• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

2 US Navy Boats/10 American Sailors Held by Iran [Upd: Released thanks to diplomacy]

Status
Not open for further replies.
A

AcademicSaucer

Member
Iran is in red alert against Saudi Arabia, USA as Saudi Arabia's biggest ally, is going to raise suspicion on Iran's part if they have Navy Boats close to their territory. I can understand why this would happen.
 
D

dabig2

Member
Valhelm said:
Damn, bad move by Iran. Is this "punishment" for our refusal to abandon Saudi Arabia?
Click to expand...

No. US boat broke down and drifted into Iranian waters. Iranians picked them up. Literally within the hour after the pickup they verified the story and told the US that they would give them back in a couple hours. The end.

The only response from the US should be "thanks for picking up our guys and sorry for having them drift into your territory. Peace."
 
O

Ovid

Member
dabig2 said:
No. US boat broke down and drifted into Iranian waters. Iranians picked them up. Literally within the hour after the pickup they verified the story and told the US that they would give them back in a couple hours. The end.

The only response from the US should be "thanks for picking up our guys and sorry for having them drift into your territory. Peace."
Click to expand...
It's a non story.
 
P

Phantast2k

Member
Somewhat related:

ARABIAN GULF (Dec. 26, 2015) Forward Looking Infrared Radar (FLIR) footage taken by a U.S. Navy Sea Hawk helicopter operating from USS Harry S. Truman (CVN 75) as an Iranian Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps Navy (IRGCN) fast inshore attack craft (FIAC) fires several unguided rockets in close proximity to the USS Harry S. Truman (CVN 75), USS Bulkeley (DDG 84), and the French frigate FS Provence (D 652), along with other commercial traffic, as they were transiting the Strait of Hormuz into the Arabian Gulf in an internationally recognized maritime traffic lane. (U.S. Navy video/RELEASED)
Click to expand...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xKjZVX7fplU

News article: http://www.military.com/daily-news/...es-video-of-provocative-iran-rocket-fire.html
 
K

Kathian

Banned
Well its not exactly the British captured sailers is it? And even then Iran managed to look reasonable by the end. Seems a straight forward process; sailers will be sent back on their way shortly.
 
J

Joni

Member
Iran: Hey US, we found some of your guys. Please come pick them up.
Obama: Okay, sending the plane now.
GOP: THIS IS A DECLARATION OF WAR! SEND IN THE NUKES.
 
D

Drencrom

Member
dabig2 said:
No. US boat broke down and drifted into Iranian waters. Iranians picked them up. Literally within the hour after the pickup they verified the story and told the US that they would give them back in a couple hours. The end.

The only response from the US should be "thanks for picking up our guys and sorry for having them drift into your territory. Peace."
Click to expand...

Joni said:
Iran: Hey US, we found some of your guys. Please come pick them up.
Obama: Okay, sending the plane now.
GOP: THIS IS A DECLARATION OF WAR! SEND IN THE NUKES.
Click to expand...

Yeah, what is up with all the "bad move, Iran" comments and such? I'd say this situation couldn't possibly be handled better all things considered.
 
J

Jotaka

Member
Drencrom said:
Yeah, what is up with all the "bad move, Iran" comments and such? I'd say this situation couldn't possibly be handled better all things considered.
Click to expand...

That show to me the years brainwashing propaganda in effect in a lot of people OR people just don't read beyond the headline lol
 
K

Kathian

Banned
SliceSabre said:
Story begins and ends literally overnight.

Iran just did what any country would do if someone else's military personnel drifted into their waters.
Click to expand...

Erdogan%2Bfacepalm.jpg
 
S

shem935

Banned
Wait they were released? Whaattttt no but Jeb told me that Obama's policies on Iran were a failure. Jeb can't be wrong can he?
 
S

Shake Appeal

Member
shem935 said:
Wait they were released? Whaattttt no but Jeb told me that Obama's policies on Iran were a failure. Jeb can't be wrong can he?
Click to expand...
The new narrative is "Of course they released them, it's all part of their nefarious Iranian long game to build an nuke and destroy us all."
 
U

UnemployedVillain

Member
I hate the rhetoric some news stations are using with regards to this. Navy boats "captured" when in reality it was "detained". You might think the distinction is subtle, but it isn't and was very much intentional
 
Tal Shiar Agent

Tal Shiar Agent

Member
UnemployedVillain said:
I hate the rhetoric some news stations are using with regards to this. Navy boats "captured" when in reality it was "detained". You might think the distinction is subtle, but it isn't and was very much intentional
Click to expand...
Yeah, when I read "captured" I thought it a hostile act, reading the actual events mellowed it out so much it's almost a non story other than showing Iran is willing to be much more cooperative and open with the US.
 
N

Netherscourge

Banned
If two Iranian naval ships wandered into US waters, what do you think the US response would be?

Help them fix their motor and let them go on their merry way without any other interaction whatsoever?

Of course not. They would be boarded, detained, questioned, investigated, possibly interrogated... for starters.
 
F

FreedomFighter

Member
The way the US media handled this is just deplorable. This situation is exactly why I've been done with US mainstream news outlets for a long time.

The coverage is just humiliating.

Most outlets are flat out lying as they're neglecting to even mention that the US vessels entered Iranian waters. They're being extremely jingoistic and beating war drums over what is really, clearly, a non-issue. They're spinning this as Iran making the US look "weak" (and Obama as well) because diplomacy actually took place here.

It's really sickening.
 
P

pgtl_10

Member
CHEEZMO™;192028115 said:
"Because it's dark" is a pretty silly reason to not release them immediately, probably a delaying tactic to wind people up or something. If they had actually been doing something untoward then Tehran would be making a lot more noise.

Between this and the rocket thing a few days ago, probably the Pasdaran trying to make a point/send a message.
Click to expand...

Not really. It is easier to see what's going on during the day. Probably a security protocol.
 
J

Jenov

Member
Awesome that this was handled quickly and without any incident. +1 Obama and improved relations with Iran. Less ammo for the GOP is always good.
 
N

nib95

Banned
Glad it was dealt with quickly, and as such more of a middle finger to those Republican war and fearmongers.
 
D

dabig2

Member
FreedomFighter said:
The way the US media handled this is just deplorable. This situation is exactly why I've been done with US mainstream news outlets for a long time.

The coverage is just humiliating.

Most outlets are flat out lying as they're neglecting to even mention that the US vessels entered Iranian waters. They're being extremely jingoistic and beating war drums over what is really, clearly, a non-issue. They're spinning this as Iran making the US look "weak" (and Obama as well) because diplomacy actually took place here.

It's really sickening.
Click to expand...

This is the real story here, how the US mainstream media handled this. Like you said, it's absolutely disgraceful and pitiful.
 
P

pgtl_10

Member
FreedomFighter said:
The way the US media handled this is just deplorable. This situation is exactly why I've been done with US mainstream news outlets for a long time.

The coverage is just humiliating.

Most outlets are flat out lying as they're neglecting to even mention that the US vessels entered Iranian waters. They're being extremely jingoistic and beating war drums over what is really, clearly, a non-issue. They're spinning this as Iran making the US look "weak" (and Obama as well) because diplomacy actually took place here.

It's really sickening.
Click to expand...

http://time.com/4180372/u-s-sailors-freed-by-iran-but-their-humiliation-persists/

It takes political skill to know how and when to react to a military provocation. The Obama Administration, intent on sealing a deal limiting Iran’s nuclear ambitions, plainly wants to do nothing to derail that achievement. The key question is why Iran didn’t feel the same way.
Click to expand...

Seriously the media should be ashamed. OMG Iranians video taped the incident!

Can you blame Iran? The US media likes to make stuff up.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

US Navy firees warning shots at Iranian Revolutionar Guards ship in Gulf.
6
1K
JonnyDBrit replied
  • Locked
Navy sailors detained by Iran "were derelict in their duties"
3
998
blackjaw replied
  • Locked
Report: US airlifted $400 million to Iran as detained Americans were released
15
4K
Chumly replied
  • Locked
Obama wrote secret letter to Iran Supreme Leader on fighting ISIS
25
5K
Metallix87 replied
  • Locked
Saudi Arabia launches air campaign in Yemen against Iran-backed Saleh & Houthis
1
831
commedieu replied
Top Bottom