COMICS! August l OT l So what's new with comics?

Status
Not open for further replies.

rCIZZLE

Member
New 52 is a fantastic place to start. Of the Batman books I'd recommend Batman and Batman Incorporated. Detective Comics has been pretty bad but it might be turning around with #13 in September due to a new writer. Haven't really followed the other books in the Batman universe so can't speak for them.
 

K-19

Banned
I"m not sure if that's the right thread for this, but I will try anyway.
After watching Dark Knight Rises I got massive Batman boner, that doesn't seem to be going away anytime soon, even after second visit to the cinema and replaying the whole damn Arkham City. So I decided to go back to Batman comics.

I've read all the classics, so what I'm interested is following regular and current series. But I see there are like half a dozen regular series :] Are they all interconected or can I stick to only some of them? What's a good point to start with modern batman? New 52?


The Batman relaunch (new 52) Snyder/Capullo is a MUST HAVE. The Batman: The Court Of Owls
 
The main Batman titles are stand-alone series. Just order this for now:

http://www.amazon.com/dp/1401235417/?tag=neogaf0e-20

Or try to go to a comic shop or website and pick up the Batman issues of Scott Snyder's Batman series.

Detective Comics and The Dark Knight are going through creative changes and show promise, but regular Batman is consistently good.

Agreed, Scott Snyder is awesome. A shame that volume 2 will a long wait though. 7 fucking months..

EDIT: Preview for Batman 12# looks great: http://www.dccomics.com/galleries/batman-12-preview
 

NawidA

Banned
I"m not sure if that's the right thread for this, but I will try anyway.
After watching Dark Knight Rises I got massive Batman boner, that doesn't seem to be going away anytime soon, even after second visit to the cinema and replaying the whole damn Arkham City. So I decided to go back to Batman comics.

I've read all the classics, so what I'm interested is following regular and current series. But I see there are like half a dozen regular series :] Are they all interconected or can I stick to only some of them? What's a good point to start with modern batman? New 52?
I'm not a big fan but everyone else seems to like Batman (the main series starting with the #1). Other than that, some like Batman and Robin, but I find Tomasi subpar.

I think you should start Morrison's run. The beginning of it just got collected in a big hardcover for pretty cheap (and I and others have posted reading orders before).

For deeper cuts, I always hear that the Brubaker/Rucka/Dixon era was phenomenal.
 

Garryk

Member
Word Balloon with Matt Fraction

This is a good listen if you have some time. Fraction says that David Aja is doing the first 3 issues, then Javier Pulido will do 4-5, and Aja will be back. Says Wacker is continuing his efforts to keep top artists on his titles (Punisher, Spider-Mans, Daredevil). Majority of stories will be self-contained, but 4-5 will be a two-parter.

Fraction is always fun to listen to, as opposed to read. Guy has a great sense of humor.
 
Word Balloon with Matt Fraction

This is a good listen if you have some time. Fraction says that David Aja is doing the first 3 issues, then Javier Pulido will do 4-5, and Aja will be back. Says Wacker is continuing his efforts to keep top artists on his titles (Punisher, Spider-Mans, Daredevil). Majority of stories will be self-contained, but 4-5 will be a two-parter.

Fraction is always fun to listen to, as opposed to read. Guy has a great sense of humor.

That editor has that shit on lock down. Too bad the X editors suck and let anyone with a Deviantart account ruin the sanctity of the franchise.
 
Steve Wacker may be a dick online, but he's one hell of an editor. Kept 52 coming out every single week, even with four different writers and multiple artists, kept ASM coming out pretty much 3 times a month for Brand New Day, and he scheduled the HELL out of Spider-Island. I've never seen such consistency, continuity and timely releases between event issues and tie-ins. And more often then not, he's got some impeccable taste in artists. Rios, Martin, Rivera, Bachalo, Caselli, etc
 
Wouldn't that be potentially catastrophic? "Hey, welcome to the future, you starry eyed kids! Let's talk about the Phoenix, shall we? Jean, it's gonna make you eat a star, cause your clone to summon the devil, force an alien race to viciously slaughter your entire family oh, and in the end, you'll die because of it! Scott, the Phoenix is going to literally force you to stop loving Jean, then it'll grant you a fifth of it's cosmic power and turn you into the kind of megalomaniacal madman you've been fighting! Hank, the Phoenix is going to totally wreck your face and destroy your empire!"
They're not going to be going back or anything; the original five will be here to stay. Time travel shenanigans, creating alternate timelines, etc. etc.
 
