• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Magic: The Gathering |OT|

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yea pretty much.

Image.ashx
I see your Sharazad and raise you an Ambiguity!

Image.ashx


I wish they would print stuff that is as crazy as that again. Just not that cheap as hell. Is that the most text that's ever been on a card?
Nope.

Image.ashx


Image.ashx


Image.ashx


Image.ashx
 
If I already have ~200 cards, should I buy a Deckbuilder's Toolkit?

I wouldn't. If you want a playable deck instantly I would buy the Creep and Conquer Event deck. If you want to build a deck I would buy a fat pack OR even better I would draft if you have access to them. If you already have in mind what deck you want to build I would buy singles.
 
Weird, we talked about that card last night during a Commander game, where my friend ultimated his Karn and restarted the game. If someone played that white monstrosity during an EDH game, I'd scoop.

I have seen the spell being cast and getting Forked/Reverberated/Twincast a few times. It's really funny.
 
So, in an EDH game, if someone resolves Shahrazard, and your commander is in play, do you get to take your commander with you to the subgame?
 
Well my core 2013 box finally shipped! That's it, I guess I'm officially into magic. I'm really excited to start playing with my friends and bothering you guys with dumb questions every time we play

Edit: first dumb question! How expensive are booster packs and where's the best place to purchase them?
 
Well my core 2013 box finally shipped! That's it, I guess I'm officially into magic. I'm really excited to start playing with my friends and bothering you guys with dumb questions every time we play

Yay! I enjoy answering people's rules questions way too much. I should probably become a judge.
 
Edit: first dumb question! How expensive are booster packs and where's the best place to purchase them?

4 bucks.

Best place? Your favorite LGS. Reality? Buy them everywhere! They are extremely addicting.

I have a shop between my subway station and my home. I pass by it twice a day to and from work. The draw to buy just one pack is intense, let me tell you.
 
Rules question: Say I have a Typhoid Rats (1/1 deathtouch). Can I block a creature and regenerate it with Swarmyard and still kill the blocked creature?
 
Rules question: Say I have a Typhoid Rats (1/1 deathtouch). Can I block a creature and regenerate it with Swarmyard and still kill the blocked creature?

Yup. As long as the Rats dealt damage to the blocked creature, Deathtouch kicks in and the creature dies, no matter how much damage it was or if your Rats dies or regenerates as well.
 
Rules question: Say I have a Typhoid Rats (1/1 deathtouch). Can I block a creature and regenerate it with Swarmyard and still kill the blocked creature?

Yep. Regeneration just puts a "shield" on the creature that will trigger the first time it is destroyed. If nothing happens to your creature before the combat damage step it will take lethal damage in combat, deal its 1 point of deathtouch damage, and then regenerate instead of going to the graveyard, leaving it tapped on your side of the field.

If something happens to destroy it before combat damage (say it gets Lightning Bolted or whatever) it will get removed from combat and not deal its damage because regenerating removes a creature from combat. (Assuming the regeneration ability resolved before said destruction.)
 
Rules question: Say I have a Typhoid Rats (1/1 deathtouch). Can I block a creature and regenerate it with Swarmyard and still kill the blocked creature?

As long as the other creature doesn't have first strike- Regen is a replacement effect that occurs when the creature would die, which has a side effect of removing it from combat
 
I... don't think I could actually play through that. As much as I love Shahrazad.

Yeah, it was played out a handful of times and then it just became an auto-scoop from most people since they don't want to play it out that much. There's pretty much an unspoken rule in the circle I play with that you don't play that spell anymore.
 
How much do judges have to know about templates?
 
Can someone please build a deck with these three things in it:

Image.ashx
Image.ashx
Image.ashx


I'm sure the deck wouldn't be any good. But I had this dream while napping on the bus this morning that I had Yeva out, cast Beast Tracker in response to Guild Feud, and slammed the Wurm down.
 
Can someone please build a deck with these three things in it:

Image.ashx
Image.ashx
Image.ashx


I'm sure the deck wouldn't be any good. But I had this dream while napping on the bus this morning that I had Yeva out, cast Beast Tracker in response to Guild Feud, and slammed the Wurm down.

