pieatorium
Member
lol wow ok
-
Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!
Manga Discussion/News Thread |OT4| New Ch/Vols! - SEE FIRST POST FOR RULES!
- Thread starter mysticwhip
- Start date
- Status
That's because you've gone on record on straight up refusing to read any of my posts. There is no doubt that you're misreading everything I say, and if not, you're interpreting it differently than intended. If I say "Most people accept Robin is the most developed character in One Piece" I would ASSUME that people would realize I'm not talking about the masses. There is absolutely no reason to be using that point otherwise.
Angry Grimace
Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
I've love for you to find this record.
But really, nobody ever reads your posts right according to you. It's hilarious how every time you're proven wrong you go out of your way to speedpost to conform your old, incorrect statements with whatever information proved that wrong.
Fucking opinions m8te. I actually liked his character and despite Kishi's constant negligence he's a good character. He's been through some heavy shit, and his confrontation with his brother was meaningful (no matter how brief)
Again, it wasn't so much growth, Asuma was just a character tool to show how much they'e grown. With Chouji's newfound confidence and power (Choji was definitely not confident in himself right after Asuma died.) Did you forget that Kakashi was their replacement team leader? What the fuck did you expect, the 3 of them chasing against Kakuzu by themselves? Yes I am well aware the Kakuzu fight was shit, but you're livid if you think Ino and Choji in their current form could stand against Kakuzu and Kakashi is a jobber lol.
Again, I agree with this but I had no problem with Kishi finalizing Ino and Choji's character growth during the war arc. You're literally just nitpicking for the sake of nitpicking.
Its the opposite for me. I didn't really care for them interrupting Naruto's training arc (though for a good reason!)
Much prefer Naruto's moveset over seeing Neji or Lee?
Lol get over yourself bro. You'd much prefer seeing Neji or Lee as the main lead as opposed to Naruto? Ok thats fine, but outright implying that the 2 of them are significantly than Naruto is absurd. Have you fucking seen Naruto's jutsu list? Its massive. Yes many of them are Rasengan derivatives but he's a wide variety of "flash" and fun jutsu (including forms) that make his fights interesting. I recall you said you feel the same way about Sasuke. Lee only has Taijutsu and he's flat out inferior to Guy. (Unfortunately, this ends up making his character redundant battle-wise) as for Neji. I didn't like his fighting style upon inception and I sure as hell don't like it now. ((2 jutsus + taijutsu max)
Sasuke's "realization" was rushed, hamfisted bullshit. There is no indication that he gives a FUCK about Juugo, Karin or Suigetsu. I actually facepalmed when Kishi showed as that he did. Him disregarding them was one of the best decisions he's ever made. Naruto hyperventilating at the kage summit is my greatest bane. I couldn't defend it IF I TRIED, but Kishi rectifies this with positive character development that I addressed earlier. Chouji regressing? Um no, his actions and thoughts were perfectly normal (and expected) so I hardly see this as regression.
And the top it off, these minor "hiccups" are the main reason you think Part II Naruto is trash?
It's going to be difficult to find but I'm pretty positive you straight up refused to read my explanation for reading Naruto/Bleach despite explaining very clearly the reason after trying to make a point of, "WHY YOU READ NARUTO/BLEACH IF YOU THINK THEY SUCK?" Stat Flow can back me up on this one for sure.
Well I assume Wiseblade did not cause not a single one of those posts, in context, really used "It's popular so it must be right" argument. Matter of fact the statement was there more-so to display that I find it strange that there is an opposing opinion, rather than saying their opinion is irrelevant because "it's popular." I believe the first response was to someone saying Robin was paper-thin/cardboard cut out in response to my tier list.
pieatorium
Member
What the fuck. So by saying "most people" you actually don't mean most people and just the people who agree with what you say? How in the fuck is anyone supposed to read your mind across the internet to decipher that?
Much prefer Naruto's moveset over seeing Neji or Lee?
Neji and Lee have a moveset?
Angry Grimace
Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
See what I mean? Nothing actually means whatever it plainly says; he just changes the meaning of whatever he wrote to conform with whatever is later determined to be the most correct.
They are like the only characters to get a second arc to develop them.
Beside Usopp vs Luffy was an awesome fight
"Most people" is referring to manga critics, manga enthusiasts, true manga fans, aka people who come to this thread often. I assume everyone here fits in this critera, and hence, when I say "most people" I would assume there is no other way to take it but referring to this part of the fanbase. Similar in how saying most people consider Oldboy to be one of the best films of all time, but in that context would be referring to film fans rather than the masses.
It has nothing to do with disagreeing or agreeing with me whatsoever.
Glass Rebel
Member
Okay I guess I found the worst moment for this but I just finished Sanctuary. Fucking wow. I felt that the ending was a bit rushed but I guess it made sense in the story and I'm glad the author wasn't afraid to take such a route.. Fantastic read, absolutely recommended. Is there anything similar out there?
Angry Grimace
Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
We need to get God's Beard in here for manly hugs and discussion stat
Rebel Leader
THE POWER OF BUTTERSCOTCH BOTTOMS
Without chapters of WSJ, Thy go insane whilst walking though the abyss
----
I demand a TLR Darkness christmas chapter
----
I demand a TLR Darkness christmas chapter
God's Beard will be along shortly to provide your brohug.
