You know, it's kind of funny, "sexiness" is more of a visceral function than an in depth one. I mean, is a model considered sexy even though all you have is a picture? But then what happens when you learn he's boring, cowardly, and indecisive? It also says something interesting socially about what role looks play with women, that as long as he's a nice piece of ass, she'd want to lay it as long as he's not abusive. The only reason Shu's not getting any is because he's not as sexually aggressive as a more interesting, brave, and decisive man would be to his harem.
Case and point: see Makoto from School Days. The entirety of his transformation has to do with him gaining confidence and a spine to wield it with, to
effect. So the real question is, what do you want? Would you rather an arrogant douche who is neither indecisive nor cowardly, or do you want the standard moron with APS? Or do you want someone presumably like you? Interesting implications all around either way.
Me too :3