• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Manga Discussion/News Thread |OT4| New Ch/Vols! - SEE FIRST POST FOR RULES!

Status
Not open for further replies.
i don't know if this is the right place but... gaf, advise me on the greatest japanese graphic novels

these are currently my favorites:

devilman
buddha (tezuka)
coo world
barefoot gen
captain harlock
dragonhead
sanctuary
pushman and other stories
nausicaa

thanks!

Harukana Machi-E and other stuff by the same author, Taniguchi Jiro.
 
i don't know if this is the right place but... gaf, advise me on the greatest japanese graphic novels

these are currently my favorites:

devilman
buddha (tezuka)
coo world
barefoot gen
captain harlock
dragonhead
sanctuary
pushman and other stories
nausicaa

thanks!

Well you seem like you have similar enough taste to me so I'm just going to recommend stuff from my favourite authors.

Daisuke Igarashi: Witches, Children of the Sea

Iou Kuroda: Japan Tengu Party Illustrated, Nasu, Sexy Voice and Robo

Taiyou Matsumoto: Tekkon Kinkreet, Ping Pong, Takemitsu Zamurai, Hanaotoko

Inio Asano: Solanin, Goodnight Punpun, Nijigahara Holograph, A Girl by the Sea

Fumiyo Kouno: Town of Evening Calm, Country of Cherry Blossoms

Jiro Matsumoto: Freesia, Velveteen & Mandala, Uncivilized Planet

I could go on (this is what happens when I go on), but that is probably too much already.
 
Full Ahead! Coco vol 2

Yeah, this is totally One Piece with a slightly more traditional pirate crew.

Looks like things are really gonna start now and we'll probably get a timeskip.
 
So does this manga have some sort of conclusion? It has been like 8 years since volume 2 and I doubt that the dude even cares about ending it.

Yeah it was clearly canned or just abandoned. I don't really mind because I think his efforts are better spent elsewhere, but what really is a shame is that he barely makes manga anymore.
 
Ivan is his only son, and he is the head of Raven Tail. I am not sure why MS called him Ewen. Laxus is his grand son.

MS are just using the official names, i.e. Jellal


300 was a pretty terrible movie and wasn't THAT epic, it's just a joke calm down
You shouldn't have even told him this as a joke. 300 is terrible and not epic at all unless you're a bro who calls a basket of chicken wings "epic."

Beelzebub cracked me the fuck up this week.
 
Miri, bro, the Queen is back and she's better than before.

Dresden, my bro, your taste in waifus is as bad as ever.

It's funny you mention this series because I randomly just started reading it -- like, literally a few hours ago -- and really like it. I also decided to look into the series a little bit and found out two things:
- the whole thing is about 160 chapters long and the scanlator is dedicated, so it will actually be fully translated (a rarity, really)
- when I say "dedicated", I mean that ONE PERSON has been working on EVERYTHING related to this series, from chapter one, for almost two years. That is either obsession, insanity, or perhaps both. Though it does sound like he's never gonna try that ever again.

It's actually funny that you mention this, cause it was just the other day that I was thinking that this is the quite possibly the most consistent of mangas when it comes to translations. To hear that one guy does it all himself is nuts. It's almost every couple days that a release hits, and sometimes even chapters at a time.

But as for the manga itself, yeah, it's incredible. So personable. So inspirational. I don't want to see it end, but I have to, and the ending is going to hit me hard. I can feel it.

If only Bartender got the same love, scans wise.
 
Itsuwaribito Utsuho vol 2

At the end of the first volume I dreaded the battles with lies could become boring, but the second volume had me rethink that. The battles are still pretty cool and engaging and the use of lies to fuck with the enemies is just as strong as it was in the first volume.
I also enjoyed seeing Utsuho falling for someone else's lies, and the way he coped with it. It was really laugh worthy.
Anyone else reading this?
 