How many times did you cry?
Anyway if you want something with manly tears, I think something like Kaiji is comparable?
I choose manga critic. It's time for my to ascend for my true purpose, GAF. Goodbye
Glass Rebel
Member
Wait, I'm
survivor said:
I cried several times. Lost count around the time Segawa died.
Tbh I didn't feel it that much when I read it. Also doesn't help that the art is absolutely atrocious.
Angry Grimace
Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
Sometimes, I miss that crazy bastard God's Beard and his "Hancock New Strawhat" troll
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/RageQuit
We had one. There was a color shot of Momo in a Santa costume and then a chapter with tail masturbation.
A true Christmas miracle.
Usopp is actually nothing like Rock Lee. Usopp (eventually) realizes his limitations and strengths. He finally understands his position in the crew and doesn't strive to be somebody he's not.
Rock Lee's the old "hardwork can surpass a genius" archetype, but kishi seems to have sidelined him hehe. (to be fair, he was sidelined as early as part I, after Gaara had to save his ass)
He really botched his character
Are you talking about Sai or Sasuke? Cause if it's the former then lol at you. If it's the latter then I got no problem
Yeah, having both Lee and Guy is really stupid. They are just bad clones of each other. And Neji's fighting style is pretty mediocre.
Usopp worked hard to overcome his coward act.Usopp is actually nothing like Rock Lee. Usopp (eventually) realizes his limitations and strengths. He finally understands his position in the crew and doesn't strive to be somebody he's not.
Rock Lee's the old "hardwork can surpass a genius" archetype, but kishi seems to have sidelined him hehe. (to be fair, he was sidelined as early as part I, after Gaara had to save his ass)
He really botched his character
Also Kishi ditched the hardwork shit cause it doesn't work. Everyone is a genius in Naruto
Angry Grimace
Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
Usopp is actually nothing like Rock Lee. Usopp (eventually) realizes his limitations and strengths. He finally understands his position in the crew and doesn't strive to be somebody he's not.
Rock Lee's the old "hardwork can surpass a genius" archetype, but kishi seems to have sidelined him hehe. (to be fair, he was sidelined as early as part I, after Gaara had to save his ass)
He really botched his character
See, this is why I prefer the Harry Potter magic scheme where nobody has an internal limitation on magic, it's all skill based.
Angry Grimace
Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
don't you read smut
So when I read Bakuman for the made up manga, are these shit too?
Angry Grimace
Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
Just saying, Voldemort being good at magic isn't implied to be because he has just has a high magic reserve, it's because he's a fucken genius
This.
He got foiled by a band of teenagers for 7 years in a row.
Harry only manages to get things done because PLOT ARMOR and Hermione carrying his and Ron's useless asses.
So what you are saying is that Hermione can kill Voldemort?
Angry Grimace
Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
Just sayin' bro, the number of graphically drawn fluids in a given series isn't commensurate with it's worth
That's a value judgment on JK Rowling's storywriting as opposed to the world building, which is what we are talking about.
peeps are born with natural skill in harry potter, shit is unfair from the start. Squibs, Nevilles, and girls.
the fuck you know brah
the fuck you know brah
Angry Grimace
Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
I don't agree with that at all. Neville sucked at magic because he had no confidence and was legitimately stupid. It's not so different as real life; some people ARE smarter and more talented than others, but it's not for a literal physical capacity to be good at say, electric guitar.
Let's not forget magic makes no sense in Rowlingverse whatsoever.
It's only slightly better than Tolkien magic in that there's some semblence of technique and logic behind it (except there really isn't and it's all an illusion.)
Some people are just better at math than others, or music, or art, or writing, etc.
There are genetic variations in brains as well as bodies.
Tolkienmagic is real magic. All mystical and eagles and shit.
No.
ooooooooooooooooooooo
dresden getting called out!
SONGS OF POWER.
RINGS OF POWER.
WORDS OF POWER.
SWORDS OF POWER.
POWER POWER POWER POWER POWER POWER.
I like how Luthien, not even a fucking maia, managed to put Melkor to sleep. Wtf hax.
I love The Lay of Beren and Luthien.
You kind of agree by default when you start your post with "So when I read Bakuman..." in response to "every manga you people read are shit."
With or without the penis shrooms?
Angry Grimace
Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
Hermione wasn't as talented as Voldemort and she didn't spend a lot of time studying dark magic, either.
It doesn't make sense in what regard? Because we aren't told how it explicitly works? Magic. The point is more that we're never told Voldemort or anything else got by on a physical capacity for magic which exceeded that of anyone else, he was just a twisted genius. In other words, no MP meters.
Lol, why would I care? Korean comic scene died with the censorship laws like a decade ago. It doesn't help that people seem intent on bringing the trashiest shit over, stuff like anything Im Dal Young, etc.
Stop hating on Bakuman. It's only shit when it's not about HiramaruYou kind of agree by default when you start your post with "So when I read Bakuman..." in response to "every manga you people read are shit."
pfft, Hermione is the smartest person alive in the Potter universe
In that there is no sensible explanation for how arbitrary wand movements and words in faux-latin can have a 1-1 correlation with spells.
Hermione was so overpowered.
So like, the entire manga?
- Status