• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Bands that made one album you absolutely love..

Status
Not open for further replies.
[
51V6iqwu5fL._SL500_AA300__PJautoripBadge,BottomRight,4,-40_OU11__.jpg


The Hives: Black & White Album

Love this album. Could care less about any of the other albums they've put out.
 
I don't understand how you like Blue, but dislike Pinkerton. Pinkerton is easily the best thing they ever did.

I guess around the people I knew, the Blue Album was considered the best Weezer album. Pinkerton was kind of dismissed when it came out but was sort of rediscovered when true emo started becoming popular on college radio. I don't dislike Pinkerton or the Green album at all, but to me the Blue Album is just a classic.
 
My contribution:

iVDnExmuM0iGF.jpg


Although, I didn't realize they released an album last year and haven't listened to that.
 
album-big-choice.jpg


I guess around the people I knew, the Blue Album was considered the best Weezer album. Pinkerton was kind of dismissed when it came out but was sort of rediscovered when true emo started becoming popular on college radio. I don't dislike Pinkerton or the Green album at all, but to me the Blue Album is just a classic.

Quoted for truth.
 
A Perfect Circle thread? I think so.

I need this kind of Maynard. Where did you go? Why did you do Emotive? Please come back...please?
 
Bit of an interesting choice considering pretty much everything they put out is considered classic. So you don't really care about their other self titled album? I can see not liking White Light/White Heat and Loaded as those kind of went in different directions.
 
TS1z8.jpg


This album was fucking fantastic when it came out. Then, all their other albums were boring shite. Such a shame.
 
There's a ton of bands that I can think of that put out one amazing album and a bunch of middling to decent albums, but not a lot where I dislike everything but the one amazing one they put out.
 
I was going to post this in reply to bands that only made 1 album, but it looks like they made another one in 2011 and I never noticed.

ibjakIffuuavQU.jpg


Rival Schools - United

Amazing album. Released in 2001. Made another one in 2011, 10 years later which is kinda strange. I'll have to check it out.
 
no, war on errorism was the exact reason i was calling bullshit. unless you count the decline as an album in which case it's pretty obvious that's a good record.
 
Oracular_Spectacular_2008.jpg


There second album Congratulations really didn't do much for me. I appreciate what they did with it, but didn't have the same lasting effect.
 
That's a bit excessive don't you think.

which part? i do think de-loused in the comatorium is one of the greatest (25? def top 50) albums of all time, and i do think their follow ups never recaptured what made the first so good
 
I love The Deftones' White Pony album. I don't otherwise like The Deftones, but man...that album's my absolute favorite album ever and has been since high school.
 
I really like Cowboys From Hell from Pantera. The rest of their stuff sounds more like modern metal trash but I was almost convinced that if metal was going to sound like that going forward then maybe I could get over the 80s stuff dying out.
 
Urge Overkill and a Flock of Seagulls are excellent picks. The Cars debut album is wrong because Candy O and Heartbeat City are arguably better. Deltron doesn't really count because it's a one-shot deal (until the rumored second album actually comes out).

I prefer the remarkable albums that the rest of the band's catalog didn't suggest they were capable of. One of my favorites is Dust by the Screaming Trees. Such an awesome album that is head and shoulders above anything else they did.
 
My favorite album of the 2000's... and I pretty much avoid the rest of their catalog.

UglyOrgan.jpg


This record is meant to be played start to finish. The songs by themselves don't really stand out, but as a record? It's fucking awesome. It's got a one of a kind sound, too. Even Cursive couldn't replicate it, lol.

Hey, here is the full album start to finish. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y5uLleCmm6k
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom