback.

Are we talking a Quiznos franchise?

 

[Wellington]

Want to take 7 off the board for the Packers?

How about Eli doesn't throw that pick 6.

 

[Kusagari]

Who is better Kolb or Keenum?

 

[The Frankman]

Please all game long JPP, Canty, and Tuck is being held, the Giants have to beat the Packers, the Refs, and the NFL who want you to go 19-0....

I never know if you're trolling.

Want to take 7 off the board for the Packers?

How about Eli doesn't throw that pick 6.

GB is just having fun out there on D.

 

[Elfforkusu]

... are you kidding me?

REALLY? God damn it just make up the rules as you go, NFL.

Tyree had that secured on his helmet. The ball appeared to be moving in his fingertips.

Last couple steps it looked like he had the tip of the ball grasped in his left hand. Is that enough for a catch? I don't know, and the ref might not either based on him saying "the call stands".

 

[ZZMitch]

Please all game long JPP, Canty, and Tuck is being held, the Giants have to beat the Packers, the Refs, and the NFL who want you to go 19-0....

Time to wear the tin foil hats!

 

[Deleted member 8095]

What the fuck, that toy is a total Dinoriders rip off!

 

[Dragon]

The ball seemed to be moving in his grasp.

 

[TheDarkKnight774]

ugh cowboys...here we go again!

 

[jacket320]

Kevin Kolb is a franchise quarterback.

Looked sharp on that drive in particular

 

[cajunator]

Well I'm out of here. Off to work. GO SAINTS.

 

[Goro Majima]

Please all game long JPP, Canty, and Tuck is being held, the Giants have to beat the Packers, the Refs, and the NFL who want you to go 19-0....

Really? Giants-GAF is better than this. Every team has to play against the refs and gets the benefit of calls at times.

 

[brentech]

... are you kidding me?

REALLY? God damn it just make up the rules as you go, NFL.

You try to judge the outcome of a play based on the team that makes it.

Just watch the damn thing. The ball doesn't move at all when on his finger-tips until he gets hit by the defender, after like 3-4 steps no less. Now, I'm not saying its an easy judge, because the rules are weird now, but to say he didn't have control is just a complete lie.

 

[Rafa=FedKilla]

What the fuck, that toy is a total Dinoriders rip off!

And 43 dollars to boot!

 

[Futurevoid]

The dream!

 

[mjc]

You could see on that last replay that the left hand clearly did NOT have the ball for the whole time. It did control it for about one step and then was promptly knocked out again by the defender.

No idea how they could call that a touchdown, but I'm not surprised they did.

I think we can safely blame the rules for it.

 

[The Frankman]

Ok who changed this from Madden to Tecmo Bowl?

 

[C Jones]

You could see on that last replay that the left hand clearly did NOT have the ball for the whole time. It did control it for about one step and then was promptly knocked out again by the defender.

No idea how they could call that a touchdown, but I'm not surprised they did.

It's because the ball stopped moving in his hand. It doesn't matter how many hands you have on it.

 

[Dragon]

Well I'm out of here. Off to work. GO SAINTS.

GEAUX?

 

[eznark]

Tramon is getting absolutely clowned

 

[Wellington]

Wow. Fucking lost another TO. Way to fucking go.

 

[mastershake]

nice throw by eli there

 

[Elfforkusu]

Ok who changed this from Madden to Tecmo Bowl?

*slowly raises hand*

 

[darkside31337]

How did the Giants even end up using a timeout there? That's awful.

 

[tmdorsey]

*Sigh*. It must be nice to have QB and receivers who can make plays deep down the field.

 

[etiolate]

"Alex Smith's career has been like a mini-series on the Lifetime channel."

Make this happen pls

 

[Ducarmel]

nice play by the g-men, but wow clay got leveled.

 

[mr2xxx]

Clutch catch by Hakeem.

 

[Slo]

Take six steps with the ball in the end zone.

Still have no idea if it's a catch.

This league is so dumb.

Seemed EXACTLY like Rudolph's TD today, which they ruled a catch.

 

[mjc]

How did the Giants even end up using a timeout there? That's awful.

They had to since they couldn't get down field fast enough.

 

[Goro Majima]

Tramon isn't really a pro bowl corner this year.

I'm also pretty sure my PS3 Sunday Ticket is about 2 minutes behind the broadcast...

 

[eznark]

Wow. Fucking lost another TO. Way to fucking go.

What happened there? Did they just celebrate instead of going down the field?? Hell, I'll trade 50 yards for your timeouts every time up by two scores.

 

[LJ11]

They've overturned catches for less than that Jennings catch this year, thought that one would be a no brainer.

 

[GraveRobberX]

What the fuck, that toy is a total Dinoriders rip off!

And PRICEY AS FUCK!, $42.99? WHAT ON EARTH?

Dinoriders were cheap as I remember, I mean the T-Rex was only $19.99 @ my local Kay-Bee Store

 

[The Frankman]

You try to judge the outcome of a play based on the team that makes it.

Just watch the damn thing. The ball doesn't move at all when on his finger-tips until he gets hit by the defender, after like 3-4 steps no less. Now, I'm not saying its an easy judge, because the rules are weird now, but to say he didn't have control is just a complete lie.

If the ball moves slightly with the new rules, it's not secured possession. Bottom line. I thought I saw the ball move in his fingers before it was knocked out.

 

[Elfforkusu]

Seemed EXACTLY like Rudolph's TD today, which they ruled a catch.

What do college football rules have to do with this?