psynergylover
Member
we "invasion of the body snatchers" now?
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Apparently women's bodies are considered 'hosts', according to one US lawmaker
- Thread starter Kadin
- Start date
- Status
Aeriscloud
Banned
Maybe he's just thinking about when his mom carried him.
Silent Chief
Member
"host" makes it sounds like they are carrying the offspring of a parasite.
Get some lawyers to write your laws, not some preacher.
Get some lawyers to write your laws, not some preacher.
MsKrisp
Member
I feel like pro-life is all about policing women's behavior. It's clear they don't give a damn about the "sanctity of life"
I thought we had this thread yesterday
GameAddict411
Member
I have no idea why is abortion IS SUCH A FUCK'IN BIG deal to these men? Why do they have to care what women have to do with their Vagina? It's shocking how a developed country still debates these issues. Very shameful and stupid.
Here's the thing though; invites can be retracted. I can host a party, invite people over, but I can kick anyone out of my own home at any time for any reason. So his whole analogy falls to pieces since 'invites' are up to the 'host's' discretion to rescind whenever they see fit.
Kadin
Member
Oh we sure did, that was my bad. I searched for 'host' and not 'hosts' like I should have done. Stupid rookie mistake...
CadetMahoney
Member
His arguments also have zero legal precedence supporting it, but there's lot's supporting the exact opposite (Roe v Wade and privacy/bodily integrity).
Gamer @ Heart
Member
Oh we sure did, that was my bad. I searched for 'host' and not 'hosts' like I should have done. Stupid rookie mistake...
General rule: if the article you are basing a thread on is more than an hour old, it almost assuredly has a thread.
Kadin
Member
Yeah for sure. The article I linked and based this on was from late today but your point stands. Simple searching is usually what I do and is most of time enough. Clearly it wasn't this time... lol
Airola
Member
Change "kick anyone out" to "kill everyone inside and then kick them out" and then your analogy works. Because that's what the guy is against, the killing of the new person "hosted" by the woman. You are fighting shadows as long as you don't understand the core of the issue as the pro-life people see it. There is zero chance of them understanding your side until you understand what their point is.
This "kicking people out from the party" analogy only proves you haven't understood what the core of their belief about this subject is. In their analogy the context is that once the invited person is inside the house the person can't live outside of the house anymore and it's 100% certain death if you remove that person too early.
Chaos2Frozen
Member
That would also imply he thinks men are parasitic wasps or something :v
Oh we sure did, that was my bad. I searched for 'host' and not 'hosts' like I should have done. Stupid rookie mistake...
I just had to make sure I wasn't crazy because I had sworn that I commented on this before but couldn't find my post in this thread, ahaha.
CadetMahoney
Member
The analogy should be "in your body" then the pro-life side comes crashing down from a legal POV. After all, no one born and alive has those rights pro-lifers want to grant the unborn and fertilization is neither illegal nor negligent.
The U.S. lawmaker isn't basing his arguments on anything remotely close to a legal argument to overturn Roe.
Perhaps the pro-life side need to comeback with better arguments than the same ones since 1973.
Muppet of a Man
Member
Carlin was so fucking on point about politics all the time...it's like he was a goddamn political prophet or something.
nelsonroyale
Member
Disgusting. What a disgusting thing to say. I wish I could say it to him in person.
Now that I think about it, it does make men seem like the parasites. Double dickhead.
Now that I think about it, it does make men seem like the parasites. Double dickhead.
Muppet of a Man
Member
Fetuses are a gestational stage of human animal natal development (everyone can agree on that part), but until that fetus can live outside the body on its own, I wouldn't grant it personhood rights.
What is so hard to understand about this?
I'll give you a one word answer: religion.
Religion is a problem, as it obfuscates the ability of a person to think rationally.
Prototype Viktor
Member
there's only 3 people involved in a pregnancy/reproduction that have agency
the fetus
the father
the insurance company
the fetus
the father
the insurance company
corporations are people
fabricated backlash
Member
so the Republican Party is basically Weyland Yutani
Fallout-NL
Member
Yup, just one more way to increase their power. Disgusting.
Rest
All these years later I still chuckle at what a fucking moron that guy is.
That's what pregnancy is. Just because it's reproductive doesn't mean it's not a parasite/host relationship.
That's some fucked up reasoning though.
SolarMystic
Member
Midwest proving once again that it's the worst place to live in the US.
1.21Gigawatts
Banned
Bring yourself back online, wife.
What an idiot...
What an idiot...
Well I mean that's how pro-choice people have been using the analogy for the longest time. I dunno why this guy thinks that leaning into the host/parasite thing is going to help his case.
excelsiorlef
Member
Yeah I read that and thought oh so I'm totally allow to just straight up call the fetus parasite? Because that's what it is in the end/
Dog Problems
Banned
A lot of conservatives can because they don't see women as people.
Beren the Empty-Handed
Member
Well that's fucking disgusting.
I mean, most people when they discover they are hosting a parasite freak out and go to the doctor to get it removed.
Sorry, I was not a 'host' for four my pregnancies. My third did not miscarry because I was a bad host. Nor was I a bad host when the last was born too early. I was a woman who happened to pregnant and wanted kids. I later had a hysterectomy due to complications with the last kids. Everyone else can stay out of music medical decisions thanks. It seems if some had their way, I do nothing but pump out babies even if it wasn't healthy for me.
Sorry, I was not a 'host' for four my pregnancies. My third did not miscarry because I was a bad host. Nor was I a bad host when the last was born too early. I was a woman who happened to pregnant and wanted kids. I later had a hysterectomy due to complications with the last kids. Everyone else can stay out of music medical decisions thanks. It seems if some had their way, I do nothing but pump out babies even if it wasn't healthy for me.
The kid might end up being Republican, after all.
YourMaster
Member
To be fair, it is kinda unfortunate for men who would love to have that baby, but forcing women to carry it and give birth to it is no option.
And of course, the fetus has no intrinsic value, so it is not a party to be considered at all.
What would be a proper solution is to work on techniques to transfer the fetus from her to him and allow him to poop it out several months down the line.
And of course, the fetus has no intrinsic value, so it is not a party to be considered at all.
What would be a proper solution is to work on techniques to transfer the fetus from her to him and allow him to poop it out several months down the line.
CaviarMeths
Member
Imagine my surprise when I learned that Justin Humphrey is an old white dude!
buy teh haloz
Banned
Yes it does, parasites are a different species from their host
Hierophant
Banned
sounds like some resident evil shit, have I been living with monsters this whole time?
That hasn't been true for over 5 years. Here is one such available assay:http://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMc1113044#t=article
Vicetrailia
Banned
His argument is to blame the woman for everything. Wow typical. Maybe the male should have exercised better seeding judgment.
Options make our life better, we shall have them.
Often times the woman wants the baby over the impregnating male anyway. But regardless, a woman's body, a woman's choice.
Options make our life better, we shall have them.
Often times the woman wants the baby over the impregnating male anyway. But regardless, a woman's body, a woman's choice.
This, all of this. It was already known that this is what they thought, but still astonishing to actually have one of them outright admit to regarding women as incubators rather than people.
PedroPanache
Member
Ever since that iconic X-Files episode back in the day, I've been somewhat uncomfortable with the use of the word 'host', especially in this context.
So, yeah, crazy republican dude, this is what you're effectively reducing women to.
So, yeah, crazy republican dude, this is what you're effectively reducing women to.
- Status