Halo 4 Designer Calls Out Kojima on Sex (Pot to Kettle: "You are blue!")

I agree. This is not the video game industry i know. We should teach all those sexist character designers a lesson. And how do we teach people a lesson in the video game industry? We murder them by the hundreds. So grab your weapons and spread the word: We are sick of sexism! We need more blood, gore and suffering!
 
To me they are somewhat equally as bad, for MGS4, well, that just isn't practical at all and as Kojima has said they are just doing it "because" rather than an actual reason. As for Halo and Cortana, her design imo has always been out of place, especially in Halo 4 as graphics have improved, it just looks stupid to have a virtual woman who looks completely naked minus the smaller details in the typical military environment of the games.

Serina from Halo Wars was far better, I mean look at this, she is fully clothed, crazy right.

Serina.jpg
 
Didn't know Halo 4 was an example and a paragon of maturity. This obsession of the industry about eroticism is getting ridiculous and looks more and more like a witch hunt. I know the industry is in search of respectability but come on, even cinema has its exploitation movies.

in an industry so full of brutal violence I find it extremely hard to get up in arms about 'sexy' character designs.

the game will be rated accordingly, who fucking cares? you don't see this kind of petty bullshit with tv, movies, etc.

it's kinda hilarious, and sad, seeing the videogame industry trying to become a bastion of morality while cinema and music industry don't give a fuck and have no problem displaying as many titties and ass as possible to sell their products.
 
Some devs (No, I will not point them out for the sake of privacy. It's their personal account.) have already commented on the matter. David's reply is tame by comparison.
 
Gemüsepizza;80298233 said:
Riiight. Regarding character design which makes sense: Master Chief wearing a robe makes also total sense. But at least it's cool. And a military AI which has the form of a nude woman is not an "adolescent wank fantasy"?

Never said it wasn't but I've never played Halo so it's kind of irrelevant. Played MGS4 and it was kind of cringeworthy sometimes.
 
As a girl, I did find Cortana in Halo 4 to be a little...too naked. But Kojima's design for this girl in MGS5 is just as bad if not worse. I remember when I first saw the trailer, I rolled my eyes when she appeared. Kind of turned me off from the game.
 
Ugh.

I am so sick of these moralist slams against niche games.

Newsflash: these aren't "representative of your (precious) industry", they are the rare viewpoint of a bizzare little game for a bizzare little audience.

Let people enjoy what they want... Stop policing video game content under the guise of "furthering the medium" as you decree it.

I also like you.
 
I know we have a bunch of female gamers on Neogaf and would like their opinion on this.

Do you find the female character renders released by Kojima disgusting as well?
 
Call him a hypocrite for not criticising sexed up Cortana (and not getting fired) if you want, but he's not wrong.
 
Quiet looks like a 90's comic book character.

Halo 4 Cortana looks like an H-game love interest.

Both shitty character designs. If the Beauty and the Beast Unit in MGS4 proved anything, it's that Kojima needs to do more than sex appeal and a tragic backstory to get us to like his characters.
Come on, just look at her evolution

2361403-evolution_of_lks96.jpg


It's a blatantly obvious. But I guess it makes it okay since they didn't actually say it like Kojima.
You can tell the exact moment when the moe~moe sets in during Halo 3.
 
it's kinda hilarious, and sad, seeing the videogame industry trying to become a bastion of morality while cinema and music industry don't give a fuck and have no problem displaying as many titties and ass as possible to sell their products.

Those industries aren't desperately trying to convince everyone that they're grown up.

That said, lines do get crossed, they're just much further back.
 
Its funny i actually did not find the character sexy untill this controversy, now i have looked at her too much and am starting to find her erotic, i guess thats what happens when people look into too much detail. Thank You Ellis, now i cannot play the game without looking at that character way too much, Mmcheeww....
 
it's kinda hilarious, and sad, seeing the videogame industry trying to become a bastion of morality while cinema and music industry don't give a fuck and have no problem displaying as many titties and ass as possible to sell their products.

