Super Smash Bros Wii U & 3DS Thread 4: New Year, Old Arguments

ixmaIpaRfBu4x.gif

To refute the cloud post from the last page, I have shown you what it really looks like overlayed.
This is like searching for the clipping on Joakim's teeth. XD

Great job!
 
Alright here is the list so far. I'll update it as more people pledge their allegiance.

#TeamReal
Fiktion
SuperSah
-Horizon-
Clov
Not
Jagsrock
RealDeadOne
SkullHydra
Baron von Loathsome
Tyeforce
Moonlight
Gleethor
BigEvilTurtle

#TeamFake
BGBW
Pop-O-Matic
EndlessSky
Kurtofan
Anth0ny
Hyperactivity
SmithnCo
emb
Lunar15

Put me on team real Captain.

If we win, I am going to party so hard.
 
If it is fake, all the effort in creating the shots has certainly paid off in getting to watch all this madness unfold at their own hand.

Everyone's gone from having fun to having too much fun.
 
This team crap is so dumb.

I think many people think Palutena will be in the game, but don't think this leak is real or want to just be cautious regarding the leak.
That's some bogus! The game is still in development. We've seen several small changes to Link's face already.
Changes? You mean this?
nbG9McM.jpg
 
TeamFake all over here. I mean, there's yet to be anything to disprove Palutena, but there's no "golden detail" to seal the deal for me. The Power Star would have been but that's off the table now, so...

Fake until proven legit!
 
The only winning move is not to play

and then wait until it's proved one way or another and laugh at the wrong people and act like you knew better the whole time despite being totally clueless in actuality.

That plan's never failed me before.
 
After this I'm definitely #teamreal.
Suit yourself, but it doesn't really refute the point I made since the clouds still are different shapes even in that gif. I could even point out the shadows on the two clouds are different. The leak's is dark all the way down.
 
Suit yourself, but it doesn't really refute the point I made since the clouds still are different shapes even in that gif. I could even point out the shadows on the two clouds are different. The leak's is dark all the way down.

Hey, nothing personal! I just think that the minor differences are due to the quality and lighting of the two pics.
 
Updated the list. Look at all those nonbelievers on #TeamFake. They will be second class citizens once we take control.

This was something I didn't want to lean toward either way but TEAM REAL! All aboard the hype train! The rest of you can get on the Expect Less Express!
 
#TeamReal that just pic seems to have to much attention to detail to be fake in my eyes, and besides im an optimist :) BOOO #TeamFake you and your damn rationality >_>
 
#TeamFake

I thought it might be real at first, but the evidence against it is building...

I still hope Palutena's playable.
 
Evidence?

The cloud thing for one; BGBW's post pushed me over the edge. I had a hard time believing random 3DS screenshots would just leak out like that.

Also, why did the leaker not screenshot the lower screen? Oh yeah, because we don't know what that looks like yet, so it won't be possible to fake convincingly.
 
The cloud thing for one; BGBW's post pushed me over the edge.

There's a rebuttal to that at the top of this page.

Also, why did the leaker not screenshot the lower screen? Oh yeah, because we don't know what that looks like yet, so it won't be possible to fake convincingly.

Because he's trying to show us Palutena and not what is probably an incomplete touchscreen UI.
 
The cloud thing for one; BGBW's post pushed me over the edge. I had a hard time believing random 3DS screenshots would just leak out like that.

Also, why did the leaker not screenshot the lower screen? Oh yeah, because we don't know what that looks like yet, so it won't be possible to fake convincingly.
ixmaIpaRfBu4x.gif

To refute the cloud post from the last page, I have shown you what it really looks like overlayed.
The cloud 'evidence' is false.
 
The cloud 'evidence' is false.

Not necessarily, but neither .gif is really evidence, they're clouds and we haven't had a picture from that exact camera angle before, so we can't tell if it's fake or not.

in short, the can't really be used to support either fake or real.

Plus, no one has the actual skybox model, as the clouds are most likely not all on one layer, in brawl, the clouds on stages like skyworld were overlayed polygons with transparent textures, so the clouds in the 3ds battlefield may just as well be overlayed.
 
Here's the list so far. The ranks are growing on both sides, but #TeamReal has strength in numbers.

Check for your name in case I missed anyone. I'll add any late comers later.

#TeamReal
Fiktion
SuperSah
-Horizon-
Clov
Not
Jagsrock
RealDeadOne
SkullHydra
Baron von Loathsome
Tyeforce
Moonlight
Gleethor
BigEvilTurtle
Javier
Sorastitch
Riki
Fidelis Hodie
qq more
PK Gaming
Axass
Neoriceisgood
RomanceDawn
exfatal
GreatCharleston
anaron
KHlover
The Solid Snake
nullset2
Neoxon
TheLegendOfCap
Jaruru
Poltergust
Vampirolol
FireVoa
rawktapus
Mauricio_Magus
Heyt
akidnamededdy
DisconnectD
FlynnCL

#TeamFake
BGBW
Pop-O-Matic
EndlessSky
Kurtofan
Anth0ny
Hyperactivity
SmithnCo
emb
Lunar15
Chico Terry
Anura
Mushroomer25
J@hranimo
jph139
PaperFlame
Hasardeur
Wichu
Camjo-Z
Loco4Coco
BY2K
ec0ec0
Whiskeymatt
OrangeGrayBlue
Anteo
 
Top Bottom