Attempt #1, a sort of Jund brew.

uHzY5.jpg


Lotleth trolls for regenerating defenders that can also pitch any wurms you draw (who when discarded get shuffled back into your library). The Jarrad's orders let you fetch a beast tracker to your hand and pitch the wurm (again reshuffled). Bunch of removal to just buy time. Thragtusks because... well... green mana.
 
Attempt #2, a RUG brew.

SLnqk.jpg


This one is a bit dodgier, but it does have a second way to cheat it in with Counterlash. Pity both methods for getting this big boy out cost 6 mana.

yHVBT.jpg


I did get there though. =p
 
Attempt #1, a sort of Jund brew.

uHzY5.jpg


Lotleth trolls for regenerating defenders that can also pitch any wurms you draw (who when discarded get shuffled back into your library). The Jarrad's orders let you fetch a beast tracker to your hand and pitch the wurm (again reshuffled). Bunch of removal to just buy time. Thragtusks because... well... green mana.

Haha this is awesome
 
Do you have Jaces available? This seems like a deck that wants him to stall/dig.

Also might want Keyrunes or Chromatic Lanterns.
 
Yessss...yessss.....

I am so building these when I get home from work.

EDIT: I'm thinking Increasing Amibition over Diabolic Revalation in that Jund brew maybe?

EDIT2: Oh yes, Jace in the second deck. Also gives you an alternate way to theoretically get the Wurm onto the table if you can get him to ultimate.
 
I swapped out the 2 revelations for 2 more jarad's orders, works much better. Though yea increasing ambition to fetch the guild feud would probably be better. The deck hinges on that card.
 
Starcity is raising the price of premium http://www.starcitygames.com/magic/misc/25169-StarCityGamescom-Premium-Announcement.html

I sporadically subscribe to them, mostly on Quarterly memberships (10 dollars for 3 months), but at this point, with how strong CFB is on video content (assuming you have ad block installed, of course), and the articles on Dailymtg and Brainburst, the only reason I have even been going to SCG.com over the last month or so was for the weekly Chas Andres columns on finance, because he is such a great writer and I always learn something from them. Now that my 10 dollars that previously bought me 90 days now buys me 30 days, I'll probably just wait a month to read his stuff.

I'm glad they are going full-scale porn site mode though with a 3.99 weekly pass. Kinda sad they didn't just go all the way and make it a 48 hour VIP pass for 2 dollars or something though.
 
Is the additional revenue going to make the website not look like ass?
ADSADSADSADSADSADSADSADSADSADSADSADSADS
ADSADSADSADSADSADSADSADSADSADSADSADSADS
ADSADSADSADSI doubt it.ADSADSADSADSADSADSDS
ADSADSADSADSADSADSADSADSADSADSADSADSADS
ADSADSADSADSADSADSADSADSADSADSADSADSADS
 
I kinda feel like playing something like this... any thoughts?

Caravan's Vigil
Abundant Growth
Farseek
Ranger's Path
Terminus
Bonfire of the Damned
Entreat the Angels
Thragtusk (or Primordial Hydra)
Gisela, Blade of Goldnight
24 Lands
 
Starcity is raising the price of premium http://www.starcitygames.com/magic/misc/25169-StarCityGamescom-Premium-Announcement.html

I sporadically subscribe to them, mostly on Quarterly memberships (10 dollars for 3 months), but at this point, with how strong CFB is on video content (assuming you have ad block installed, of course), and the articles on Dailymtg and Brainburst, the only reason I have even been going to SCG.com over the last month or so was for the weekly Chas Andres columns on finance, because he is such a great writer and I always learn something from them. Now that my 10 dollars that previously bought me 90 days now buys me 30 days, I'll probably just wait a month to read his stuff.

I'm glad they are going full-scale porn site mode though with a 3.99 weekly pass. Kinda sad they didn't just go all the way and make it a 48 hour VIP pass for 2 dollars or something though.

That's really stupid. Time for me to stop subscribing.

Edit: Ah, sneaky:

1. Current subscribers can auto-renew at our current rates for as long as they wish to do so.*
 
Do you guys have any other good places to read Magic articles? I usually read CFB, Starcity (non-premium), TcgPlayer/Brainburst and GatheringMagic.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom