• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Bale Batman vs Affleck Batman

Bale Batman vs Affleck Batman

  • Total voters
    75
Airbus Jr

Airbus Jr

Banned
Lets settle this once and for all

Whos gona win between these two?

Hand to hand combat only, no weapons or gadgets allowed

images


images
 
Affleck Batman seems more brutal and seems to not give a shit about injuring or killing his opponent so that might give him an edge.

Then again Bale batman is secretly a force user and can hit people without touching them:
de2091a2-b90a-4c78-b04e-f8535bd5115a.gif



So I say it's going to be pretty close
 
Last edited:
They both sucked.

But if I had to pick I'd pick Affleck batman just because bale batman got on my nerves with his bat voice and as bruce his acting was stiff as a board. Honestly fucking val Kilmer was a more entertaining batman than bale.
 
Fbh said:
Affleck Batman seems more brutal and seems to not give a shit about injuring or killing his opponent so that might give him an edge.

Then again Bale batman is secretly a force user and can hit people without touching them:
de2091a2-b90a-4c78-b04e-f8535bd5115a.gif



So I say it's going to be pretty close
Click to expand...
giphy.gif
 
Bale is better. Affleck is great too but we haven't seen him in the role enough. He could have been very good in a solo Batman movie. I'm not sure who would win in a fight.
 
Last edited:
I got bale not because he's better but because of the Joker and more importantly the world building in the 3 movies, Affleck thinks he's gods gift to Hollywood and now we know his version of Batman didn't work.
 
Where's my Keaton?

If I had to choose I choose bale only because he had a better arc during his movies.

I liked the general look of Affleck better tho.
 
This was about a FIGHT between Affleck Batman and Bale Batman...

Not which had a better story or who acted the part better.

A FIGHT!

Y'all KNOW Batfleck would destroy the Bale Batman in a one on one fight!
 
DeafTourette said:
This was about a FIGHT between Affleck Batman and Bale Batman...

Not which had a better story or who acted the part better.

A FIGHT!

Y'all KNOW Batfleck would destroy the Bale Batman in a one on one fight!
Click to expand...

But is he ready to fight with the real deal?

tenor.gif
 
Last edited:
I kind of like Batfleck with his no-nonsense ass kicking. Then again I'm that weird minority that didn't think the Nolan films were all that they were cracked up to be (plot holes the size of small moons throughout).
 
The one triumph of Affleck/Snyder Batman is they nailed the physicality of what I imagine Batman to be. Nolan nailed the mental thing but his action was always just ok. Affleck could probably beat up Bale he's a much bigger guy. Plus he's from Boston, zero chance he hasn't been in fights. But then Bale is a crazy dude with mad dedication.
 
Last edited:
highrider said:
The one triumph of Affleck/Snyder Batman is they nailed the physicality of what I imagine Batman to be. Nolan nailed the mental thing but his action was always just ok. Affleck could probably beat up Bale he's a much bigger guy. Plus he's from Boston, zero chance he hasn't been in fights. But then Bale is a crazy dude with mad dedication.
Click to expand...

Imo Afleck Batman could beat Bane in the first encounter

In BvS he can easily smash through a thick wall to grab the guy holding a gun from behind in the Martha rescue mission

Hes deff way more powerfull than Dark Knight Batman
 
Swole Batman would win, but Keaton Batman would strap a bomb to him when he wasn't looking.

I actually really miss Batfleck. :(
 
This is a hard one because both were very good.
I even feel that Ben Affleck had more potential than Bale.
 
I would say Bale. Even though his Batman voice isn't the best, he still convincing that hes Bruce Wayne. Ben Afflect face is kinda weird...doesn't seems to fit the character well.
 
I feel the OP wasn't effective enough to state what he said ... People still acting like he said "who played Batman better"

*Sigh*
 
Last edited:
Let's be real. Nic Cage should've been the Batman we all desire.

oYPOxe6.jpg

Amazon.com: Reawoo Custom Black and White Funny Nicolas Cage Pillowcase Soft Nap Pillow Cover Protecter with Zipper 20x30 Inches: Home & Kitchen

Buy Reawoo Custom Black and White Funny Nicolas Cage Pillowcase Soft Nap Pillow Cover Protecter with Zipper 20x30 Inches: Throw Pillow Covers - Amazon.com ✓ FREE DELIVERY possible on eligible purchases
www.amazon.com

JTQyNAy.jpg

Amazon.com: Rechzng Li Nicolas Cage Square Pillowcase Both Sides Print Zipper Throw Pillows Covers 18x18 Inches : Home & Kitchen

Buy Rechzng Li Nicolas Cage Square Pillowcase Both Sides Print Zipper Throw Pillows Covers 18x18 Inches: Throw Pillow Covers - Amazon.com ✓ FREE DELIVERY possible on eligible purchases
www.amazon.com

hBScoWD.jpg

Amazon.com: SKCASE Nicolas Cage Pillow Cases 18x18 inch Cushion Case (Two sides) : Home & Kitchen

Buy SKCASE Nicolas Cage Pillow Cases 18x18 inch Cushion Case (Two sides): Throw Pillow Covers - Amazon.com ✓ FREE DELIVERY possible on eligible purchases
www.amazon.com
 
There's no contest in terms of who's better, but in a fight? Yeah... probably Affleck's. But he was built for a more fantastical world, and to stand amongst (or even above) practical fucking gods on Earth.

I think Jake Gyllenhaal was shortlisted for the Dark Knight trilogy, and for the upcoming The Batman. That's my favorite actor right there.
Probably for the best he's not in The Batman though, Matt Reeves fucking sucks.
 
Ben A fleck is Daredevil, Gigili. Also took part in Pearl Harbor, therefor he is bad. He is overrated, not a good accountant at all, only knows how to whine or run. He no gud Betman is.

FOR FUCK SAKES. ... he didnt even bother to shave for his Bruce "i dont give a wet fuck about shaving today" Wayne scenes. ALSO Batman does not kill his enemies.

Easy win for Bale, even if his voice as Batman aint anythign to brag about.
 
onehitflunder said:
Ben A fleck is Daredevil, Gigili. Also took part in Pearl Harbor, therefor he is bad. He is overrated, not a good accountant at all, only knows how to whine or run. He no gud Betman is.

FOR FUCK SAKES. ... he didnt even bother to shave for his Bruce "i dont give a wet fuck about shaving today" Wayne scenes. ALSO Batman does not kill his enemies.

Easy win for Bale, even if his voice as Batman aint anythign to brag about.
Click to expand...

Once again just like someone on top already mentioned

This match isnt about the actors role in their previous movies or acting but fighting abilitities
 
Last edited:
Aflecks design is better, but worse movies. The warehouse scene is the only fistfight in the entire movie series I actually thought was well choreographed.
 
I'm pretty sure Affleck Batman straight up killed people so my vote goes to him.

Affleck Batman isn't afraid of guns, brands criminals like a sociopath and killed Superman just because he felt Superman was too powerful.
 
Monsterkillah said:
Once again just like someone on top already mentioned

This match isnt about the actors role in their previous movies or acting but fighting abilitities
Click to expand...

They ain't hearing us... The title should have been "Which Batman would win in a fight?"... But I feel the comments would STILL be the same about acting and story. Smh
 
I wish I could change my vote. Affleck would win.

Affleck Batman is way superior from what we saw in the movies. Bale Batman obviously has the better movies but his physical feats were pretty grounded (just as Nolan wanted).
 
A.Romero said:
I wish I could change my vote. Affleck would win.

Affleck Batman is way superior from what we saw in the movies. Bale Batman obviously has the better movies but his physical feats were pretty grounded (just as Nolan wanted).
Click to expand...


You can...
lBrAhau.jpg

7lrGPc7.jpg


7lrGPc7.jpg
 
Last edited:
Great video for this showdown . This guys videos are great but he's disappeared . He does these showdown videos and uses science to determine the outcome .


If you don't want to watch , Affleck's Batman is considerably stronger and faster than Bale's Batman, he's much closer to what the comic book is . The strength he was hitting people in that warehouse scene was inhuman , while Bale's Batman couldn't even beat a venom-less Bane .
 
Affleck Batman is bigger than Bale Batman but he has a very weak mind. The only possible explanation, in movie, for him to not kill Superman at that Martha scene is that he has huge mental problems. It was the most stupid thing I ever saw a iteration of Batman do.

Batman is not only brawl. I would expect Bale Batman to take advantage of Affleck Batman mental disorder, even in a fist fight and it is not like Bale Batman don't have any strength.
 
Belmonte said:
Affleck Batman is bigger than Bale Batman but he has a very weak mind. The only possible explanation, in movie, for him to not kill Superman at that Martha scene is that he has huge mental problems. It was the most stupid thing I ever saw a iteration of Batman do.

Batman is not only brawl. I would expect Bale Batman to take advantage of Affleck Batman mental disorder, even in a fist fight and it is not like Bale Batman don't have any strength.
Click to expand...

All i can say is...thank god it wasnt Bale Batman theyre using in Justice League....

Batman will look short next to Gal Gadot Wonder Woman and Jason Momoa Aquaman😂😂😂😂
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Scarlett Johansson in talks to join The Batman: Part II
2
50
753
DKehoe replied
Matt Damon & Ben Affleck on Rogan
2
52
857
Toots replied
  • Poll
Aztec Batman Trailer (Because only Batman gets to have all of the fun adaptations)
8
519
Toots replied
DCU Batman movie to be written by Christina Hodson (Birds of Prey, The Flash, Batgirl)
2 3
123
782
KyoZz replied
Madden | Official Teaser | Starring Nicolas Cage and Christian Bale
6
266
Unknown? replied
Top Bottom