Thanks for complimenting my acting skills. I'm really glad I was able to convince the whole world I was friends with that guy.
Also remind me to never again have fun with flavor, people take me too seriously here
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Batman [Mafia] |OT| The mafia game Gafia deserves , but not the one it needs
- Thread starter roytheone
- Start date
Thanks for complimenting my acting skills. I'm really glad I was able to convince the whole world I was friends with that guy.
The fact that you are still alive tells me you are lying or your night actions haven't mattered anyway so I doubt it's a huge deal, just advice for future games.
Xamtheking
Member
Well, flavor can be a pretty big thing.
For example, role playing as someone before claiming can lead to people believing you more because they might feel you had some tangible flavor to go off of.
CornBurrito
Member
Xam has a 100% win record though.
I didn't know you were confirmed scum.
Well one of you probably is. I've believed Launch for this long.
CornBurrito
Member
Yesterday you said he was just about.
Unless Launch is lying, either you or Coppa have to be scum. Or neutral. But our neutral player just left the game yesterday.
Meaning you or coppa have to be scum. Or both.
If you have access to your own role PM, you know your alignment. If you aren't scum.... hmm...
I wouldn't be against a turbo on Coppa if the rest agrees. I've already laid out why I think he should be lynched today.
This would also be nice to look back at after the flip.
Don't get me wrong, I've been quite certain that Coppa was scum for a while. That doesn't mean he was confirmed scum though
CornBurrito
Member
hmm...
Vote: Ty4on
Something just doesn't sit right with me about you Ty. Playing coy with the "oh when did Coppa become confirmed scum" and then going "yeah we could turbo Coppa."
You're being non-committal while trying to sound committal.
Vote: Ty4on
Something just doesn't sit right with me about you Ty. Playing coy with the "oh when did Coppa become confirmed scum" and then going "yeah we could turbo Coppa."
You're being non-committal while trying to sound committal.
lol
I'm having fun with Coppa because it sounded like he accidentally revealed to be scum. He said I should know he was scum which I obviously don't. Nothing has confirmed Launch yet. The only reason I trust Launch is because I town read him.
CornBurrito
Member
You cannot improve as a person until you learn to throw trust away.
Vote for Launch. His scum list gambit has come to an end. He's clearly lying.
You're right, you don't know it 100%, but the alternative to you thinking I'm scum is thinking launch is lying. Now, that's entirely possible but he would have to be scum to be carrying on a gambit this long, and I'm not sure I believe he would come up with that after joining midgame.
Nah. Trust is what I do best. I fail the most when I stop trusting people and am not accepting new input to improve my read of the situation. Sure, you should take everything with a grain of salt, but if you distrust everyone you can explain away almost anything and nothing makes sense anymore. There has to be a cutoff, that cutoff is how Launch acted when he revealed all of that. After El Topo flipped we now know scum had zero communication and Launch was a new replacement, yet he still remained active in the thread drip feeding information about his role to achieve his goal.
And, just in general, the way Launch behaved that especially day seemed genuinely townie to me.
Xamtheking
Member
CORNBURRITO IS YOUR MAN
Considering Corn seems to have had a meltdown and is now wildly pointing fingers at anyone with a pulse for unknown reasons, I have no arguments.
I was planning for you or Coppa if the other didn't flip scum or Corn if we did hit scum. I doubt there are objections.
Xamtheking
Member
CornBurrito
Member
Xamtheking
Member
Don't admit defeat Corn
Just
Don't post and let the wave of fire consume your mortal vessel
CornBurrito
Member
If I'm being honest, I think there might be 4 scum and I'm panicking right now. If there are 4 scum we already lost, unless one of you is having an override or day kill power or literally anything. In which case use it on fucking Sorian, PLEASE.
Xamtheking
Member
I'm actually Jason Todd and Camjo should have been modkilled weeks ago
Why does scum keep coming back for me :/ I'm apparently not an easy person to lynch.
Xamtheking
Member
You should totally kill Launch if Coppa flips town, but I can see why you'd think that way
I'm not really scum reading him. Not that I have much of a read on him.
It's a silly thing to do as scum though. They're still in the lead and just need to keep their cool.
----------------------
Honest question Xam, do you town read Sorian? I still read him as scum.
Xamtheking
Member
I town read Sorian out the ass, yeah.You should totally kill Launch if Coppa flips town, but I can see why you'd think that way
I'm not really scum reading him. Not that I have much of a read on him.
It's a silly thing to do as scum though. They're still in the lead and just need to keep their cool.
----------------------
Honest question Xam, do you town read Sorian? I still read him as scum.
I don't think he's scum.
CornBurrito I think is scum because he is trying everything he can to switch the target off of Coppanuva and onto people like me
Why? Maybe if people were leaning against Sorian or me, but it isn't looking that way. Scum is still in the lead after losing Coppa so they'd have to be really greedy if they want to save him.
Xamtheking
Member
We lynch coppa today
Sorian kills ScumBurrito tonight
Scum has one left and it becomes very apparent
Hmm, I can maybe see that if Sorian is town. Weird that they didn't poison Sorian again if that were the case.
Xamtheking
Member
Maybe it's only once per person as a balance mechanic
CornBurrito
Member
It might be because I joined the game late as a replacement, but I really just don't see how people could go for a Coppa lynch when Sorian is right here in front of us.
Sorian is someone I confidently scum read. Coppa in constrast... well idk. Dude has barely been around since I've been here. What do I have to scum read him with? His presence on Launch's list? That's not enough. Ty is on that list too. And then that assumes Launch is town and not lying. That's two layers of ifs, compared to Sorian's one.
Xamtheking
Member
There is a very easy reason why we would go after Coppa
We know Coppa has moved
That's right and his claim came very late. Sorian also has a sketchy claim, but he didn't do it by necessity (Kark's roleblock didn't confirm that he had a role) and gave us flavor right away.
Coppa was busy, but I still find it weird Trigger revealed seeing him, night, he kinda claimed (don't wanna say everything) even though almost every role had claimed at the time and then some time after that he finally claimed sleepwalker. After someone asked him he gave away the fluff as well.
CornBurrito
Member
With no ill effect on anyone though if I remember correctly.
His behavior all of yesterday.
And compare how he was yesterday to how he was today. Dude was in panic mode yesterday and today is all calm. Exactly what I'd expect for scum if they are this close to winning.
Better question: What part of his panicking was scummy to you? To me it's totally reasonable to be fighting back hard as town when you're in presumed Mylo or close to it.
I'd suggest reading up on the lynch of Kark D3 and his earlier encounter with Kark on D2 regarding Camjo. I think he was scummy in his poor reasoning for lynching Kark, but his discussion with Kark about Camjo seemed out of place for a scum.
I'd suggest reading up on the lynch of Kark D3 and his earlier encounter with Kark on D2 regarding Camjo. I think he was scummy in his poor reasoning for lynching Kark, but his discussion with Kark about Camjo seemed out of place for a scum.
I checked out when our town tracker tied the vote, great that I didn't die but terrible for the WIFOM and figuring out who is scum and who isn't. I get to kill someone tonight and it'll probably be scum so that's the silver lining but we are still going uphill I think.
Oh, I didn't see what Corn was saying, carry on.
Nah, I'm with you there. I felt the same when that happened.
It was a little bit like reaching the boss after a ton of effort and then the game reset/crashed. You don't feel like putting the same amount of effort the next time.
CornBurrito
Member
We werent in LYLO yesterday though.
Xamtheking
Member
We can still pull this off
You might have priority
CornBurrito
Member
You Can (Not) Win
I have no doubt that my kill will go off even if they try to kill me since that's how night kills work. I just feel like there's more going on if they didn't bother killing me or blocking me again. I'm really worried that it's 4 scum and they have half the vote right now.
CornBurrito
Member
Especially if you lynch me or kill me, because I'm town ffs.
Xam stop tunneling on me. Sorian is scum. Ty is scum. Coppa is scum.
Xam stop tunneling on me. Sorian is scum. Ty is scum. Coppa is scum.
Xamtheking
Member
No, I mean you might be able to stop a kill like how I had priority
Oh, you would have never stopped a kill. Kills happen simultaneously. You were just "first" because if it came down to you and one other killer, you won.