Didn't all this started when Anita sarkeesian showed up? So....since 2012? I really don't remember much complaining about character designs at all before that. Now it's all the rage. And it's mostly about Japanese character designs too, if not only about JP designs.

I didn't see them complaining about butt naked women in God of War, whose purpose in the games are to have sex with.

Sees scantily clad women in videogames: Disgusting!
Sees butt naked women in videogames: -
 
Yeah, nobody said anything at all about that performance.

That was because it was an awful performance and not because it was sexed up. As pointed out many times, Britney Spears did a far more sexual performance at the VMA's years ago and it was highly praised.
 
Alright let's kill sexy girls in games. Im down with that if we can have guys without bulging muscles or perfect physiques and have average looking guys instead like that spokesman from subway while all women should look like Ellen Degeneres.
 
Metal Gear has had lots of sexualized female character before, but this one is pretty different thing, they weren't almost naked and that torn pantyhose is really really trashy and just there for fetish/pandering. I think this one went too far, say Eva/Sniper Wolf/Fortune or b&b units with tight cloths/weird camera angles they had are 'modest' in comparison.
 
Whatever you guys wanna say, the Halo designer is right. That Kojima is a right ol' kinky, nasty mofo!

But does that make me bad? Being physically attracted to nasty?
 
Also i am puzzled by how society puts more priority into sexual discussions over violence, like isnt there a saying that ''make Sex not War, condoms are cheaper than bullets''
 
Cortana had no logical reason to be nude. "But she's AI, and her nakedness puts her enemies off guard, and ..." no. It was a pervy decision, just like Quiet's design. "How can we get away with having a sexy, confident, nude woman character?".

Charity starts at home. This Halo 4 designer should have had words with the Halo team about seeing if they could carry Cortana forward without her being naked. Which she is, just without the nipples.

This 'White Knight' shit sometimes gets pushed too far. Sure, you might not agree, but no need to insult anyone. And, actually, you can keep that opinion to yourself.
 
Some devs (No, I will not point them out for the sake of privacy. It's their personal account.) have already commented on the matter. David's reply is tame by comparison.

Would be interesting to see if they in a glass house just like David is .
If it is one thing that gets me really angry it is a hypocrite .
 
I'm so serious

If the same people who tried to discount Dragon's Crown as a crime against women everywhere don't get vocal about MGSV after what Kojima said then it proves these people had no argument from the beginning and wanted to stir shit up just because..

If you wanna be some righteous activist, you can't pick and choose your arguments based on different circumstances or because of the fact that maybe it just so happens to be a game you like now.. These both fall under the same umbrella.

And I'm calling it out because I saw the hypocrisy in it from Day One.
 
I sure did miss David Ellis' unique brand of "if its not Halo it sucks" game journalism. Glad to see Twitter keeps the dream alive.

It is pretty much always men complaining about female designs.

Yeah I was a huge fan of him back when he was a 1UP Yours/Listen Up regular, he saved me a few hours a week of podcasts to listen to.
Him joining that show was the beginning of the end for it. Terrible.
 
People certainly complained about those.

"People" complain about everything, but i'm talking about the industry itself, game designers? Maybe there were game designers complaining? I didn't see it myself, but seems to be the thing to do nowadays.
 
Come on, just look at her evolution

2361403-evolution_of_lks96.jpg


It's a blatantly obvious. But I guess it makes it okay since they didn't actually say it like Kojima.

In all fairness to 343, Cortana has always been a nude blue woman with weird patterns on her. It's just the fact that with the evolution of polygons and what have you, she looks like an actual woman rather than a funny cartoon girl. What did you all want them to do? Make her look less human? Sure they probably made her a bit more curvy and whatnot but it's not like they overhauled her design.
 
If David Ellis and 343i actually created a decent Halo game, without an over sexualized cortana. Then maybe he has a point, but sadly he is being hypocritical now.
 
I think it's kind of shitty. She absolutely has gotten tarted up in comparison to her reveal model, that's the story here, not that her clothing is exactly the same.
 
Top Bottom