The Batman relaunch (new 52) Snyder/Capullo is a MUST HAVE. The Batman: The Court Of Owls
New 52 is a fantastic place to start. Of the Batman books I'd recommend Batman and Batman Incorporated. Detective Comics has been pretty bad but it might be turning around with #13 in September due to a new writer. Haven't really followed the other books in the Batman universe so can't speak for them.
Court of the Owls was fucking fantastic and I'm now hooked on Batman comics. Great story!
 
Guess I'll be skipping the Daredevil annual since it seems completely separated from Waid's run and I have no idea what a ClanDestine is.
 
Finally got around to reading the run of Saga so far and all I have to say is 'wow'. Such a fantastic and immersive experience. Up there with Chew for my favorite art in recent memory.

A million times this. As good as the story is, the art is even better.
 

Garryk

Member
Eh, DD Annual is part 2 of a 3-part story that crosses F4, DD, and Wolverine annuals. At $4.99 a pop, it's a nice little cash grab by Marvel.
 

Owzers

Member
i have no ties to Clandestine and i spend too much on comics, easy decision to avoid all those annuals.

Regarding Space Punisher, i passed that one up Xp.

Getting caught up on FF/Fantastic Four now that i have a few issues stored up, FF #18 was a whole lot of fun. Hickman's run on Fantastic Four/FF has been amazing, even if i had some problems with the pacing after the death issue, it's still great. Bring on an omnibus.
 

MisterHero

Super Member
So what was the consensus on Batman Earth One?
I liked it. Gary Frank's art is always great. Batman's origin story has slight twists but they don't really affect a whole lot. The most divergent characters, Alfred and Bullock, are complete and interesting characters. The story just doesn't give them a lot of time.

I don't know what to expand on, really. The book felt really brief.
 
What do people think of the new knightfall/quest/send collections that have just been released? Plus do you think they will be collected into one big collection eventually? x
 

Dan

No longer boycotting the Wolfenstein franchise
What do people think of the new knightfall/quest/send collections that have just been released? Plus do you think they will be collected into one big collection eventually? x

I revisited Knightfall and it was entertaining. Bane wasn't nearly as intelligent as people have said though.

Hell no. It would be like 2100 pages.
 
Hey, that's --

*looks at latest Wolverine & The X-Men*

Oh god damn it

Brah it's just I'm still fucking really pissed about Uncanny and X force. Tochinni, Land, who the hell are these brahs. And I dont read WATXM since AvX, since as you said writing is the most important part regarding comics.
 

Owzers

Member
Fantastic Four 605.1 was fun, but i really didn't care for 606. On to more issues!

Oh, and the art rotation on this book is still ridiculous, it's like they are trying to make sure everyone who isn't a top artist at Marvel draws an issue of the book between this and FF.
 
Fantastic Four 605.1 was fun, but i really didn't care for 606. On to more issues!

Oh, and the art rotation on this book is still ridiculous, it's like they are trying to make sure everyone who isn't a top artist at Marvel draws an issue of the book between this and FF.

Amazing how FF has survived with D List talent. Interested to here what Fraction's plans for FF are. Aaron's comments on Thor didn't really impress me, brah couldn't handle two personalities on the Hulk but will have three with Thor. Nice.


And Instock Trades is slow as hell at shipping orders.
 
Amazing how FF has survived with D List talent. Interested to here what Fraction's plans for FF are. Aaron's comments on Thor didn't really impress me, brah couldn't handle two personalities on the Hulk but will have three with Thor. Nice.

it's like some kind of wild dimension where Stay Angry never existed.
 
And Instock Trades is slow as hell at shipping orders.

I ordered my brick of Hellboy/BPRD trades Saturday night and they arrived today. Fantastic packaging, too.

LbwIn.jpg
 

BJK

Member
Catching up with last week...

Reading Fraction's Hawkeye #1 feels like cheating on the Jim McCann (mini-) series Marvel cancelled last year. Aside from the obvious logical conundrum
If Clint has $12.5 million to throw around, why is he renting an apartment in Bed Stuy?
it made for a good read. I've been enjoying Fraction's Iron Man run thusfar, and I'll definitely keep reading Hawkeye. Aja's artwork looks beautiful.


