Fantasy booking AJ vs. Paige:
Paige comes in with Saraya as the obnoxious stage mom, pushing Paige, and Paige as the anti diva, making them heels.
They align with AJ, and become a stable, and destroy all the divas.
Eventually though, Paige will have to turn face. There's no way she doesn't get over as a face, so you better have an exit plan. So have a story where Paige loses a few matches. This sets up a story where Saraya dumps her own daughter for AJ because AJ "has the grit to be the champ" and Paige doesn't. Saraya starts acting like AJ is her daughter instead of Paige.