Fairy Tail 267
tumblr_ly4gg0a8am1qf72s6o1_500.jpg

Utterly epic chapter. Blue Pegasus was awesome too, Hibiki and Eve, and then Lamia Scale with Lyon and the wave magic user, Yuka. Oh and then guild with that cool guildmaster, Goldmine.
300px-Goldmine.jpg


So many favorites in one chapter. Glad Mashima left it open to introduce an entirely new guild though, it would be nice if all the favorites got to work together to team up to defeat some dark foe this arc, even with Jellal to join in too. Gajeel should have shown up to take Elfman's place for Wendy.
 
Itsuwaribito Utsuho vol 2

At the end of the first volume I dreaded the battles with lies could become boring, but the second volume had me rethink that. The battles are still pretty cool and engaging and the use of lies to fuck with the enemies is just as strong as it was in the first volume.
I also enjoyed seeing Utsuho falling for someone else's lies, and the way he coped with it. It was really laugh worthy.
Anyone else reading this?


I was gonna say no one is reading this cause it's probably one of those Italy only manga then I realized Viz picked this up.

I might pick it up on my next manga shopping haul
 
lol

i think, me, Kreed and a few others still have "Reach Elf island" on our lists to cross off
We're in the very least in the arc where it's gonna take place so it very close.

Miura's comment about the God Hand is very interesting cause if valid it should mean that we're going to see the origin of each of the God Hand in the series sometime soon...which means, in the next year, which is good by Berserk time!

Miura also comments that he's practically keeping himself alive (which kind of falls in place with him losing a crapload of weight a while back) to continue to publish the series.
 
Fairy Tail

Oh yeah, the tournament is finally started after all of this time. Shit's about to get real .-.
I like the FT outfits (barring Erza's, why is it so fanservicy :9) and the other guild opponent look good. Calling it, that ditzy girl will be a top tier fighter.

PS: Fuck yeah, it looks like Wendy will compete eventually.

PS2 : Did that one Pegasus guild member admit to being a pedo ?_?
 
I want to go watch Brook's flash back right now. It was quick but beautiful. One of my favorites.

I've been rereading Thriller Bark because it's the second best One Piece arc after Skypeia.

"Why is it... I know it's possible he isn't waiting. He had the right to leave. But if by some chance he believed in our promise, and has always been waiting for us... How lonely would he feel right now? He might think we had betrayed him. But if he continued to wait for us even now, how strong his feelings might be! I can't help but feel that he believed in us all this time, and that we would come back, and like always we would play our cheerful music while waving our arms out to him. I don't think he would forgive us because we died irresponsibly, and because of our selfish promise he would yell into the skies if his voice could reach us... THAT DEATH ISN'T AN APOLOGY! BECAUSE A MAN ONCE SAID... THAT THEY WOULD ABSOLUTELY RETURN!"
 
Fairy Tail

Oh yeah, the tournament is finally started after all of this time. Shit's about to get real .-.
I like the FT outfits (barring Erza's, why is it so fanservicy :9) and the other guild opponent look good. Calling it, that ditzy girl will be a top tier fighter.

PS: Fuck yeah, it looks like Wendy will compete eventually.

PS2 : Did that one Pegasus guild member admit to being a pedo ?_?

Who is the pedo?
 
The Breaker: New Waves

You guys need to quit fronting. I can't be the only one reading this gloriously bad pile of panels.

I don't know why the manga expects me to suddenly sympathize with OG after painting him as an obsessive dictator of the clan, and opressor of Jinie, but whatevs; The dude brings serious heat when in the streets, so that counts for something. Whoop. Whoop.
 
The Breaker: New Waves

You guys need to quit fronting. I can't be the only one reading this gloriously bad pile of panels.

I don't know why the manga expects me to suddenly sympathize with OG after painting him as an obsessive dictator of the clan, and opressor of Jinie, but whatevs; The dude brings serious heat when in the streets, so that counts for something. Whoop. Whoop.

I read it too. More Manga for me to read weekly is always welcome.
 