It took awhile for AvX to pick-up, but I'm amazed how quickly things have sped up in the past 2 issues. AvX # 9 stunned me in how quickly the Phoenix Four are losing their fight against the Phoenix Force. While I've never liked the idea of White Queen as one of the good guys, her fall plays out as downright tragic. And Spidey=Man. ('Nuff Said)
 
Catching up with last week...

Reading Fraction's Hawkeye #1 feels like cheating on the Jim McCann (mini-) series Marvel cancelled last year. Aside from the obvious logical conundrum
If Clint has $12.5 million to throw around, why is he renting an apartment in Bed Stuy?
it made for a good read. I've been enjoying Fraction's Iron Man run thusfar, and I'll definitely keep reading Hawkeye. Aja's artwork looks beautiful.


It took awhile for AvX to pick-up, but I'm amazed how quickly things have sped up in the past 2 issues. AvX # 9 stunned me in how quickly the Phoenix Four are losing their fight against the Phoenix Force. While I've never liked the idea of White Queen as one of the good guys, her fall plays out as downright tragic. And Spidey=Man. ('Nuff Said)

Cuz he's a true New Yorker brah, he wants to live in bad areas and then gentrify the place.



Instock Trades brah, I ordered my crap the same time and is still just chilling there. Guess brahs don't order Books of Magic everyday.
 
Damn I can't believe we're gonna wait another two months for Rotworld to continue. Things were just getting starting after a 12 issue build-up.

I guess there are worse things than leaving you wanting more.
 

CorvoSol

Member
They'll probably just feed the teenagers pizza, it is a Bendis book after all.

The more I think about it, the more I just CAN'T see it ending well no matter what you do.

Jean: "So, I see how Scott, Hank, Prof. X, Bobby and Warren are doing, but where am I?"
"Oh, you're uh, dead?"
"How did I die?"
"Magneto killed you. Only, it wasn't actually Magneto. It was Xorn. Except it wasn't actually Xorn, it was Xorne. Maybe."
"Can I at least go and see my family?"
"Yeaaaaaaaaaaaaah. About that."

Like, seriously, if Dark Phoenix wasn't a problem BEFORE, when Jean was a relatively innocent girl, imagine how dangerous she would be knowing that at some inevitable date in the future she and her entire family would be slaughtered and none of the people who loved her did anything about it. Not Scott, not Hank, not anyone.

There just is no way that bringing teenage Jean to the present shouldn't be catastrophic.
 
The more I think about it, the more I just CAN'T see it ending well no matter what you do.

Jean: "So, I see how Scott, Hank, Prof. X, Bobby and Warren are doing, but where am I?"
"Oh, you're uh, dead?"
"How did I die?"
"Magneto killed you. Only, it wasn't actually Magneto. It was Xorn. Except it wasn't actually Xorn, it was Xorne. Maybe."
"Can I at least go and see my family?"
"Yeaaaaaaaaaaaaah. About that."

Like, seriously, if Dark Phoenix wasn't a problem BEFORE, when Jean was a relatively innocent girl, imagine how dangerous she would be knowing that at some inevitable date in the future she and her entire family would be slaughtered and none of the people who loved her did anything about it. Not Scott, not Hank, not anyone.

There just is no way that bringing teenage Jean to the present shouldn't be catastrophic.

And that's not even as bad as what's going to happen with the redundant originals. Young Jean at least has something to do. What is Bendis really going to do with another Iceman and another Angel? "Oh hey young Bobby, why don't you just go off and be in the background somewhere with modern Bobby while Wolverine does something in the foreground." What's the purpose of them even being around?
 

Parallax

best seen in the classic "Shadow of the Beast"
And that's not even as bad as what's going to happen with the redundant originals. Young Jean at least has something to do. What is Bendis really going to do with another Iceman and another Angel? "Oh hey young Bobby, why don't you just go off and be in the background somewhere with modern Bobby while Wolverine does something in the foreground." What's the purpose of them even being around?

They're gonna strap a bandana to bobbys head and put him on the young xmen team. Same with hank and angel.
 
I revisited Knightfall and it was entertaining. Bane wasn't nearly as intelligent as people have said though.

Hell no. It would be like 2100 pages.

I'll snap it up then. thanks. So I'm guessing Knightfall is the famous Bane story? The one where he does something to somebody.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom