While most of these games were shit, you can say the same stuff (more of the same, not setting the world on fire) about Halo 4 or Forza too. 2012 wasn't that great for both.
On the other hand Sony clearly owns 2013, but mostly for the fact that MS abandoned this gen. Hope it translates into great next gen games.
I don't think those games are shit, I'm just making a point that he has no idea what he's talking about, and is talking out of the side of his neck at this point. He's bringing up rehashes of past series and indie games that were moneyhatted by Sony, not to mention a "new" IP that is new in name alone.
I liked the TM beta; I liked the beta/demo for Starhawk; I liked Forza Horizon; Halo 4 looks rad (haven't played it yet) I don't have a problem with MSony moneyhatting games to make them exclusive; what I don't like is when people keep on spouting hypocritical BS AND use examples that are the exact same things of what they were complaining about.
The difference is that first party games give insight into the future of the console, not just the present. For example, we know even before they announced the system that PS4 is going to get games from Naughty Dog, Polyphony, etc. Back in 2005, we knew the 360 was going to get a game from Bungie. 3rd party developers hold no guarantees for the future. They could go multiplat like Bungie has now, or Insomniac, or they could go exclusive to another system.
What do we know that we are getting from the next XBOX? I guess we'll just have to wait and find out.
Perhaps it doesn't really matter, but I think it's first parties that help give each console and each brand an identity.
And we know we're going to get games from 343, Rare, Turn10, Black Tusk, Twisted Pixel etc. on the Nextbox.