The Breaker: New Waves

You guys need to quit fronting. I can't be the only one reading this gloriously bad pile of panels.

I don't know why the manga expects me to suddenly empathize with OG after painting him as an obsessive dictator of the clan, and opressor of Jinie, but whatevs; The dude brings serious heat when in the streets, so that counts for something. Whoop. Whoop.
The MC needs a power fix. Just knowing that after this he's gonna go back to his hobbled weak self bothers me.

On another note, I mat be the only one in the world, but I really miss veritas. Random battles, nonsensical plots, and a main character who was mostly ignored? It was crazy, but I want more of it
 
The MC needs a power fix. Just knowing that after this he's gonna go back to his hobbled weak self bothers me.

You ain't kidding. Still, it's better than basically resetting the whole manga again, I guess. We get a bunch of little bumps in the road instead of a cliff to drive ourselves off of, if that analogy works.
 
Full Ahead! Coco vol 4

Looks like special abilities are finally starting to appear in the form of transforming animal weapon arm attachment things. Hope Coco and the gang get one soon.
 
Plastic Girl vol 1 END

I need to start reading more shoujo manga. They are all happy and fluffy and cute. Can't be worse than half of the other shit I read.

Vz8jn.png


Maya had a lot of funny faces throughout the entire volume. This Pierre is truly a gentleman. He is always saving the day, his eyes alone makes girls faint, and he is freaking French. Dude is a master at picking up girls. Shoujo men really have it easy. The whole model agency crap was alright. Probably just an excuse to get more poses out of Pierre since the dude always come at the end to save the disaster caused by Maya.

Overall it was an enjoyable manga. I don't care much for believable romance plot in shoujo manga but this one didn't feel stupid cause it was so short. They were already kissing by chapter 3.
 
Overall it was an enjoyable manga. I don't care much for believable romance plot in shoujo manga but this one didn't feel stupid cause it was so short. They were already kissing by chapter 3.
Out of curiosity, how does one define this? What makes something "believable" as opposed to otherwise?
 
Out of curiosity, how does one define this? What makes something "believable" as opposed to otherwise?

They're totally unbelievable btw. They're just unbelievable in a different way than shonen. For example, in shojo the chick just gets a super hot guy despite being unassuming or possibly having glasses and a pony tail, and this happens relatively early, but in shonen the lead just accumulates a massive harem and never resolves it.
 
The MC needs a power fix. Just knowing that after this he's gonna go back to his hobbled weak self bothers me.

On another note, I mat be the only one in the world, but I really miss veritas. Random battles, nonsensical plots, and a main character who was mostly ignored? It was crazy, but I want more of it

I kinda feel the same way. It wasn't good, but . . . I liked Vera. :( Sexhair maximum.
 
Kissing Mars

Found this to be quite good. It's a josei, and mostly handles the lives of two girls, one who has never had a boyfriend and another who has had some and is currently in a relationship with an university student, who starts off not liking each other, and after a certain situation ends up spending time together and becoming really close friends.
What i liked is the way the two girls were handled, their interactions and how that, little by little, made Yukari, the more experienced girl, start to change and, in the end, realize her feelings.
I also liked the character art.
It was a mature and touching story, and I suggest anyone who likes josei and never read it, to give it a look, since there's a scanlation for it.
 
Full Ahead! Coco vol 5

Yep, that squirrel is totally a changeling and Coco is gonna use it to fight!

Unfortunately, I am running out of chapters :(. Seriously, someone needs to pick this back up.
 
Full Ahead! Coco

Oh man, what a shitty place for the translations to run out at :(. Alice's weapon form is awesome. The way they merge with the user's skin is really cool and I'm sure we'll get to see some unique ones down the line.

I seriously need to stop starting series that haven't had a translated chapter in over a year or so.
 
Any good no-bullshit mage-manga? I don't like Negima and Magico isn't exactly what I'm looking for.

Dorohedoro. :)

Summary: In a city so dismal it’s known only as “the Hole,” a clan of sorcerers have been plucking people off the streets to use as guinea pigs for atrocious “experiments” in the black arts. In a dark alley, Nikaido found Kaiman, a man with a reptile head and a bad case of amnesia. To undo the spell, they’re hunting and killing the sorcerers of the Hole, hoping that eventually they’ll kill the right one. But when En, the head sorcerer, gets word of a lizard–man slaughtering his people, he sends a crew of “cleaners” into the Hole, igniting a war between two worlds.
 
TWGOK

Wait, so if he wants Chihiro in on everything, why not just explain why he flipped her off (and, uh, apologize).


Anagle Mole

H1cjT.png


:lol come on


edit: caught up on Anagle Mole

Shit got real. I could have enjoyed some more SoL but this is great too.

So anyway I love this. It's really cool. Fukuchi doesn't screw around.
 
Plastic Girl vol 1 END

I need to start reading more shoujo manga. They are all happy and fluffy and cute. Can't be worse than half of the other shit I read.

I read like 5 times as much shoujo and josei as I do shonen stuff. Read Koukou Debut next time you want a new one. It's hilarious and one of my favorites.
 
Plastic Girl vol 1 END

I need to start reading more shoujo manga. They are all happy and fluffy and cute. Can't be worse than half of the other shit I read.
You are saying this NOW? I don't think you let me get away with one shoujo post without calling me out. lol
Out of curiosity, how does one define this? What makes something "believable" as opposed to otherwise?
Lovely Complex is believable and by no coincidence my favorite shoujo.
 
Out of curiosity, how does one define this? What makes something "believable" as opposed to otherwise?
Well I don't read that many shoujo manga so I'm not expert on this matter. But I find the whole "kissing is forbidden" shit or "the male MC is perfect in every way" to be unbelievable. I'd much rather believe the overly sexual romance manga like A Girl by the Sea over the other shoujo that treat holding a hand as a sacred thing and takes you ages to get a confession.

Haha for a second there I thought you were talking about this Plastic Girl (I have images turned off) and your description was just very sarcastic or something.
I was actually gonna read that instead but I decided to hold on it until I do my Usamaru Furuya marathon.

I read like 5 times as much shoujo and josei as I do shonen stuff. Read Koukou Debut next time you want a new one. It's hilarious and one of my favorites.
Oh it's actually a complete manga? yeah sure I will read it.

You are saying this NOW? I don't think you let me get away with one shoujo post without calling me out. lol

Lovely Complex is believable and by no coincidence my favorite shoujo.
Will read Lovely Complex too since it's finished.
 
Well I don't read that many shoujo manga so I'm not expert on this matter. But I find the whole "kissing is forbidden" shit or "the male MC is perfect in every way" to be unbelievable. I'd much rather believe the overly sexual romance manga like A Girl by the Sea over the other shoujo that treat holding a hand as a sacred thing and takes you ages to get a confession.
That is a tough one. Basically there are three types of shoujo, fantasy, fantasy reality, and reality. The main one to understand is the fantasy reality area. These manga are set in reality but are totally unrealistic. Sub-plots include gifted student facilities, everyone is billionaires, male MC is absolutely perfect, etc... If you read fantasy reality shoujo expecting realistic scenarios, you will only grief yourself.

There are a lot of recommendations to be made but if any of those areas bug you, then a lot can be crossed off. Sadly, I would say the reality shoujo is few and far between. Or at least leans very close to fantasy reality most of the time.

EDIT:
I was just playin with the first part of my last post BTW.
 
"Believable" isn't a concept I'm familiar with on anything I read to be honest.
Lovely Complex is a good one though
 
TWGOK

Not that Chihiro is going to believe Keima anyways.

RageTown

So based on the dialogue of recent chapters, my guess the only real reason for this to continue to exist is for Haruto to fuck Yuzuki, but he's not even making an effort for no apparent reason.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom