• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Manga Discussion/News Thread |OT4| New Ch/Vols! - SEE FIRST POST FOR RULES!

Status
Not open for further replies.

9CseZ.png
 
"I loathe One Piece because it's silly, but Bleach is awesome because of it's seriousness."

True story.

Ah ... hm.

It may be terribly worded but ... isn't that kind of right? I mean, One Piece is a lot more whimsical and less rigid and strict compared to Bleach, though I find that is part of the charm of One Piece (and, really, what makes it work so well).
 
Ah ... hm.

It may be terribly worded but ... isn't that kind of right? I mean, One Piece is a lot more whimsical and less rigid and strict compared to Bleach, though I find that is part of the charm of One Piece (and, really, what makes it work so well).

The irony is that Bleach is infinitely more silly than One Piece because it fails at being serious.
 
Ah ... hm.

It may be terribly worded but ... isn't that kind of right? I mean, One Piece is a lot more whimsical and less rigid and strict compared to Bleach, though I find that is part of the charm of One Piece (and, really, what makes it work so well).

I don't know why shadow is picking on AdrianWerner. Not everyone has to like over the top aspects of One Piece.


The irony is that Bleach is infinitely more silly than One Piece because it fails at being serious.
It doesn't matter if Bleach does serious and fails or what not. One Piece by design is supposed to be more silly than Bleach. And if you can't handle that then it's expected that you won't like the manga
 
I don't know why shadow is picking on AdrianWerner. Not everyone has to like over the top aspects of One Piece.



It doesn't matter if Bleach does serious and fails or what not. One Piece by design is supposed to be more silly than Bleach. And if you can't handle that then it's expected that you won't like the manga

Uh, yeah, and Bleach manages to be sillier through sucking.

WHY ME SAD.
 
The irony is that Bleach is infinitely more silly than One Piece because it fails at being serious.

But it's a different silly. It's not the zany antics and whimsy kind of silly that One Piece is. It's /facepalm at bad direction silly or something along those lines. Good or bad, enjoy it or loathe it, those are design descriptors of the two. How they work doesn't really matter since that's rather subjective.

I don't know why shadow is picking on AdrianWerner. Not everyone has to like over the top aspects of One Piece.

GODA etc.
 
How about we all just agree that Silver Spoon is fantastic?

Constantly both funny and with a degree of seriousness to it.

Hiromu Arakawa always does the funny faces in serious moments so well. Not that many manga can pull it off that well.


Uh, yeah, and Bleach manages to be sillier through sucking.

WHY ME SAD.
Look, if you think Bleach is silly cause it sucks and shit like why me sad then that's fine. But you really can't ignore that One Piece has a different art style and way of telling stories that might seem over the top to some people.
 
Do we really need to go over this again .
Plus i don't find bleach to be serious at all, in fact almost all shonen have there serious parts but at the end of the day they all about beating the odds.
 
Heh, he was known as (ペイン, Pein) in the Japanese version, and thats how I like to refer to him as.

I truly, and honestly don't care about your opinion.
Actually, his name was "Pain" in the Japanese version too; "Pein" is a transliteration.

It was intended to both be and evoke the english word "Pain." His name is Pain and we will continue to make fun of you if you call him Pein, whether you care about it or not.
 
Actually, his name was "Pain" in the Japanese version too; "Pein" is a transliteration.

It was intended to both be and evoke the english word "Pain." His name is Pain and we will continue to make fun of you if you call him Pein, whether you care about it or not.

I still think Rokku Ri and Maito Gai would pulverise Pein, any Shuu no Hi.
 
Its been a while since this thread has had the Pein/Pain argument.


Actually, his name was "Pain" in the Japanese version too; "Pein" is a transliteration.

It was intended to both be and evoke the english word "Pain." His name is Pain and we will continue to make fun of you if you call him Pein, whether you care about it or not.

Grimace just does not give a fuck. lol
 
Buddha
Kinda reminds me of Adolf right now,two friends, one goes off to the military to possibly be corrupted and the other stays behind and helps the family.
 
Oh shit. We got some tough guys in this motherfucker. Hope this AdrianWerner dude comes to join ManGAF.
Do you post in AnimeGAF? I know some of the regulars do

Man I kinda want some ManGAF anime discussion or something since I can't really go in there. Watched Madoka yesterday too, but what can I do
 
Buddha
9p6XK.jpg


bwhaha

Also, holy shit at tatta nonchalantly getting swallowed by a snake. I thought he had some sorta escape plan, nope. luckily he had some random outta nowhere dude kill it in time.
 
Oh shit. We got some tough guys in this motherfucker. Hope this AdrianWerner dude comes to join ManGAF.

No need all we going to get is another bleach vs OP fight from what i read on the last 3 pages of that thread .
I rather the regulars go at it again if that going to happen .

EDIT i see beam is over there now for bleach in that thread lol .
EDIT even Angry Grimace is talking we only need big one now and all is right .
 
Pein is a fucking stupid name.

Pein is a fucking awesome name.

Do you call One Piece 'Wan Piisu' too?

FUCK no.

Actually, his name was "Pain" in the Japanese version too; "Pein" is a transliteration.

It was intended to both be and evoke the english word "Pain." His name is Pain and we will continue to make fun of you if you call him Pein, whether you care about it or not.

Right, thanks for the clarification, i'll totally call him Pain from now on! Angry Grimace, you are mistaken if you think i'm childish enough to resort to ignoring everyone in this thread "simply because they're teasing."

You know, all in good fun? Stage On decided (on a whim) to take it one step further by calling it me out due to his (frankly) unsound and misinformed assumption. His post simply had the appeal of a paper cut. I really can't stand snide self indulgent posts like that.

Grimace just does not give a fuck. lol

It's cool. I couldn't care less
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=om7O0MFkmpw
 
No need all we going to get is another bleach vs OP fight from what i read on the last 3 pages of that thread .
I rather the regulars go at it again if that going to happen .

EDIT i see beam is over there now for bleach in that thread lol.

He started pulling the Bleach is deep cause of these quotes. He is going all out.


Do you post in AnimeGAF? I know some of the regulars do

Man I kinda want some ManGAF anime discussion or something since I can't really go in there. Watched Madoka yesterday too, but what can I do
what episode are you on?
 
what episode are you on?
Marathoned it all yesterday after I took a break from ep3

http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?t=419458&page=83

its quiet though bar any annoucements (iirc they have other madoka animated stuff in the works plus you can check out the different mangas)
I, um, I already read the mangas too *blush*

But I dunno they're doing stuff like studio and director talks, meh. Guess I'll check it out when I've recovered (Toradora took me a month so this could take two before I'm able to hear the OST again)
 
Marathoned it all yesterday after I took a break from ep3

Lucky. You didn't have to wait a month for the last 2 episodes. These times were hell :(

Silver Spoon

Pretty great chapter. Is this manga still going to rotate through the seasons? It just seems that summertime been going on for too long for a supposedly short manga.
 
Lucky. You didn't have to wait a month for the last 2 episodes. These times were hell :(
I'd rather have been "unlucky" enough to be able to watch anime back then (speaking of which I also quit Silver Spoon around then too because I was so bitter)! :( But I guess I did dodge a bullet.



Anyway guys it's an emergency. I just got informed I'm doing two night shift weeks in a row next-next-week, and my wishlist is full of <20 chapter manga. I'm in deep shit so I need recommendations asap. Readlist here (so far got Aiki, Sankarea, Iris Zero and Curry)
 
Oh shit. We got some tough guys in this motherfucker. Hope this AdrianWerner dude comes to join ManGAF.
That guy.. doesn't even know what he's talking about....
Do you post in AnimeGAF? I know some of the regulars do

Man I kinda want some ManGAF anime discussion or something since I can't really go in there. Watched Madoka yesterday too, but what can I do

I think it's ok if you do some anime discussion in here as long as you spoiler it, there's some people scared or don't like the manga thread and they post their manga impressions in the anime thread.

Anyway guys it's an emergency. I just got informed I'm doing two night shift weeks in a row next-next-week, and my wishlist is full of <20 chapter manga. I'm in deep shit so I need recommendations asap. Readlist here (so far got Aiki, Sankarea, Iris Zero and Curry)

What are you looking to read bro? I'd try Alive: The Final Evolution for action , Bamboo Blade for slice of life / comedy.
 
Anyway guys it's an emergency. I just got informed I'm doing two night shift weeks in a row next-next-week, and my wishlist is full of <20 chapter manga. I'm in deep shit so I need recommendations asap. Readlist here (so far got Aiki, Sankarea, Iris Zero and Curry)

I don't see Historie or Vagabond in that list. you'll like those if you enjoy vinland saga. Also you might like Angel Densetsu, Sanctuary or Dorohedoro.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom